New SOG Fish On Knife
-
I don't suppose anyone at SOG has mentioned whether their themed knives sell competitively with their regular budget fusion series?
I suppose they wouldn't keep making them if they weren't profitable, but it seems odd to (and here's a brand new turn of phrase I intend to abuse at the next executive committee meeting!) "niche without speSmurfpillsing"
which is to say - appeal to a certain market, without actually making something that is especially useful to them (Actually, I guess it is pretty normal. Like Simpsons apparel - it doesn't actually help you watch TV, but lots of simpson-watching people buy it)
-
I think Sog should have stopped with the Kilowatt knife. That was actually a good design and functional for electricians but their other theme knives seem to be nothing more than novelties for collecting, not really useful IMO. Sure there's a blade but other than that the handles are just too busy to be comfortable, no ergonomics. I've worked as a carpenter and can think of a dozen knives I'd rather use than their "contractor 2X4". It doesn't even come with a proper sharpener for the flat contractor pencils.
-
@Nutznboltz said:
I think Sog should have stopped with the Kilowatt knife. That was actually a good design and functional for electricians but their other theme knives seem to be nothing more than novelties for collecting, not really useful IMO. Sure there's a blade but other than that the handles are just too busy to be comfortable, no ergonomics. I've worked as a carpenter and can think of a dozen knives I'd rather use than their "contractor 2X4". It doesn't even come with a proper sharpener for the flat contractor pencils.I agree entirely. Gimmick knives like these just take away from SOG's reputation as a serious knife maker. It's like they have a 9 year old in charge of their design department or something. :P
-
I think Sog should have stopped with the Kilowatt knife. That was actually a good design and functional for electricians but their other theme knives seem to be nothing more than novelties for collecting, not really useful IMO. Sure there's a blade but other than that the handles are just too busy to be comfortable, no ergonomics. I've worked as a carpenter and can think of a dozen knives I'd rather use than their "contractor 2X4". It doesn't even come with a proper sharpener for the flat contractor pencils.
I agree entirely. Gimmick knives like these just take away from SOG's reputation as a serious knife maker. It's like they have a 9 year old in charge of their design department or something. :P
So Bob you have one on the way then
:D -
I think Sog should have stopped with the Kilowatt knife. That was actually a good design and functional for electricians but their other theme knives seem to be nothing more than novelties for collecting, not really useful IMO. Sure there's a blade but other than that the handles are just too busy to be comfortable, no ergonomics. I've worked as a carpenter and can think of a dozen knives I'd rather use than their "contractor 2X4". It doesn't even come with a proper sharpener for the flat contractor pencils.
I agree entirely. Gimmick knives like these just take away from SOG's reputation as a serious knife maker. It's like they have a 9 year old in charge of their design department or something. :P
So Bob you have one on the way then
:DAll they need to do is strap on a big ol' gaudy set of pliers to the side and I'm all over it buddy!

-
I think Sog should have stopped with the Kilowatt knife. That was actually a good design and functional for electricians but their other theme knives seem to be nothing more than novelties for collecting, not really useful IMO. Sure there's a blade but other than that the handles are just too busy to be comfortable, no ergonomics. I've worked as a carpenter and can think of a dozen knives I'd rather use than their "contractor 2X4". It doesn't even come with a proper sharpener for the flat contractor pencils.
I agree entirely. Gimmick knives like these just take away from SOG's reputation as a serious knife maker. It's like they have a 9 year old in charge of their design department or something. :P
So Bob you have one on the way then
:DAll they need to do is strap on a big ol' gaudy set of pliers to the side and I'm all over it buddy!

Silly of me Bob , I forgot even a knife with a bit exchanger & bottle opener (like E series LM knives ) aint a tool in Bob land :P :D. what if the SOG had a spring loaded net & a harpoon attachment would that get into "Club Bob" :P :D
-
[quote author=Nutznboltz link=topic=8762.msg162499#msg162499 date=1232772157]
I think Sog should have stopped with the Kilowatt knife. That was actually a good design and functional for electricians but their other theme knives seem to be nothing more than novelties for collecting, not really useful IMO. Sure there's a blade but other than that the handles are just too busy to be comfortable, no ergonomics. I've worked as a carpenter and can think of a dozen knives I'd rather use than their "contractor 2X4". It doesn't even come with a proper sharpener for the flat contractor pencils.I agree entirely. Gimmick knives like these just take away from SOG's reputation as a serious knife maker. It's like they have a 9 year old in charge of their design department or something. :P
So Bob you have one on the way then
:DAll they need to do is strap on a big ol' gaudy set of pliers to the side and I'm all over it buddy!

Silly of me Bob , I forgot even a knife with a bit exchanger & bottle opener (like E series LM knives ) aint a tool in Bob land :P :D. what if the SOG had a spring loaded net & a harpoon attachment would that get into "Club Bob" :P :D
[/quote]Club Bob has a rigorous set of criteria but I do believe that would qualify. :D
-
Well, I don't care what anyone sez. I think that this one is neat.
Dtrain
-
@Dtrain said:
Well, I don't care what anyone sez. I think that this one is neat.Dtrain
Do not mind me Dtrain I just paid for my Victorinox Autotool :o :D, I REALLY like unconventional MT's. If I liked knives as much as MT's I would be looking at these odd SOGs , maybe. I think the muscle car one was very unusual knife.
Silly of me Bob , I forgot even a knife with a bit exchanger & bottle opener (like E series LM knives ) aint a tool in Bob land :P :D. what if the SOG had a spring loaded net & a harpoon attachment would that get into "Club Bob" :P :D
[/quote]Club Bob has a rigorous set of criteria but I do believe that would qualify. :D
[/quote]:D :D :D I would like to see that criteria Bob :D
-
No issue at all. I do think that if a "Theme" knife, so to speak is done well with quality mamterials it can draw the casual user into the world of quality cutlery/multi-tools and away from the "$5.99" Iron Mongery.
Dtrain
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
