Scale variations
-
Always learn so much when JB posts

-
This is really great JB - Thanks for taking the time to construct all this.
We spend so much time talking about the tools and the tool evolution - It's really good to see the scales get some air time.
And as always so much knowledge and info to suck up.
BTW. You must be a chemist in your other life - Right? - All this formulation stuff

-
@Reinier said:
Do you consider the blue alox knives made for the Dutch air force to be a different variaton, or do you discount them for being non-standard?I consider them to be a proper variation and different from the #3 aluminum scales in the first image since they are anodized and the pre-war aluminum stuff is not. I didn't include it in this shot because I don't have one unfortunately.
-
Some more scale variants. First one is original tortoiseshell
-
Those are awesome.
-
@wengercollector said:
Some more scale variants. First one is original tortoiseshellVery nice! I like that 2nd one in, the horn

-
@jazzbass said:
I consider them to be a proper variation and different from the #3 aluminum scales in the first image since they are anodized and the pre-war aluminum stuff is not. I didn't include it in this shot because I don't have one unfortunately.
@wengercollector said:
Some more scale variants. First one is original tortoiseshellOh my, those are really nice. That crossbow logo should be re-introduced!

-
Added this to the SAK ID thread

/post/1630522Thanks JB
-
Cool thread!
Lots of interesting information here. Thanks!@jazzbass said:
So about the scale deterioration mentioned in my first post - take a look at this image (click here for higher res). It shows most of the major forms of scale deterioration I know of in the 84mm/91mm lines.In my experience, scale deterioration isn't limited to scales made of synthetic materials. In particular, horn scales often exhibit significant issues as well. One major problem is that they tend to get eaten by bugs (see http://www.knife-expert.com/bugs036.txt for a nicely written article about this problem). Another common problem is that they tend to develop deformations (shrinking and/or swelling) and cracks. The attached image shows a 1960's Spartan with horn scales exhibiting all of these issues. The holes on the back scale are typical to the damage caused by bugs and the scales also exhibit significant deformations (shrinking in some directions while swelling in others) and some cracks.

-
Tiffany series sterling silver scales( not solid to my regret)

-
@MiniChamp said:
Cool thread!
Lots of interesting information here. Thanks!
In my experience, scale deterioration isn't limited to scales made of synthetic materials. In particular, horn scales often exhibit significant issues as well.I agree with you completely. When I saw your post I did a sort of head smack for not including the buffalo horn scales in it, so I'm glad you posted. My original idea was really to just talk about the plastic CN/CA/CAB deterioration, and when I was pulling knives to photograph, I saw the cracked fiber scale Spartan and threw it in almost as an afterthought. None of the horn Spartans in my collection are in bad shape so I didn't even think about it. :-[ That said, I have purchased several horn scaled knives where the scales are in really, really bad shape. Your pictures show the problems with bugs and swelling perfectly.
Now I'm under the impression that the horn scales are a lot like the fiber scale - damage/degredation tends to be environmental vs inherent in the material itself like the early plastics. In other words, if kept in a cool, humidity-controlled, bug-free environment, is there any reason to worry about degradation of horn scales in a collection?
My understanding is that all the oils and protection layers knife guys talk about for horn scales are necessary for knives that see use - out in the elements, humidity, being used, etc. I know I'm hesitant to start putting oils or anything on a 80 yr old horn handled knife. However, I do want to do more research on this because I'm not actively taking any steps to preserve the old horn/stag handle knives in my collection, and now I'm wondering if I should be....
-
@jazzbass said:
Now I'm under the impression that the horn scales are a lot like the fiber scale - damage/degredation tends to be environmental vs inherent in the material itself like the early plastics.I believe that you are right about horn scales being a lot like fiber scales in this respect, but degradation of plastic scales is likely to depend on the environment as well. To the best of my limited understanding, the process of celluloid decomposition tends to be autocatalytic. Hence, it usually cannot be stopped once started, but the timing of when it starts may depend on the environment. I find the following article quite illuminating: http://www.oregonknifeclub.org/celluloid_02.html
It seems to suggest that environmental conditions may play an important role in the deterioration of early plastic scales as well.In other words, if kept in a cool, humidity-controlled, bug-free environment, is there any reason to worry about degradation of horn scales in a collection?
I don't know. It's a very interesting question. Particularly, for those of us fortunate enough to be able to produce such an environment. I keep fighting with my wife because of her employing cooking methodologies that involve massive emission of water vapor into our indoor atmosphere. My claims that this may be causing horrific damage to many of my precious objects seem to get limited sympathy from her. I even developed clear preference for rice over pasta because of this. Particularly in the winter. It helps a little. :D
-
I love threads like these.
One of the great things about the SAK hobby is that participants can stay in the shallow end of the pool or delve as deeply as they wish. Furthermore, no matter how deep you go there’s always more to be found.
-
Very good points all round F 
-
Fantastic post and thread. Now I understand why some of these wonderful Swiss Army knives are so rare and difficult to find in good condition!

