Daredevil Challenge 2021
-
@ReamerPunch said:
Well, there you have it. 30 days with the Flik. I was not expecting my mind to be changed, and it has not, for the most part.I made a slight modification to the bottle opener profile, and now, when opened with the small flathead, the two can accommodate the square-hole bit adapter. This expanded the Flik's usefulness immensely. Gerber sold their own version of this bit adapter. Why not be able to use it by default? It took so little effort to do this, that it could have been a feature. Open both flatheads, put the bit adapter on there. It fits well enough to be used. There is no reason for the flathead to have that little belly by default. It still opens bottles perfectly well after my mod.
Ergonomics are still average at best. I am a little used to handling the tool, but ergonomics are not good.
Opening the pliers with a Flik of the wrist never got old. SNAP! Pliers. Well, there is the extra step of spreading the handles to get the pliers to shift position and create splay, but still. Oho pliers are nice, and the pliers themselves are nice. And retracting them got better. They used to get jammed all the time when being retracted. Now I can press the buttons and retract the pliers quite reliably. They do jam on me on occasion, but this is not as big a problem now. Still not a fan of the issue being there, though.The scissors I cannot forgive. They do not even cut paper that well. I cannot believe just how bad they are. Fiskars owns Gerber, and the Flik was an expensive, premium, top of the line offering. Very few tools in my collection have worse scissors than the Flik.
The saw is terrible. Thick, bent out-of-the-box, with tiny teeth. It clogs, it binds, and it even scrapes the frame when being folded.
The can opener should have been omitted. Having it was just wishful thinking. It does not open cans effectively. Not if you want to eat the food afterwards. And it took valuable space. The Phillips could have been squared, instead of being flattened.
The blades are sharp, and I especially like the serrated blade, but again, why are there issues where there should not be? The unsharpened heels on the blades are three times as long as they should have been. And this was to reduce accidents? Why not just fix the thumb-holes? Gerber makes a ton of folding knives with thumb-holes. Why did the Flik get the short straw? This is probably the thing that baffles me the most.
Another weird thing is having to push the locking tabs back, to lift the short implements, and expose their nail-nicks. Why not just have the implements sit a little higher and have the nail-nicks already exposed? The Leatherman Free series and Roxon Phantom and Flash have their implements completely flush, but on all those, this serves ergonomics, plus it is easy to deploy the implements with one hand. On the Flik, it does not matter. The ergonomics are already sub-par. Having the implements flush serves no purpose, and the extra step to partially deploy them does not allow one-handed use anyway, so what's the point?
Conclusion
I do not know what the conclusion is. I still disagree with many of the choices made with the Flik. If this was done differently, it might have stayed in production. I do not really recommend it, because it frustrates me to see such an ambitious design receive such poor implementation.
I do not regret spending a month with it. I managed to modify it to accept the Ganzo bit adapter, and this alone is a massive plus. I doubt I'll add it to my edc rotation, but at least it is a little more useful now. If you have one already, take a Dremel, grind the belly off the bottle opener, and enjoy driving standard bits.I agree with comis. It seems that the tool was not thoroughly test driven before being put into production. The feedback they could have gained from some consumer product testing could have helped fix some flaws and created a popular product.
-
The new forum badges for this challenge is up!

Thank you Steve for putting them up!

And in case it is your first time apply for a merit badge, please kindly follow the instructions Grant has written here. And always feel free to holler if there is any question about applying. :D

Thanks Steve

-
@Humayd A R Mahomedy said:
these pics pop,i love how the brushed finish on the tool appears here.
great use too

You might fool the other participants, but I know that you made this post at 7:22 AM. There are still some hours left in Day 30

:D

@Adam5 said:
I have this tool (Bibury brand in my case) and agree with your assessment. It is definitely worth the $22US you spent in my opinion because it is better than the lower priced options from Leatherman and Gerber in many ways. But it is not quite good enough for EDC if you can afford a better tool. Better for a back up or loaner. However, when I could not afford to get anything more expensive than a Suspension, I would have gladly used this MT instead.I remember there was a time when LM sidekick or wingman was just under $30, and I probably would have choosen those over the Wetols/Bibury(since they are so much easier to carry), but for whatever reason, LM prices just spiked and now Wingman/Sidekick has simply doubled in price in a short time frame. But I do concur, as a loaner/backup, that price is pretty hard to beat.

-
<u>DAY 30</u>
After the parched looking ghost Chilli yesterday here's the OHT with a well hydrated Lily

I think it's fair to say that this has been a struggle for us awl.
For me it has been less of a struggle simply because I had chosen a LM (albeit one I just can't get on with
) Therefore, it's well designed and well constructed.However, I find the OHT blades too short and the plier locking mechanism too fiddly (it just moves on its own) Moreover, it's VERY bulky and has no scissors
It's mostly done everything asked of it but, due to work demands, I've not needed to use it as I used my O/G Surge during July (which is just typical ::) )I guess that if push came to shove I could use it for work, but I wouldn't choose it over my Surge or, if I'm honest, my original work issue MP600. I guess it's just ok

If I had to choose just one LM MT it would be my O/G Surge (not had a chance to use my new B/O one yet because of this challenge
)However, I do like my MXBS and if they made a Surge sized one.... :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Well done AWL....


