Knot in October GAW
-
I was wondering if there would be a single winner to this giveaway, or whether it might be tied.

-
Also worth (k)noting is that the bowline isn't a safe knot and can slip (which can be dangerous and has lead to a few climber deaths) so it should always be ended up with a safety knot to secure it.

Just add a single fisherman knot like on the lanyard pfsantos posted before as a stopper knot.


-
@enki_ck said:
Also worth (k)noting is that the bowline isn't a safe knot and can slip (which can be dangerous and has lead to a few climber deaths) so it should always be ended up with a safety knot to secure it.
Just add a single fisherman knot like on the lanyard pfsantos posted before as a stopper knot.
I was taut to do the same (to borrow RP's pun.).
And there are other variants......

-
@enki_ck said:
Also worth (k)noting is that the bowline isn't a safe knot and can slip (which can be dangerous and has lead to a few climber deaths) so it should always be ended up with a safety knot to secure it.
A knot is safe if it is used for the right purpose.
Otherwise I could say a Half-Windsor is terribly unsafe for bungy jumping. -
I'm with enki: the bowline is a fantstic knot....I use it frquently...but it is (k)not a knot I'd trust my life with.

-
-
I've seen that version, tail outside the loop, no security knot, referred to as the 'Dutch Bowline.'
-
@Syncop8r said:
A knot is safe if it is used for the right purpose.
Otherwise I could say a Half-Windsor is terribly unsafe for bungy jumping.The thing is that bowline was and for many still is the right knot. They use it to tie themselves in (ok if you add a stopper knot), or as the main anchor point which one should never do anyways. And that's how accidents happen.
-
@Nix said:
I've seen that version, tail outside the loop, no security knot, referred to as the 'Dutch Bowline.'Also known as the cowboy bowline
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowboy_bowline
It made more sense to me to have the tail outside the object it's tied around.

-
My army instructor disapproved of the 'Dutch' version. But apparently it was preferred by the Dutch and thought to be stronger......

-
Too right. I think that is one reason knowing about knots is important.
And....I think the ordinary Bowline has a history of being used where and when it shouldn't.
-
@enki_ck said:
The thing is that bowline was and for many still is the right knot. They use it to tie themselves in (ok if you add a stopper knot), or as the main anchor point which one should never do anyways. And that's how accidents happen.I think of a bowline predominantly being used to tie onto objects such as tree limbs.
Having said that, I can tie one around my waist with one hand by another method... -
Ashley: The Bowline "is so good a knot that the sailor seldom uses any other Loop Knot aboard ship"
He also notes that dragging a bowline through the water makes it more prone to jamming, so he says an extra half-hitch is sometimes added to lessen the chance of the knot jamming:

I defer to his wisdom, but fail to see how that really helps......
Like enki's extra overhand, I was taught to use the working end to put an extra half-hitch around the loop, like this:

I think that when it comes to untying, my half hitch will be easier to loosen up than enki's overhand.....but that probably means enki's overhand finishing knot is less prone to fall apart.
-
@Hevy (CT-782) said:
Acting as proxy to my 8 yo son Vitor:
(My boy likes SAKs, Knifes, Knots and Star Wars)This knot is called Bowline.
The bowline is a simple knot used to form a fixed loop at the end of a rope. It has the virtues of being both easy to tie and untie; most notably, it is easy to untie after being subjected to a load.He makes this one really fast. :-)


Enviado de meu moto g(6) usando o Tapatalk
I first learned the bowline in Girl Scouts and I think I was 8yo. It is funny because they taught it to us with using a tree and bunny analogy, which is hpw to this day I remember how to tie.
-
Thanks Nix, enki and Sos.
He's very happy for sharing his recent knowledge about knots.
And very happy with the challenge
(He's training to tie knots)

Enviado de meu moto g(6) usando o Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