-
Looks like Facebook SAK Collectors like your post JB
Just started dabbling in this group - I see a few links to here - And lots to SAKWiki.
And lots of "Please anyone tell me what this model is?" questions ....... when the answer is awlways in the Wiki

-
FolderBeholder posted this thread: /topic/82769 that is of significant relevance to the discussion here. This is a great example of cellulose acetate butyrate (CAB) breakdown in early Elinox scales. The acetate is breaking down and producing acetic acid (i.e. vinegar), and that acid is tarnishing the nickel silver inlays on the knife. This is a mild-ish deterioration, and it doesn't look to have damaged the knife too much - yet.
This is an area where collectors of older knives like myself, FB, jnoxyd and other need to learn about plastic conservation. Honestly up until recently I didn't really think much about it and (naively) assumed that these plastics were stable and the ones that I had that were damaged had just lived difficult lives. I've just started doing in depth research on this, but fortunately there is a LOT of information about conservation of antique plastics. Hell, there's even a Wikipedia article on it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conservation_and_restoration_of_plastic_objects
I've just started thinking about plastic conservation for my collection, and have a ways to go. What I'm doing right now is:
-
Limiting exposure to UV. Esp important for older cellulose nitrate knives from the 40s.
-
Maintaining humidity control. Pretty easy for me, as I live in the US and my wife loves AC. RH stays around 50% in my house all year long.
-
Limit exposure to water. I used to wash all knives in an ultrasonic bath when I got them, because if you've purchased many knives from eBay you'll know - many of them are disgustingly dirty. For modern knives it's not a problem, but anything 1975 and before I need to find a new way to clean.
-
Limit exposure to high temps. The other part of my old cleaning process was water warmed to 120-130F. This was nice because the temps really helped loosen up all the grime in the knives. Turns out it also was probably the main factor in setting of autocatalytic reactions in several of my knives. Since it doesn't happen immediatly, I had no idea I was damaging the knife. But the results are pretty clear - a 50 yr old CAB knife I buy has minor tarnishing, I clean it with hot water, and 2 years later the scales are all but destroyed and the tools are rusty.
-
Separate "problem" knives from the rest of the collection. Any knives experiencing obvious signs of breakdown (tarnishing emblems, cracking scales, etc) are being moved away from the main part of the collection and placed somewhere with good ventilation. These so-called "malignant plastics" will apparently destroy other collection items with their nitric acid/acetic acid out gassing if left in proximity.
That's just a start, though. I have several things I want to do in the next couple months:
-
Find new methods to clean new additions to the collection without damaging them or setting off autocatalytic reactions
-
Install fans to actively ventilate the main part of the collection. My knives are stored in drawers, so I'm thinking some sort of computer fan setup on the back of the cabinet to pull fresh air into the drawers.
-
Install A-D strips to monitor acid levels in the environment. More info here: https://www.imagepermanenceinstitute.org/imaging/ad-strips
-
Install humidity monitoring/notification sensors in the collection. You can build a wireless, low power temp/humidity sensor node from parts on Amazon for < $10.
-
Look at moving certain knives (older CN scaled knives in particular) into some sort of lower temp storage. Indications are that lower temps helps slow the CN break down significantly.
More information for the curious:
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