-
Congratulations everyone on a challenge well suffered

-
After the parched looking ghost Chilli yesterday here's the OHT with a well hydrated Lily

I think it's fair to say that this has been a struggle for us awl.
For me it has been less of a struggle simply because I had chosen a LM (albeit one I just can't get on with
) Therefore, it's well designed and well constructed.However, I find the OHT blades too short and the plier locking mechanism too fiddly (it just moves on its own) Moreover, it's VERY bulky and has no scissors
It's mostly done everything asked of it but, due to work demands, I've not needed to use it as I used my O/G Surge during July (which is just typical ::) )I guess that if push came to shove I could use it for work, but I wouldn't choose it over my Surge or, if I'm honest, my original work issue MP600. I guess it's just ok

If I had to choose just one LM MT it would be my O/G Surge (not had a chance to use my new B/O one yet because of this challenge
)However, I do like my MXBS and if they made a Surge sized one.... :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Well done AWL....

The perfect time... I'll trade you a lightly used Rev for it, so much slimmer and lighter to carry, no fiddly plier mechanism...

-
@GearedForwards said:
The perfect time... I'll trade you a lightly used Rev for it, so much slimmer and lighter to carry, no fiddly plier mechanism...


-
Day 30
I just typed out a long treatise on the virtues and failings of the MP600 Pro-Scout, somehow hit the wrong button, and it disappeared. Yelling at the computer that "I have certain skills, and I will find you" did absolutely nothing. Not even going to try to do it again. Short version is, I actually like the MP600. It has some interesting features. You can use the pliers collapsed in the handle as a big tweezers because they will open about 1/4 inch. That might be good for pulling slivers, or fuses, or RAM from a circuit board, and that sort of thing. It also would allow you to use long 1/4 inch bits gripped in the pliers jaws under the pivot (see picture). You would lose the big tweezers feature if you had blunt nose pliers or if you ground down the needle nose, but without the needle nose sticking out beyond the frame the tool could be pocket carried, so it's a tradeoff. The semi-serrated knife blade took a good edge and cuts. You can't ask for much more than that. It is not in regular rotation mainly because the tools are short and for the overall size it doesn't have the same utility as a Rebar or Spirit tool. If you've been carrying a Victorinox Spirit for the last several years as I have, the MP600 lacks any elegance by comparison and just feels like a Soviet farm tractor. You could get the job done if this was all you had and it might even be a better choice than many I've seen. -
@Alan K. said:
Day 30
I just typed out a long treatise on the virtues and failings of the MP600 Pro-Scout, somehow hit the wrong button, and it disappeared. Yelling at the computer that "I have certain skills, and I will find you" did absolutely nothing. Not even going to try to do it again. Short version is, I actually like the MP600. It has some interesting features. You can use the pliers collapsed in the handle as a big tweezers because they will open about 1/4 inch. That might be good for pulling slivers, or fuses, or RAM from a circuit board, and that sort of thing. It also would allow you to use long 1/4 inch bits gripped in the pliers jaws under the pivot (see picture). You would lose the big tweezers feature if you had blunt nose pliers or if you ground down the needle nose, but without the needle nose sticking out beyond the frame the tool could be pocket carried, so it's a tradeoff. The semi-serrated knife blade took a good edge and cuts. You can't ask for much more than that. It is not in regular rotation mainly because the tools are short and for the overall size it doesn't have the same utility as a Rebar or Spirit tool. If you've been carrying a Victorinox Spirit for the last several years as I have, the MP600 lacks any elegance by comparison and just feels like a Soviet farm tractor. You could get the job done if this was all you had and it might even be a better choice than many I've seen.
The tip about the 1/4" bits 
-
First few badges awarded !

-
@Alan K. said:
They have to be extra long bits though.What are you implying

-

Congratulations to awl who finish with their sanity intact.

-
@Fireman said:
Daredevil Day 30! We made it!

Final pic for cody6268. I have to take my wife to the eye doc today, so I doubt there will be any use.

