Combo Edge Cooperative - partial to partially serrated blades
-
I've always been a fan of combo edges. The serrated section is great for cutting fibrous material such as rope and palm fronds and I happen to live where I tend to encounter such fibrous materials. I don't cut enough of them to the point where I would want a fully serrated edge though, and that's where the combo edge comes in. I can understand why most people don't care for the serrations. I probably would prefer just a straight edge too if I lived where I was less likely to encounter fibrous materials and found only hard woods or smooth items that I needed to cut. That's why everyone makes their own decision on knife edges, except in the case of military or employer issued equipment.

-
I have a couple of knives with the combo edge. My Spyderco Endura is probably my favorite version, but the Vic Trekker is no slouch either.
-
I have a few with combo or serrated edges as well. I'm definitely primarily a PE guy, but if a model I otherwise like is only available with CE or SE, that isn't an automatic deal-breaker. Also, I always want to be carrying at least one PE blade, but a CE or SE as a second (or third or fourth
) blade (either on the same knife/tool or on separate knives/tools) provides an additional option and some variety.I think it's worth noting that all serrations are not created equal. Just like PE blades, the cutting geometry of some is much better than others.
Possibly fodder for separate threads, but for those (all four of us, apparently :D) who see at least some redeeming qualities in CE blades for at least some applications:
[list type=decimal]-
Do you prefer the serrations near the tip of the blade, and the plain section near the handle? Or would you rather have the plain section near the tip, and the serrations near the handle? Explain the reason(s) for your choice.
-
How much of a CE blade should be serrated? Half? Three quarters? One quarter? Why? Does your answer change based on the total length of the blade?
-
-
@nate j said:
I think it's worth noting that all serrations are not created equal. Just like PE blades, the cutting geometry of some is much better than others.Possibly fodder for separate threads, but for those (all four of us, apparently :D) who see at least some redeeming qualities in CE blades for at least some applications:
[list type=decimal]- Do you prefer the serrations near the tip of the blade, and the plain section near the handle? Or would you rather have the plain section near the tip, and the serrations near the handle? Explain the reason(s) for your choice.
- How much of a CE blade should be serrated? Half? Three quarters? One quarter? Why? Does your answer change based on the total length of the blade?
Great topics for discussion on this thread

Different serrations are definitely made for different tasks... Though I can't figure out in what way. If you look at the serrations on the regular LM Skeletool and the LM Skeletool Rx (a very clever model identifier for an EMT tool, I might add), they're quite different... The latter deep, wider serrations being for cutting through seatbelts, denim and other tough clothing material.
The Cold Steel serrations have micro teeth in between the deeper concave scallops. Those do bite in to rope better.I suppose that the total length of the blade, and the blade shape matters, but I would estimate that I would prefer no more than 1/3 of the blade being serrated. While aesthetically I feel that the inner 1/4 to 1/3 of the blade having serrations looks better... Functionally, the outer portion of the blade having the serrations (like on the Vic OHT) works best.
I can't say that a combo edge is my preference... Or even a fully serrated blade for that matter. But the last few times I reached for a serrated blade, it was on the sheepfoot blade on the LM Wave... and it was the blade shape as much as the serrations that I was after.... Which again gives the nod to the Vic OHT which has a blunt tip.
I will say though... The fully serrated sheepfoot blades are good for tearing through tough material.
-
I think like a lot of new knife buyers the lesser expensive options had combo edges so thats what I bought. As time went on I realized I did like the serrated portion but preferred a fully serrated blade. I bought a Spyderco Native fully serrated and WOW. I then got a fully serrated Delica and again WOW. Spyderco does a great job on their serrations.
I then got a Spirit with butter blade
. I was not used to the serrated portion towards the tip so I was initially not sold. The serrated portion is about 75% in my estimation. After some time with it I was sold. Victorinox did a great job on their serration and the style of blade was also to my liking.I picked up a fully serrated Spyderco Jumpmaster from Barry and this is a heck of a work knife. I really like having a fully serrated fixed blade for hose line, nylon rope, paracord, plastic banding, and everything else I can use this knife on.
As to combo edge knives in general
well I'd prefer PE or SE and while I get along with my butter blade on my Spirit, its to my mind mostly a serrated edge knife. -
-
I think the Vic type with the serrations towards the tip makes a lot of sense because that should give you the best leverage for cutting rope and such and the non serrated rear portion of the blade should give you the most control for cutting a feather stick or sharpening a pencil, etc.. However most knives are the other way around and that is what I learned on and have more of. Absolute best combo edge was on a Schrade CH-7 I had years ago. It would rip through palm fronds (palm fronds are my benchmark) without much effort at all and even out performed some fully serrated blades. If I'd had the sense to buy several of them I'd still be using it but I don't want to risk the one I still have. The worst combo edge or fully serrated for palm fronds are Leatherman blades, but most Leathermans have an excellent saw blade so I just use that instead.
-
I think 1/2 serrated is enough for most tasks and probably the best compromise, but it can go to 3/4 and still be usable. I have a partially serrated rigging knife that is 3/4 serrated and the plain edge is at the tip and on this particular knife I always wish it had less serrations. My solution is to always carry 2 or more knives and use whichever one is best suited to a particular task.
-
-
@Alan K. said:
-
I think the Vic type with the serrations towards the tip makes a lot of sense because that should give you the best leverage for cutting rope and such and the non serrated rear portion of the blade should give you the most control for cutting a feather stick or sharpening a pencil, etc.. However most knives are the other way around and that is what I learned on and have more of. Absolute best combo edge was on a Schrade CH-7 I had years ago. It would rip through palm fronds (palm fronds are my benchmark) without much effort at all and even out performed some fully serrated blades. If I'd had the sense to buy several of them I'd still be using it but I don't want to risk the one I still have. The worst combo edge or fully serrated for palm fronds are Leatherman blades, but most Leathermans have an excellent saw blade so I just use that instead.
-
I think 1/2 serrated is enough for most tasks and probably the best compromise, but it can go to 3/4 and still be usable. I have a partially serrated rigging knife that is 3/4 serrated and the plain edge is at the tip and on this particular knife I always wish it had less serrations. My solution is to always carry 2 or more knives and use whichever one is best suited to a particular task.
The issue I always had with a priori choosing a blade for a particular job... Keeping in mind that doing this sort of work becomes more fun because I get to use a MT... I ever really know which tool is the best one for the job because I did the whole thing with the blade I selected first
Most of the time if it isn't the SAK in my pocket then it's the fully serrated blade on the Wave. The combo edge on the Cold Steel Voyager and the Victorinox have gotten in on the action within the last year too, but the Wave has always been handy... So it gets more use.
Point is... I would never seem to mind that I would have to adjust my grip to use the "common" combo edge for most things.It's also interesting that the combo edge is (almost) always the cheaper option and tends to be people's initial experienced with an EDC. Hopefully the trip down memory lane will make the Combo Edge Cooperative a fun thread.
I tend to think that most of the time a decision that a company makes which seems counterintuitive is really based on focus groups or some other market research.. or some sort of human factors analysis... (to give an example... in surveys and focus groups: commuters overwhelmingly would rather stand than be in the middle of a 3-seater... so new train cars are designed with fewer seats)
Though I could be giving the MT manufacturer more credit than is due.So when a Leatherman Signal, or a Vic OHT which is designed for outdoor recreation have a combo edge
Maybe people who have a preference for a particular blade steel or insist on sharpening their own knives is a remarkably small minority.

