@Dutch_Tooler said:
Re retention, I'd tend to agree magnetic might not be for everyone (magnetic cards are definitely at risk - heck, my phone, that does not contain magnetic mounts, scrambles these) so some form of spring retention would be the alternative in order to reach a larger user population.
I hear you regarding the extra space required. However, Vic's solution with a sprung retention ball in the bit provides for a space-saving solution. Would that be an option? As an alternative I think one could also design the holder to have a spring...
Do you have pics of what you are intending to build?
I assume that is why Victoinox use that system. The cost and number of available bits is the main issue there.
It is certainly possible to have a spring in the holder, but most convential methods take a fair bit of extra space. And space for any- and everything is at a premium, and at this stage of the process within quite defined limits.
I have a few ideas that might be simply enough to implement though. I'll do a few experiments to see if any of those can provide a proper overall holding solution.
I do have both pics and a range of prototypes. I would have loved to discuss pretty much everything openly, but patent and design protection requies no previous publication. There is also the balance of getting feedback versus giving competitors and copycats a headstart at certain features. The quality of the feedback would improve with more given information so having those limitations are quite frustrating at times. I will certainly be happy to show when I'm far enough along that those issues are mostly gone. I look forward to that day!
@gerleatherberman said:
I appreciate your consideration of everyone's input. Can't wait to see what you come up with, Vidar.
I truly appreciate everyone's feedback! Making everyone happy with one particular design is impossible, but getting a broader and better view through many really helps when making the priorities and balances necessary. Even more so for a multitool with its many uses and concerns. So thanks for that!