The Terrific $20 Challenge!!!!
-
@Mercury said:
You guys are terrible!I am heading into town in a few days to find my last candidate for this challenge, that is, unless something on Ebay wins me over first....
You could always grab the Irwin vise grips multitool from lowes, it's 19.98. They look like a horrible idea, but actually function pretty well.
-
The final contender is on it's way to me! ETA Friday evening.
-
The last prize arrived yesterday! This one's a sweet Vic Silvertech huntsman. It's in really good shape, just a bit gunky from pocket carry and being used to cut tape. Toothpick and tweezers are present, but the pin is missing. All in all, it's an awesome knife, scored for just under $20 shipped to my door!

-
@Mercury said:
The last prize arrived yesterday! This one's a sweet Vic Silvertech huntsman. It's in really good shape, just a bit gunky from pocket carry and being used to cut tape. Toothpick and tweezers are present, but the pin is missing. All in all, it's an awesome knife, scored for just under $20 shipped to my door!
Love those Silvertech scales.
-
The last prize arrived yesterday! This one's a sweet Vic Silvertech huntsman. It's in really good shape, just a bit gunky from pocket carry and being used to cut tape. Toothpick and tweezers are present, but the pin is missing. All in all, it's an awesome knife, scored for just under $20 shipped to my door!

Love those Silvertech scales.
Me too! Makes me want to order a set for my explorer...
-
The last prize arrived yesterday! This one's a sweet Vic Silvertech huntsman. It's in really good shape, just a bit gunky from pocket carry and being used to cut tape. Toothpick and tweezers are present, but the pin is missing. All in all, it's an awesome knife, scored for just under $20 shipped to my door!

Love those Silvertech scales.
Me too! Makes me want to order a set for my explorer...
I have 2 Climbers with them. I wonder how cool they'd look on a Swisschamp :D
-
The last prize arrived yesterday! This one's a sweet Vic Silvertech huntsman. It's in really good shape, just a bit gunky from pocket carry and being used to cut tape. Toothpick and tweezers are present, but the pin is missing. All in all, it's an awesome knife, scored for just under $20 shipped to my door!

Love those Silvertech scales.
Me too! Makes me want to order a set for my explorer...
I have 2 Climbers with them. I wonder how cool they'd look on a Swisschamp :D
Bet they'd look sweet! Ok, now I'm itching for some silver tech scales. Anyone know a good place to get them? Felinevet doesn't have them in his store.
-
Sooooo do we have a winner? I'm not sure!
Here's the list of contenders I bought for this challenge:
Vic Executive
LM Squirt P4
LM Squirt PS4
Wenger Mountain Bike
Victorinox Silver Tech HuntsmanAs far as functionality goes, it's a real toss up. The Mountain bike has the most function, but it's also the heaviest and for me, it wouldn't make it into my regular rotation simply because half the tool is dedicated to mountain biking, the rest I can get in a SAK that's half the size. I guess the P4 and PS4 come next, as they have pliers, drivers, and blades, but the PS4 wins out with the scissors. Purely on nostalgia and form I'd pick the P4. BUT, since buying the Vic Executive the for the first contender, I've bought one of my own and carried it every day and I love it. It even ousted my minichamp out of my pocket because it sits better next to my wallet. Form wins out again, and since it has the blades, scissors, nailfile, and tweezers, it sees more regular use than my Leatherman does.
The Huntsman was the best value I think, seeing as a Silvertech goes for twice the price new and it's pretty sweet. The only thing is, I've never liked the Huntsman pattern all that much, because I don't use the saw on a SAK enough to warrant the extra bulk. I choose my explorer if I want a 4 layer SAK.
My favorite on this list is clearly the Executive, followed by the P4. What are your opinions?
-
I vote the wenger, since it it's the most interesting tool that you purchased :)
-
Can't wait to see which one wins. Thank you for taking the time to do this bud.

If you wan't to get rid of the Wenger after the challenge is done let me know.

-
No worries, it was a ton of fun!
As for the fate of the contenders, that's up to Grant as it was his cash that paid for them. (I'm kinda partial to the blue P4... :D)
I'm still not sure as to which one wins, but I'm inclined to say the Wenger, because it's both an oddball and it appears that it's at least double the price I paid for it. If there are no objections, we can make it official!
-
@Mercury said:
I'm still not sure as to which one wins, but I'm inclined to say the Wenger, because it's both an oddball and it appears that it's at least double the price I paid for it. If there are no objections, we can make it official!What, your not going to do anything with them? These tools at least deserve an arbitrary test before you declare a winner, to make sure they all work and... stuff...
Also, should that huntsman suddenly break (or not) I'll happily take it off your hands... I'll even let you keep the scales
-
I'm still not sure as to which one wins, but I'm inclined to say the Wenger, because it's both an oddball and it appears that it's at least double the price I paid for it. If there are no objections, we can make it official!
What, your not going to do anything with them? These tools at least deserve an arbitrary test before you declare a winner, to make sure they all work and... stuff...
Also, should that huntsman suddenly break (or not) I'll happily take it off your hands... I'll even let you keep the scales
As much as I would love to do a test for each, I'm pretty sure that would take a good while! I am a tad curious as to how useful the Wenger would be, I actually found myself needing a tool to remove a chain from a motor on a Towel folder at work, and the Wenger has one.
Yea, those silver tech scales are
I want a set for my explorer. 
-
Well folks, the time has come to see if we can resell these tools, and what they go for. I have listed them all on Ebay, at modest starting prices. I'm a tad late in linking them here, so please forgive me. One tool has already sold, the Wenger Mountain Bike, and it went for $26.
Here are the links so you all can follow the progress.
-
Awesome!
I'm looking forward to watching these progress!
Def
-
Well, three more of the items have sold!
The Executive went for $7.99, the Squirt PS4 went for $11.45, and the Squirt P4 went for $9.50. All of these are lower than we paid, which is disappointing. Such is my luck on Ebay!
The Huntsman didn't sell, I just relisted it. There was interest, so we'll see if it goes this time. Stay tuned!
-
@Mercury said:
Well, three more of the items have sold!The Executive went for $7.99, the Squirt PS4 went for $11.45, and the Squirt P4 went for $9.50. All of these are lower than we paid, which is disappointing. Such is my luck on Ebay!
The Huntsman didn't sell, I just relisted it. There was interest, so we'll see if it goes this time. Stay tuned!
That may be my bad. I watched it to see how it did...
-
Damn, I wanted the Wenger.
-
Sorry Cap! When I went to list them, I totally forgot you had told me that.
-
No worries bud.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login