Day by Day...a Journey down the 91mm Range
-
Hi Max,
I just got caught up on your challenge this morning. Fantastic reading and highly enjoyable, and this from guy who's been collecting/accumulating VSAKs for 40 years.
What compelled me to reply, other than to offer my compliments and thanks, is this write up on the Traveller. I've resisted these non-traditional SAKs my whole life (e.g., the timekeeper, ick) but your mini-article has convinced me I need one. I'm a mechanical watch nerd, so I always know the time and don't want to have to rely on batteries for time-telling. However, I love knowing the temperature on a camping trip, and barometric and altitude data would just be fun to have as well. Finally, although I'm not a scuba diver, I usually will wear a dive watch on a camping trip because the timing bezel is so handy for things like cooking rice or oatmeal. However, sometimes I won't have a dive watch on and then you're really screwed for timing simple events.
Obviously the answer here is the Traveller! Your article convinced me, and I'll be buying one the next time Victorinox has a site-wide sale or promotion. Thanks again and congratulations on your amazing challenge. I suspect there are a lot of other people like me who are reading it and following along without leaving specific comments.
Myron
-
Thank you Myron for your encouragement, and you can’t go wrong with the Traveler for its extra functionality. I have the Traveler Lite too (will be reviewed later in the challenge) which may be an even better option as you get the LED and inline Phillips, if you’re OK with 4 layers.

-
Day 9
The next 3-layer SAK we tackle is the well-known Super Tinker. A most fitting name, with Victorinox adding scissors to the central layer of the classic Tinker design.
Effectively a Climber with a Phillips driver replacing the corkscrew, the Super Tinker is one of the more popular of the 3-layered SAKs in Vic’s 91mm range.
Arguably the more useful back tool, the Phillips cross tip is a decent size and will engage all but the smallest Phillips screw heads.
However, the problem is that the driver only extends 38mm (1.5in), and with the ‘T’-shaped deployment position, ergonomics are somewhat challenging. This back tool layout is fine to extract corks, but less than ideal for driving screws. This may partly explain why there are only six 91mm SAKs with it, compared to 22 with the corkscrew.
The Super Tinker is a little sleeker to carry compared to the Climber, as the Phillips tucks into the body of the SAK much better than the corkscrew. But then again, you cannot attach the mini screwdriver accessory as you can with the corkscrew.
There’s also something to be said about the ‘look’ of a SAK. In many ways, one with a corkscrew just looks nicer than the Phillips equivalent. Many may disagree or not consider this important, but there is a little more history and nostalgia with the corkscrew versions.
Pros:
- Phillips more useful than a corkscrew
- Excellent scissors
- Affordable pocket carry
Cons:
- Phillips can be awkward to use
- in-line Phillips Is better if you need this tool
Bottom line:
An extremely capable little SAK that sits right in the sweet spot of function, affordability and size. Does not have the same charm as the Climber, but probably the more sensible choice.



-
Another great day! Great photo’s!

-
Another great exposition on a great SAK variation.

However, regarding the "Pros", I am of the school that the corkscrew (and mini screwdriver) is more valuable (to me) than the philips, especially because the can opener "philips" actually has worked out quite well as a philips scewdriver for me when needed. I guess I drink more wine and tighten more mini screws than I do philips screws.
Keep up the good work! -
Great Day 9 pics and review Max!

-
Thanks Rapidray, Greg, VICMAN, jph_777.

-
Interesting pictures with the disassembled SAK layers.
-
Thanks smiller43147. Debating next build...

-
Super Tinker was my partners main carry for a while. Really great SAK.
-
Very good read here Max and thanks for entertaining us. I'm a corkscrew fan because that allows you the small nested screwdriver and for that reason I only have one Tinker in my collection. Climber it is for me. Keep up the good work with the Challenge !

