Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
I would really like a database that is similar to the pen one, but with fields that pertain to knives. That is why I am not being successful with the pen one, and have been mainly putting data into Excel. I really prefer a database though and especially one that allows photos to be added.
I think you're on to something there with a topic starter!
-
If the rear stamp is "Inoxyd" then it's from the same time period. Most likely it is. If the rear stamp is "Victorinox" through a crossbow, it's a little older (early 40s).
@FolderBeholder said:
Thank you all for your help.
This one is inbound as well. I guess from the same time period. I decided to buy it since that way I'll have an 84mm and then this one a 91mm.

-
-
Fairly sure that's an Inoxyd knife too. If so, then same time period, c. 1944-1946.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
I would really like a database that is similar to the pen one, but with fields that pertain to knives. That is why I am not being successful with the pen one, and have been mainly putting data into Excel. I really prefer a database though and especially one that allows photos to be added.
I think you're on to something there with a topic starter!
l think you could do all this (including photos) with Google Sheets. That also provides hosting for the database if you want to make it publicly accessible.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Thank you all for your help.
This one is inbound as well. I guess from the same time period. I decided to buy it since that way I'll have an 84mm and then this one a 91mm.

You are building up a nice collection of vintage VICS!

-
I would really like a database that is similar to the pen one, but with fields that pertain to knives. That is why I am not being successful with the pen one, and have been mainly putting data into Excel. I really prefer a database though and especially one that allows photos to be added.
I think you're on to something there with a topic starter!
l think you could do all this (including photos) with Google Sheets. That also provides hosting for the database if you want to make it publicly accessible.
Thank you, I will look into that program.
-
I have a few questions about the vintage models.
I might be obsessing over minor details, but I imagine there are many here that love the minor details- I saw a 134k on this thread that had the 1946 can opener and recently saw another on eBay. All the reference materials I have found show the modern can opener being introduced in 1951 and the Phillips in 1952. I understand transition times, but considering how few visible rivets knives I have seen with the Phillips yet I have seen at least 2 with the 1946 can opener, I am wondering if the 1946 can opener persisted for longer on the 84's.
Note: the eBay knife was listed as 91 but it was clearly 84 - in regards to the old numbering system, I understand the 3 digit code. However I can't seem to find much information on the leading digit when a 4 digit code is given. It appears the 2xxx refers to the Alox knives. I have also seen 1xxx and 8xxx but do not understand the distinction between them. For example what is the model number in the below knife of mine? It is a Hoffritz Victoria stamped knife. Is it a 234U 8234U or 1234U?
- what is the difference between a 205 and a 234?

