Day by Day...a Journey down the 91mm Range
-
Nice review. I also have wondered why the Mountaineer is called Mountaineer, although, I will admit the metal saw/file is one of the tools that I do not have a lot of experience with.
-
@Greg Jones said:
Great review Max, over the past year I've become a real fan of the four layers
Thanks Greg

Yes, the 91mm range peaks at four layers, dropping off dramatically thereafter (with one notable exception).
Regarding the Mountaineer, I think it would be more popular if the file featured in more SAKs. It is one of the least common tools in the 2/3/4-layer range (just the one representative), yet is quite a useful tool.

-
@Max Stone said:
Yes, the 91mm range peaks at four layers, dropping off dramatically thereafter (with one notable exception).
Gotta be the S____C___p
or is it the C____T___M 
-
@Max Stone said:
Thanks Greg
Yes, the 91mm range peaks at four layers, dropping off dramatically thereafter (with one notable exception).
Regarding the Mountaineer, I think it would be more popular if the file featured in more SAKs. It is one of the least common tools in the 2/3/4-layer range (just the one representative), yet is quite a useful tool.

I guess it might be misrepresentation to a certain degree? Most people know this as "metal file", but in reality, it is a metal saw/file.
I only wish they could make one side of the metal file into a fine grind file, so it doubles as a knife sharpener/nail file.As said, I'd always choose that metal saw over the wood saw, it's essentially a 3-in-1 deal vs the single-use wood saw. :D
-
@comis said:
I guess it might be misrepresentation to a certain degree? Most people know this as "metal file", but in reality, it is a metal saw/file.
I only wish they could make one side of the metal file into a fine grind file, so it doubles as a knife sharpener/nail file.As said, I'd always choose that metal saw over the wood saw, it's essentially a 3-in-1 deal vs the single-use wood saw. :D
I have never tried using the metal saw for cutting wood. Maybe I need to test it out.
-
@Sos24 said:
I have never tried using the metal saw for cutting wood. Maybe I need to test it out.I just did. Depressing. It´s slow and it clogs.
I used a new metal saw, it´s pretty much the only tool on my Handyman or SwissChamp that doesn´t get any use.
Sawing into a 1 inch dried branch it took me 10 cuts to get as deep as 2 cuts with the woodsaw. -
Just as well the Handyman and SwissChamp both have wood saw’s then Ron...

