Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
@Huntsman said:
My date came from the SAAM's blog
So it looks like SAAM's is wrong - It has been wrong on lots of other items !!! :-[The situation with the (wrong) 1977 date for the backside fine screwdriver is actually more complicated, because the source of this isn't just SAAM's, but the "official Victorinox chronology" (as it appears in the document Everything you need to know about Multi-tools and cutlery and also in both the second edition and the third edition of the book by Derek Jackson). However, as Kamakiri correctly pointed out and JAZZBASS previously explained in detail, we very clearly see this fine screwdriver appearing along with the magnifying glass just before the end of the Victoria era. Hence, 1973 is probably the best year one can assign to it.
The piccie of the file certainly has a nail cleaner tip which it says came in in 75 - Or was that 73 too!!

Yes, 1973 is probably the best year to assign to this change of the file tip as well.
If so I can change in my spready
If you are going to change your "spready" you may want to also look at the 40 posts that accumulated in the relevant thread after you posted the last version and contain many suggested corrections. :D
-
@MiniChamp said:
......
Yes, 1973 is probably the best year to assign to this change of the file tip as well.If you are going to change your "speedy" you may want to also look at the 40 posts that accumulated in the relevant thread after you posted the last version and contain many suggested corrections. :DAs the third last of those 40 or so posts says .......
@Huntsman said:
.......
Give me a while to process it -
I think a couple of principles (that are already listed in the sheet) will stand:- The table is mainly for 91mm
- Dates are always estimates !!
To those I might add - That I will concentrate on visible/external changes - Eg: Some of the spring changes are very subtle!!
Having said that I will get it as accurate as possible - and also try to get as much into the chart as I can
So, surprise, surprise - We will have a version X !! ......And probably beyond !
..............All those 40 posts with their amazing level of detail and information and other stuff that has accumulated in the last year - is why it has not happened yet!!
(and SAKWiki and real life too of course)Backspring sd 1977 --> 1973 is easy !!
PS. It's a ***'spready' ***- ie spreadsheet - Not a *'speedy' *
-
@Huntsman said:
Ah OK - Thanks KMy date came from the SAAM's blog
So it looks like SAAM's is wrong - It has been wrong on lots of other items !!! :-[C'mon friends, SAAM created its wonderful site 10+ years ago, this site was one of the best at that time and yes, it used the existing dating at that time. I really like it so far. I recently asked him about corrections in some dates, but apparently he is busy with other things now. Anyway, thanks to him for his work.
-
Aha We finally find someone who knows Mr Saam - Brilliant I always assumed he had a secret identity!! 😳
I assume from the site that it is connected with vsakcs - right?Hey no-one is saying it’s not a great site and we don’t appreciate it - it is and we do - for many of us it was the starting point of our SAK collecting and dating journey
I refer to it in my dating spreadsheet thread and have pointed many people to the site - and I usually use the same adjective as you to describe it ie wonderful
But if it is wrong on some dates and we all collectively agree on that ...... What is wrong with calling that out? ???
As you say time has moved on and we know more. And also as we have mentioned SAK dating is as much an art as a science.Btw he did update the backspring Phillips dates within the last year or two - I noticed that!!
H -
@jnoxyd said:
C'mon friends, SAAM created its wonderful site 10+ years ago, this site was one of the best at that time and yes, it used the existing dating at that time. I really like it so far. I recently asked him about corrections in some dates, but apparently he is busy with other things now. Anyway, thanks to him for his work.I don't know SAAM, but to the best of my understanding, the site was created in October 2009 (just under 10 years ago) and its creation was discussed in this MTO thread. In spite of limited activity (about two weeks in the second half of October 2009 and three days in March 2014) this thread is still an important source of information about certain SAK evolution issues that I don't recall seeing discussed elsewhere (such as the removal of the 7.5cm mark from the fish scaler around 1987).
There is no doubt that SAAM's site is indeed "wonderful" in that it does a great job of presenting things very clearly. Unfortunately, it contains some inaccuracies and many tools have more natural variants (that can be used for dating) than what it shows. For me, this raises the following question: How can we get to the point of having something similarly nice, but better?

-
84mm


-
@MiniChamp said:
... this thread is still an important source of information about certain SAK evolution issues that I don't recall seeing discussed elsewhere..."That was my main point about this thread. From my first post here:
"NOTICE:
It would be so nice and most useful if you already made a topic with some vintage knives in the past that you include that link in your post here. Just to keep everything in one place and tidy. Also, when you do a post, please include some useful info if you know regarding that particular model (year of manufacture, model name, number etc.) or simply ask if you don't know and somebody will answer, for sure.As time goes by this topic could grow into a huge database of useful and much needed information about vintage SAKs if all of us put in some effort. That's my goal and general idea.
Thanks guys and gals." -
Champion with 39 teeth saw

Picture for MiniChamp ;) :

-
I certainly don't mean any disrespect for the SAAM's blog. It certainly was useful getting started with production evolution/chronology for me. It has a clear and easy to understand format. I just wish it was updated.
Very nice!
Recent acquisition?@jnoxyd said:
Champion with 39 teeth saw

Picture for MiniChamp ;) :

Nice knife! You should send me the Champion for, uh, metal saw cleaning. ;) :D -
[quote author=kamakiri link=
Nice knife! You should send me the Champion for, uh, metal saw cleaning. ;) :D
[/quote]Haha, thank you! What is your treatment for rust metal saw? Acid?
-
@jnoxyd said:
Haha, thank you! What is your treatment for rust metal saw? Acid?:D
Yes, as a last resort for anything that doesn't come off mechanically, I attack it chemically...whatever it is. The worst knives need to go back and forth between the two.
@M0rkoni said:
Thank you, no it's not recent. Its one of mine 84mm. I manage to grab it before some time and it's in an excellent condition.. I certainly looks excellent! Just curious. I'm trying hard not to expand my collecting to pre WWII era knives...but knives like yours make me reconsider!
-
Yes, as a last resort for anything that doesn't come off mechanically, I attack it chemically...whatever it is. The worst knives need to go back and forth between the two.
Can you say what acid/concentration/temperature or it is top secret? Once I tried ortophosforic acid low concentration and got nice deep patina [emoji51][emoji38]
-
@jnoxyd said:
Can you say what acid/concentration/temperature or it is top secret? Once I tried ortophosforic acid low concentration and got nice deep patina [emoji51][emoji38]Eesh. That's what I fear once I go chemical. I suspect you left it in too long?
The stronger treatments are TOP SECRET hush-hush. ;) The strongest need to be used only for spot treatment and immediately neutralized.
But the first thing I use if needed is just acetic/white vinegar at room temp. Even with that, I keep exposure brief. I try to do most of the cleaning mechanically, as it's 'safest' and easiest to control.
-
...this thread is still an important source of information about certain SAK evolution issues that I don't recall seeing discussed elsewhere...
That was my main point about this thread. From my first post here:
There seems to be some confusion here. I was writing about (and providing a link to) another thread, titled "Victorinox 91mm Tools Evolution," that was started in October 2009, discusses the formation of SAAM's site, and is available at this URL: /topic/14646
Of course, the current thread is also a great resource!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login