Final thoughts on the Swiss+Tech 13 in 1:
It’s neither as good as I had hoped, nor as bad as I feared.
-I started to take it apart to smooth the blade swing and had to stop for lack of proper bits. However, it was smoother after I did this.
-When I started taking it apart, I found the cause of its major weakness. There is a pivot screw for blades, and two smaller ones at the other end. The pins are held in place only by spring pressure. The scales are thin. Any torque on the tool, i.e. using screwdrivers, puts stress on the scales and pins, and it feels as though the tool will fail. That doesn’t mean you can’t turn screws or pry with it, but I’d say it’s light duty.
-File works well enough on either side, but there is no way to use it as a metal saw.
-Center tool clumping is a pain. If you want something other than the knife or file, you’re going to be separating all three center tools.
-Lack of scissors and awl is a problem for me.I think that the flexing while using the drivers would be a deal breaker for me at most any price and certainly at $18US. I would pay a little more money and get a SAK. I can buy a Tinker for $24US.
-
After the parched looking ghost Chilli yesterday here's the OHT with a well hydrated Lily

I think it's fair to say that this has been a struggle for us awl.
For me it has been less of a struggle simply because I had chosen a LM (albeit one I just can't get on with
) Therefore, it's well designed and well constructed.However, I find the OHT blades too short and the plier locking mechanism too fiddly (it just moves on its own) Moreover, it's VERY bulky and has no scissors
It's mostly done everything asked of it but, due to work demands, I've not needed to use it as I used my O/G Surge during July (which is just typical ::) )I guess that if push came to shove I could use it for work, but I wouldn't choose it over my Surge or, if I'm honest, my original work issue MP600. I guess it's just ok

If I had to choose just one LM MT it would be my O/G Surge (not had a chance to use my new B/O one yet because of this challenge
)However, I do like my MXBS and if they made a Surge sized one.... :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Well done AWL....

My lack of desire to own an OHT has not been changed one iota by your experience. I would choose a Surge over the OHT ten out of ten times. Not as certain if I would choose a MP600 over the OHT, but I have never handled either one.
-
@Echotech said:
OK Steve in the name of science
or something 
As all my cans have ring pulls so had to turn it over. This disadvantages the Hammerhead as the lip on the can is a little smaller, however have tested other MT’s this way so a level playing field in that regard
Conclusion: not great but doable, both the tool itself and the handles feel too long and kept folding up
Had to give up two thirds in and was getting a bit painful to use and slipped a lot…but if it’s all you had you wouldn’t starve…give me a SAK opener any day, but no surprise there
Hammerhead over and out





Thanks, Echotech. You could always use the hammer claw for the rest of the opening. ;)
You and the Hammerhead have been great sports throughout the challenge. I've appreciated the use photos and stories.
-
**Day 30 - I'm done!
**
The S557 waving out the end of the challenge.So how did it do for the month?
Well, it did nearly everything I asked it to do. I don't hate it. It won't be relegated to the Drawer of Shame. But...
Pros:
-
I like the 85mm size vs. the larger 91mm SAKs.
-
I found the contoured scales comfortable.
-
I liked having the nail file in a larger SAK. (Though I did miss having the smaller second blade.)
-
I did appreciate the locking knife blade a few times as a safety feature. Especially as the blade on this new SAK is plenty sharp.
Cons:
-
The blade lock release lever was always getting caught on my pocket or in my belt pouch. Why Vic would keep something sharp that sticks out that far is beyond me.
-
The finicky scissors that struggle to cut anything pliable. I use scissors regularly so not knowing if the Wenger-designed ones would cut the item was pretty frustrating.
-
The useless "Universal" wrench. I couldn't come up with a use for it the whole month, not with it stuck in the middle of a five-layer SAK so there's no way to get a grip on anything remotely flush with the surface. I'll stick with my Swiss+Tech Micro-Slim or Leatherman By the Numbers 3 flat wrenches in my pocket EDC kit.
-
The fiddly pliers. Seems like everytime I opened the pliers the slip joint slipped to the wide position (or just part way), unless I opened them very carefully. I could rarely just open and use them.
-
The very tight and very short inline Phillips driver. Yes, it works, but it's hard to use.
-
I don't understand why Victorinox didn't give the bottle opener and inline Phillips the 90 degree stop like the mainline Vic-branded SAKs, unless it has something to do with the push-locking feature.
-
No magnifying glass. I use the ones on my mainline Vic SAKs regularly so missed having that on me. I could break apart the S557 and replace the wrench with a 91mm mag glass, but I'd still be stuck with the finicky scissors, fiddly pliers, short inline Phillips, and in-the-way blade lock release lever.
For a concept, the S557 is great. But for execution, I'm not so sure.
Several of you have said that your challenge tool was OK, but not in comparison to what you usually use. I'm in the same boat. If I didn't know there were better choices out there, I might think the S557 a great SAK. But the tools (scissors, pliers, inline Phillips) are executed far better in mainline Vic SAKs or just don't work at all as part of a thick SAK (wrench).
For me, the S557's main competition is my Swiss Champ or my Deluxe Explorer mod (Explorer + pliers), and it just doesn't match up to them. I'll be going back to them, with a useful small wrench in my pocket.
Thank you, Comis, for putting together this challenge. Though frustrating at times, it was fun. Hearing everyone else's stories easily offset my own frustation.
Best of luck to y'awl. I hope none of you need therapy from this month's experiences.


-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