...but good to know...
-
@Ron Who said:
I just did. Depressing. It´s slow and it clogs.I used a new metal saw, it´s pretty much the only tool on my Handyman or SwissChamp that doesn´t get any use.
Sawing into a 1 inch dried branch it took me 10 cuts to get as deep as 2 cuts with the woodsaw.That is what I suspected, because of the uniform shallower teeth and being wider.
-
Day 14
Fishing is a very specific activity, and Victorinox has a very specific tool to support users that catch fish. Well, that’s the intention...however the tool Victorinox assigns to this task is probably rarely used as intended.
That’s because we’re discussing the fish scaler tool found on the Angler, the next 4-layer SAK up for review.
The Angler also features another tool we have not come across before in this challenge; the pliers. But first, let’s get back to that fish scaler.
The fish scaler tool has a curved edge of scalloped teeth that are polished smooth. The idea is to drag this edge across a (dead) fish to remove the scales without tearing or cutting the skin.
I have caught and cleaned a few fish in my time, and can only imagine the slime and scale mess that would accumulate on (and in) my SAK if I used it to remove scales, but as I have never tried it, I really cannot talk with any authority on this matter. All I can say is that I prefer to use a single-purpose fish scaler, or the filleting knife, to scrape the scales off a fish before gutting.
As the infomercials say, “...but wait, there’s more!...” the SAK fish scaler is equipped with a disgorging tip that can help reverse out the hook that’s securely embedded inside the mouth of a fish. Again, I cannot attest to this use in the real world, as I prefer needle nose pliers for this specific task. But I guess if I’m on a deserted island with just my scaler-equipped SAK and the fishing kit from my SOS Kit, I’d be happily to have this tool?
Fortunately, for users less concerned with shipwreck survival, the fish scaler tool has other uses. The tip makes a good improvised cocktail-fork for retrieving pickles from a jar or picking cheese off a platter. Also as a ‘prodder’ for investigating questionable or unidentifiable objects (maybe at the bottom of that pickle jar).
The scaler also has a straight-edged ruler on the top edge, marked in inches and cm on opposite sides. Unfortunately the geometry of the SAK does not let you use it flat on a surface to draw lines, but having a short measuring tool could sometimes be useful...except maybe on a deserted island.
Oh, and another use is as a rangefinder. But I’m still to check the distance of a person against their relative height, measured at arms-length on the ruler. Something for a later post.
The second new tool found on the Angler are the pliers. It’s important not to expect too much from this tool, especially if you’re used to other brands’ multitools that are built around pliers. The 91mm Victorinox pliers are understandably small to still fold into the SAK, taking up a space only a little wider than any other tool layer.
You’re not going to bend plate steel or pull six inch nails with this tool, but it’s ideal for delicate work that requires a small gripping or squeezing tool. I used it to help open and close a link in a suspension chain for my SAK, working together with the needle nose pliers of my Leatherman. It was a good example of using two multitools together and where full-sized pliers would have offered no advantage.
I’ve heard the pliers referred to as ‘super-tweezers’, and I like this description. The tips close perfectly and are effective at grabbing small items like the exposed tip of a splinter. It’s just a case of accepting that you will still need another multitool if you expect to need anything closer to real pliers.
Beyond the fish scaler and pliers, the Angler still has the core toolset of blades and openers, with an awl and corkscrew on the back.
Pros:
- Unique fish scaler tool
- The smallest current 91mm SAKs to have pliers
Cons:
- Unique fish scaler tool
- Pliers more like super-tweezers
Bottom line:
With the neat fish logo on the top scale (scale?) there’s no doubt regarding the intended user for this SAK, even if the scaler tool is questionable. However, its 4-layered cousin, the Fisherman, with its Phillips back tool and scissors instead of pliers, may well be the better choice...if you like the fishy tool.



-
Excellent write up and I have never used my scaler for it’s intended purpose. I have used it many a time for drawing straight lines with the pencil. Still learning to use it as a range finder!

-
Just found this thread and am really enjoying it. Thanks!
-
Another nice write-up.
-
@Ron Who said:
I just did. Depressing. It´s slow and it clogs.I used a new metal saw, it´s pretty much the only tool on my Handyman or SwissChamp that doesn´t get any use.
Sawing into a 1 inch dried branch it took me 10 cuts to get as deep as 2 cuts with the woodsaw.I remembered doing this test many, many years ago, but don't remember being that depressing. I think I gonna do a more through test on that to see how much it does lack behind.
-
Thanks Rapidray, Sheradin, 🆘, comis.

-
I never understood why Vx made both the Angler, with pliers, and the Fisherman, with scissors, but no fishing knife with both.
I don´t need the fish scaler tool. I always have my Handyman handy when fishing and I even put the Fisherman´s scales on it.
-
The fish scale sure is nice!

-
Day 15
We covered the LED ‘tool’ in the 3-layered Spartan Lite (day 7) and it makes another appearance in today’s reviewed SAK; the Traveler Lite.
We reviewed the Traveler back on day 8, but for a quick recap, the Traveler is basically a Climber with a digital scale that displays environmental info such as altitude and temperature, together with digital watch functionality.
The Traveler Lite adds a fourth layer incorporating an LED flashlight and inline Phillips, the latter probably the more useful of these additional tools.
This extra layer and the thicker digital scale make the Traveler Lite the widest of all the current 4-layer 91mm SAKs, even wider than some 5-layer models. But there’s no doubt that the LED and inline Phillips adds some real value to an already capable product.
Pros:
- The most feature-rich 4-layer SAK
- LED brighter than earlier generations
- Plus scales and nail file on the hook
Cons:
- A fat 4-layer SAK, not so pocket-friendly
- Does not like water
- Expensive
Bottom line:
A wide range of tools makes the Traveler Lite the dark horse of the 91mm range. If you enjoy digital functionality on a SAK, you should consider the Traveler Lite. But you may want to pass if you’re looking for something that needs a little less maintenance.

-
Nice information and photos!

Didn’t think it would be thicker than some 5 layer!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