-
-
The standard blade on the Skeletool is a combo edge. I got this KBX for the "cool factor" mainly. It's pretty easy to change the grip and choose whichever edge I want to use, especially with this modified Wharncliffe shape.
This sort of knife would be great for backpacking, particularly for people who don't reach for their knife all the time and have deeply ingrained habits. It's sort of a multitool in and of itself.
I think that sometimes, real "users" that know how to keep a razor's edge on their own knives really miss out on some of these "out of the box" gadgets (that is... if you like gadgets). It's true, there are gadgets and there are tools.
But in some circles, a multitool or knife gadget has a similar fun factor as a backpacking stove gadget. Is it easy to cook a full meal on a single burner backpacking stove? No. Are feather sticks made with a KBX going to come out looking professional? No. But sometimes it's more fun.

-
I think that most people will agree that this part serrated blade is not half bad.

-
I like serrated blades but I prefer a different kind of combo ;)

-
@Ron Who said:
I like serrated blades but I prefer a different kind of combo ;)That is nice

-
Would there be any interest in a Combo Edge Challenge?
A combo of months from February 1 to March 2 would be apropos.Several Leatherman tools, Cold Steel folders, and many others would qualify.
-
That might be interesting depending on the rules and requirements of the challenge.

-
@Alan K. said:
That might be interesting depending on the rules and requirements of the challenge.
I'm thinking.... Simply.... Carry any multitool or single blade folder for the month as long as it has a combo edge.
Skeletool, Trekker, PST-2.
No fully serrated or plain edge blade allowed.
The inspiration for this challenge comes from Leatherman advertisements that I had been looking at. Leatherman's catch phrase will be something about resourcefulness, and the tool being able to help with any job. Meanwhile, someone is bound to comment that they would prefer a plain edge.
I said to myself... Maybe I would prefer a plain edge too, but... Out of the box, the tool would (or wouldn't) get the job done, edge style notwithstanding.
So the challenge is... To use any one of the perfectly good tools like the Skeletool or Signal or Trekker, and see how you get on with the blade as is.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I'm thinking.... Simply.... Carry any multitool or single blade folder for the month as long as it has a combo edge.Skeletool, Trekker, PST-2.
No fully serrated or plain edge blade allowed.
The inspiration for this challenge comes from Leatherman advertisements that I had been looking at. Leatherman's catch phrase will be something about resourcefulness, and the tool being able to help with any job. Meanwhile, someone is bound to comment that they would prefer a plain edge.
I said to myself... Maybe I would prefer a plain edge too, but... Out of the box, the tool would (or wouldn't) get the job done, edge style notwithstanding.
So the challenge is... To use any one of the perfectly good tools like the Skeletool or Signal or Trekker, and see how you get on with the blade as is.
Anyone up for this in 2021?
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Anyone up for this in 2021?Probably me, depending on when we do it. I've been looking for an excuse to get a Myerchin titanium Crew Pro.
-
This is one of the few pairs of EDC that I have new in box copies of.
I have lived with the Delica for a long time and it could easily be my only knife any time.


M
-
@ezdog said:
This is one of the few pairs of EDC that I have new in box copies of.I have lived with the Delica for a long time and it could easily be my only knife any time.


M

There are a lot of classic EDC knives from the 90s and 2000s (I guess) that can be an "only" knife... Spyderco, Cold Steel....
-
With discussions of 2022 challenges underway I wanted to start drumming up some interest in a Combo Edge Challenge for February/Mar 2022 (what timeframe can be more appropriate?)
There are lots of tools that qualify, and lots of tools that people carry daily without any issue (though often with a secondary plain edge blade)
At this point, I'm thinking of doing the challenge with the Skeletool.
Anyone else interested? It's a long way away, but... might as well start planning early.

-
I’d be in EB

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login