- I saw a 134k on this thread that had the 1946 can opener and recently saw another on eBay. All the reference materials I have found show the modern can opener being introduced in 1951 and the Phillips in 1952. I understand transition times, but considering how few visible rivets knives I have seen with the Phillips yet I have seen at least 2 with the 1946 can opener, I am wondering if the 1946 can opener persisted for longer on the 84's.
-
- I saw a 134k on this thread that had the 1946 can opener and recently saw another on eBay. All the reference materials I have found show the modern can opener being introduced in 1951 and the Phillips in 1952. I understand transition times, but considering how few visible rivets knives I have seen with the Phillips yet I have seen at least 2 with the 1946 can opener, I am wondering if the 1946 can opener persisted for longer on the 84's.
Note: the eBay knife was listed as 91 but it was clearly 84
The Phillips back-spring tool definitely appears in the 84mm line first on models with the 1946 can opener. I've seen way too many knives with both to think that it's a factory goof, a one-off, or a later mod. So there are two conclusions: the official date is wrong and the Phillips was introduced earlier, or the 1946 can opener persisted longer for 84mm. I actually believe the answer is both. I think the official date is a little off and the Phillips was introduced c. 1950. BTW, this is actually somewhat common - many of the official dates from Victorinox don't match up with what you see with actual knives. I also believe that the 84mm line used older can openers/cap lifters a bit past 1952.
@Forklift said:
2) in regards to the old numbering system, I understand the 3 digit code. However I can't seem to find much information on the leading digit when a 4 digit code is given. It appears the 2xxx refers to the Alox knives. I have also seen 1xxx and 8xxx but do not understand the distinction between them. For example what is the model number in the below knife of mine? It is a Hoffritz Victoria stamped knife. Is it a 234U 8234U or 1234U?The standard early numbering system was 3 numbers. A leading "1" indicated it was a cellidor handled "Elinox" line knife. So, a "Victoria" line Spartan w/ bail at the time would be a 234U, and an "Elinox" line spartan would be a 1234U. A leading "2" indicated it was an alox handled Elinox knife. There's very little overlap between cellidor "Victoria" line numbers and alox numbers mainly because most of the models were different. The one case were there was the same basic model in both cellidor and alox (The Voyegeur), they did actually have the same base model number - 232 (232k and 2232).
A leading "5", "7", or "8" typically indicated a "special" model - something with tools not part of the standard "Victoria" line (e.g. fine screwdriver, pruner blade, serrated main blade). The Picnicker, for example, is basically a Camper with a serrated main blade and pruner instead of pen blade. It was a model 8237aU, whereas the Camper was a model 237aU. The Handwerkermesser (model 7236maU) was just a Ranger (model 236maU) with a fine screwdriver instead of a pen blade. There really isn't a logical system with these either - for example the Motorist was a 8134ma, the Picknicker was a 8237aU, but the Handwerkermesser was a 7236maU. Why the "7" instead of "8"? All knives were "special" models, all were originally Elinox models, etc. But one started with 7 and the other 8.
Your knife below is a 1234U (Elinox line Spartan) made for Hoffritz. All Hoffritz knives in the early days got special "Hoffrtiz/Victoria" stamped blades, regardless if they were "Victoria" line or "Elinox" line models. So if Hoffritz ordered an economy Elinox line knife, they got the same knife anyone buying an Elinox knife at that time got - unpolished tools, unanodized liners, etc. The only difference is the blade was stamped "Hoffritz/Victoria" instead of "Elinox".
@Forklift said:
3) what is the difference between a 205 and a 234?Same knife, just a minor change in the knife numbering system. Seems to have happened sometime in the mid- to late- 1940s. 205 is the original number of the knife most call a Spartan today. 234 is the number you see on boxes and in ads in the early 1950s until the change in 1974. In fact, earlier in this thread I told FolderBeholder her knife was a 205k, since it was older (pre-1946) and 84mm instead of 91mm (k for kleine). It looks like this might be a mistake - the real number is actually 206 if we're being pedantic about the old model numbers. If you look in the 1942 catalog (below), Victorinox is definitely using the same model number between 91mm and 84mm for the same knives (the 248 and 248k, for example), except for the Spartan/Tourist models which still have their original 205/206 numbers, respectively. By the early 1950s they have updated both of these to be more inline with the others (234 and 234k).

- I saw a 134k on this thread that had the 1946 can opener and recently saw another on eBay. All the reference materials I have found show the modern can opener being introduced in 1951 and the Phillips in 1952. I understand transition times, but considering how few visible rivets knives I have seen with the Phillips yet I have seen at least 2 with the 1946 can opener, I am wondering if the 1946 can opener persisted for longer on the 84's.
-
Pulled a few recent vintage ones out of the knife roll....I have others I just can't find them.

Shown are a Victoria Champion, two Fisherman, an Original Outdoorsman, a Climber and Armee Suisse 84mm Tourist and a Spartan/Standard in 91mm.

-
Thx guys!!!!
Found another one....
Fisherman Deluxe.

And you guys already saw this one.
Wenger '60 Soldat

-
Thanks jazzbass! Excellent answers
-
-
Pulled a few recent vintage ones out of the knife roll....I have others I just can't find them.

Shown are a Victoria Champion, two Fisherman, an Original Outdoorsman, a Climber and Armee Suisse 84mm Tourist and a Spartan/Standard in 91mm.


Thx FB!!!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
