Day by Day...a Journey down the 91mm Range
-
@Max Stone said:
Thank you Scubadawg1, TXSAK
Hi comis, that’s a little what Wenger did with their little wrench tool, but this is also limited in the size department, so a separate small adjustable wrench is not a bad idea if you have an EDC bag to carry it in.

Good call on the Wenger wrench!
Oh, the pocket wrench I refer is actually the following OPT, I think it does compliment most MT quite well and a perfect pry tool as well:
New love for the Pocketwrench II
I find Pocket wrench too good
Multitool.Org Forum (multitool.ninja)

-
+10
I always get surprised about the little general interest people have on the Mountaineer, and on the "metal file and saw" too, for that matter...

The Mountaineer always was a favorite of mine on the 4 layer department. The only place i feel the Camper/Hiker or Huntsman (wood saw) is useful, is in a purely rural environment, all other situations i feel a saw might be handy, the metal saw/file always takes priority for me, besides also having 4 functions (or more, depending on one's creativity), instead of just one. It's way more useful to saw a wider type of materials than the wood saw, even if slower at that.
But than again, no sak tool is made to be nearly as effective as the actual dedicated tool it's trying to replicate, so the idea is not to be "faster" but to actually "getting the job done" when nothing else is available, and it does that very well, faster or slower :DI'd love to get my hands on a Trail Guide (or 3... :D), i'd take it for urban 3 layer EDC, over any Climber.
On a side note,
Max, thank you for creating this great thread man

A joy to read on a daily basis, especially for a cellidor (84/91mm line) die hard fan like me...
-
@Max Stone said:
Hi comis, that’s a little what Wenger did with their little wrench tool, but this is also limited in the size department, so a separate small adjustable wrench is not a bad idea if you have an EDC bag to carry it in.
I have yet to use the wrench on mine as i never come across any nuts small enough for it to fit, there was once though i thought i was in luck, the small bolt on the bottom of the fridge door was loose and i figured i would tighten it with the Wenger, but no..even that was too big for it -
You're doing a great job with your reviews Max!

This is a very informative thread and will provide a great resource for others to find out about models they have not seen, and probably help inspire quite a few people to add a few more SAKs to their collection.

-
Thank you VICMAN for the kind words, I too am enjoying the journey and learning more about each SAK

Thanks also MacGyver, Borg, and comis, that’s a clever pocket wrench...I’ll need to look out for one like that.

Day 17
Choice is generally good, and Victorinox certainly give us lots of choice across the 91mm range.
And today, as an alternative to the Angler, we cover the Fisherman. Featuring the same fish scaler tool as the Angler, the Fisherman swaps the corkscrew for a Phillips back tool, and the pliers for scissors.
Now I’m a little of a traditionalist, so while I recognize the value of the back Phillips, my preference is the corkscrew.
But the scissors are certainly the more usable tool when compared to the pliers, so you have to wonder whether it would be better for Victorinox to rather put the scissors on the Angler, as set the Fisherman off on a retirement cruise...
Sometimes choices are not necessarily better.
Pros:
- Scissors more useful than pliers
- fish scaler can be used as an improvised cocktail fork
Cons:
- fish scaler tool not particularly practical
Bottom line:
The fish scaler is not exactly a high-demand tool, otherwise we’d see more of it paired with scissors. The next time we come across it is with the Swiss Champ, and there you get it with scissors, pliers and the corkscrew. But for something with less layers, the Fisherman is the best alternative.


-
Nice review and great photos!

I don’t know exactly why but I have 3 of them. And I do use the fish scaler just not for it’s intended purpose! -
@Max Stone said:
......
But the scissors are certainly the more usable tool when compared to the pliers, so you have to wonder whether it would be better for Victorinox to rather put the scissors on the Angler, as set the Fisherman off on a retirement cruise...
.....Thanks again Max
Hmmm - I always thought both was a good option - So why not bring back the Deluxe Angler? .... Or a Deluxe Fisherman?
-
Added this thread to the SAK Identifiers stickie:
/post/1630522
- Thanks Max (..... again!)
-
Thanks Rapidray
and Huntsman
for the stickie. -
I always get surprised about the little general interest people have on the Mountaineer, and on the "metal file and saw" too, for that matter...