-
I don't remember if I have written anything here but to be on the safe side.. Hi!
This is just awlsome reading and should be compressed to a guide later on
[It's not failure if you learn something from it]
-
Thanks kottskrapa, will be fun to wrap in all up at the end! And thanks Aloha, Fast Bill

Day 10
The last of the 3-layers in the current 91mm range is the Hiker, and really can be viewed as a Camper with a Phillips back tool instead of the corkscrew.
The Hiker brings a good alternative for those wanting a SAK with a wood saw for pocket carry when off the beaten track, but don’t see the need for a corkscrew.
Personally, I think there’s more chance of needing a corkscrew when you’re away from home and the kitchen draw, so it’s maybe a less convincing argument to marry the Phillips with the wood saw.
In days past, Victorinox had many more 91mm SAKs with the back Phillips, but they only added the wood saw to the 5- and 6-layer versions. The Hiker and it’s 4-layer saw/scissors Fieldmaster brother, are the only saw-equipped models in the current 91mm range with the back Phillips. All the 5- and 6-layer models are discontinued, so these two are your only options if you want this combination.
Pros:
- Great wood saw
- Small and lightweight
- Very affordable
Cons:
- You may miss the corkscrew, but maybe not
Bottom Line:
Like its Camper cousin, the Hiker is a great little SAK with an excellent wood saw. However, if you like the back Phillips and want a wood saw, you may want to also consider the Fieldmaster.(Apologies for reusing a pic used earlier today, the Hiker with a Yeoman mod).

-
@Max Stone said:
Thanks kottskrapa, will be fun to wrap in all up at the end! And thanks Aloha, Fast Bill
Day 10
The last of the 3-layers in the current 91mm range is the Hiker, and really can be viewed as a Camper with a Phillips back tool instead of the corkscrew.
The Hiker brings a good alternative for those wanting a SAK with a wood saw for pocket carry when off the beaten track, but don’t see the need for a corkscrew.
Nice finish to the 3 layer models Max!

Nice pics!

-
@Max Stone said:
Thanks kottskrapa, will be fun to wrap in all up at the end! And thanks Aloha, Fast Bill
Day 10
The last of the 3-layers in the current 91mm range is the Hiker, and really can be viewed as a Camper with a Phillips back tool instead of the corkscrew.
The Hiker brings a good alternative for those wanting a SAK with a wood saw for pocket carry when off the beaten track, but don’t see the need for a corkscrew.
Personally, I think there’s more chance of needing a corkscrew when you’re away from home and the kitchen draw, so it’s maybe a less convincing argument to marry the Phillips with the wood saw.
In days past, Victorinox had many more 91mm SAKs with the back Phillips, but they only added the wood saw to the 5- and 6-layer versions. The Hiker and it’s 4-layer saw/scissors Fieldmaster brother, are the only saw-equipped models in the current 91mm range with the back Phillips. All the 5- and 6-layer models are discontinued, so these two are your only options if you want this combination.
Pros:
- Great wood saw
- Small and lightweight
- Very affordable
Cons:
- You may miss the corkscrew, but maybe not
Bottom Line:
Like its Camper cousin, the Hiker is a great little SAK with an excellent wood saw. However, if you like the back Phillips and want a wood saw, you may want to also consider the Fieldmaster.(Apologies for reusing a pic used earlier today, the Hiker with a Yeoman mod).
Nice duo for sure!

-
Thank you VICMAN, Rapidray

4-layers start tomorrow...
-
Looking forward to the 4-layer SAKs Max!
As I mentioned my first SAK was a 3-layer Camper, but after becoming a member here I became very interested in the 4+ layer SAKs. -
@Max Stone said:
Yes, much like sensor watches (like Casio G-Shock, Protrek, etc), most are never used where the information they supply can be of real value (like your hiking example), and I suspect that 4 out of 5 Travelers fall into this category too. In the watch collecting forums, they refer to ‘desk divers’ when a watch designed for diving (100m+) is used more in a terrestrial environment (the owner may not even swim). The Traveler’s sensors are certainly very capable and it would be a good pocket choice for hiking. However, I still maintain it’s a SAK of interest mostly for its fun-factor.Interesting thoughts Max ...
I love the (derrogatory!!) term desk-diver - I had not heard that before - Very funny.Yep - I am sure you are right only 20% of people who get a Traveller will actually use the altimeter/barometer functions - And I guess the timer functions are usually available elsewhere (watch phone etc)
- And for sure the fun/gimmick factor is really good and cool
But just thinking - Does that category of tool/function not apply to many many tools on a SAK or multitool?
- ie You have this amazingly capable tool (especially as you go up the SAK layers) - But you may never, or rarely, use some of the individual implements
They are just there in case you need them - fishscaler, hook - even the wood saw, metal file etc etc spring to mind!
I guess the difference with the altimeter - Is - Unless you are hiking or climbing mountains - You would ***never ***really need the altimeter - The other tools you may have occasional occasion to use in every day life!
Anyway great reviews once again - Keep up the good work - Looking f to the XAVT !!!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login