The Mountaineer always was a favorite of mine on the 4 layer department. The only place i feel the Camper/Hiker or Huntsman (wood saw) is useful, is in a purely rural environment, all other situations i feel a saw might be handy, the metal saw/file always takes priority for me, besides also having 4 functions (or more, depending on one's creativity), instead of just one. It's way more useful to saw a wider type of materials than the wood saw, even if slower at that.
But than again, no sak tool is made to be nearly as effective as the actual dedicated tool it's trying to replicate, so the idea is not to be "faster" but to actually "getting the job done" when nothing else is available, and it does that very well, faster or slower :DI'd love to get my hands on a Trail Guide (or 3... :D ), i'd take it for urban 3 layer EDC, over any Climber.
On a side note,
Max, thank you for creating this great thread man

A joy to read on a daily basis, especially for a cellidor (84/91mm line) die hard fan like me...
Yes, another Mountaineer user! Yes!

Max, I gonna thank you again for this thread too. This is like a mini-union for all the Mountaineer Lovers out here. :D
-
I think we’ll have to start a Mountaineering Club

Day 18
There are only six 91mm SAKs in the current range that have a Phillips back tool. We’ve covered five of them so far (Tinker, Super Tinker, Deluxe Tinker, Hiker and Fisherman), so today’s mini-review is on the last one, the Fieldmaster.
The Fieldmaster can be considered the near-identical twin of the Huntsman, as it has the same tool load (scissors and wood saw), just with the Phillips on the back instead of the corkscrew.
However, the Huntsman gets the lion’s share of attention as it’s by far the more popular of the two. The Fieldmaster getting largely ignored.
Like the Huntsman, the Fieldmaster is quite a compact 4-layer SAK, and while you’ll feel it in your pocket, it is usable for EDC on your person.
As a cross-over between urban and outdoor use, the Fieldmaster is certainly worth considering. Especially if you like using the wood saw and see value in having the Phillips over the corkscrew.
Pros:
- Both the scissors and wood saw are good at what they’re designed for.
- Just about pocketable for EDC
Cons:
- Lacks the character of the Huntsman
Bottom line:
A little lost without a strong identity, the Fieldmaster is still a capable SAK with a good set of tools. It’s just questionable whether it gives any real-world advantage over the Huntsman, considering that you get the corkscrew and can still use the can-opener’s driver for cross-head screws.


-
Another great review and photo’s -

I have 3 Fieldmasters...they are all BSA’s Huntsman. Talk about a misunderstood step child...this one only gets loved by Scouts! -
@Max Stone said:
A little lost without a strong identity, the Fieldmaster is still a capable SAK with a good set of tools.What even is a ‘Fieldmaster’, anyway? I mean I know what a huntsman is, and a climber, and a Spartan...but who is the mysterious master of fields, and what does he do?
All we really know is that he prefers working on easily-accessible Phillips screws that don’t need much torque, to drinking wine. The man has his priorities wrong, in my opinion.
-
@fullbreakfast said:
What even is a ‘Fieldmaster’, anyway? I mean I know what a huntsman is, and a climber, and a Spartan...but who is the mysterious master of fields, and what does he do?All we really know is that he prefers working on easily-accessible Phillips screws that don’t need much torque, to drinking wine. The man has his priorities wrong, in my opinion.

-
Just catching up after missing a couple of entries
Great reviews Max
I accidentally became a fan of the Fieldmaster, it's the only backside Phillips I have, but I've found if you have it you'll use it, at least me, I've been EDCing mine for close to a year now
-
Great thread/challenge!

-
Yikes. I've missed several days. The 91mm has such variety yet why am I still searching for the perfect SAK
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
:D