EDC Bit Ratchets
-
@m47mu74nt said:
I was looking for one yesterday, nearly pulled the trigger on the engineer stubby ratchet DR54What's the id for the one on your picture?
I did pull the trigger on the DR54, and on cheapos, will see
-
Update: The Steinwhale bits fit perfectly, like it was made for it. Now it's easy to keep a flat head and phillips on the tool even while it's on your keychain. Kinda wish they included security torx in the set, but I'll take what I can get!

From top to bottom: Steinwhale, Wiha, Klein, leatherman

Ironically, although the Wiha double ended bit is shorter than the Klein overall, the shortness is in the middle, not the ends, and is actually just a hair longer than the Klein on the ends.
This means sometimes a bit extension can use the Klein but not the Wiha despite the wiha being shorter. For example, both ratchets can use any of these bits in the ratcheting portion, but the longer ratchet cannot grab the Wiha bit on the end (and barely grabs the klein, almost enough to not be usable in regular practice but would work in a pinch). The shorter ratchet cannot grab either the Wiha or the Klein. Both can use the leatherman flat bits, but they wobble a lot.
An ideal 2nd Generation version of these ratchets would have knurling and a deeper well on the end, like the leatherman extension, with a combo of magnet and wire retention. This would provide redundancy in case one retention method fails, and can use all bits, even the Steinwhale (though you will need assistance removing it).
-
@Blunt Object said:
What an awesome thread! I put together a miniature tool set, knifeless, fits in a non-elastic mag pouch, Vic Card scissors missing from the picture. Should be flight safe according to our national carrier which I use and who allows scissors up to 6cm. The ratchet is the smallest I've found. Wouldn't bet my life on it, but the extender works as a bitholder/driver on its own and Knipex can be used to turn it if force is needed.Great kit!

-
@refleks said:
Update: The Steinwhale bits fit perfectly, like it was made for it. Now it's easy to keep a flat head and phillips on the tool even while it's on your keychain. Kinda wish they included security torx in the set, but I'll take what I can get!
From top to bottom: Steinwhale, Wiha, Klein, leatherman

Ironically, although the Wiha double ended bit is shorter than the Klein overall, the shortness is in the middle, not the ends, and is actually just a hair longer than the Klein on the ends.
This means sometimes a bit extension can use the Klein but not the Wiha despite the wiha being shorter. For example, both ratchets can use any of these bits in the ratcheting portion, but the longer ratchet cannot grab the Wiha bit on the end (and barely grabs the klein, almost enough to not be usable in regular practice but would work in a pinch). The shorter ratchet cannot grab either the Wiha or the Klein. Both can use the leatherman flat bits, but they wobble a lot.
An ideal 2nd Generation version of these ratchets would have knurling and a deeper well on the end, like the leatherman extension, with a combo of magnet and wire retention. This would provide redundancy in case one retention method fails, and can use all bits, even the Steinwhale (though you will need assistance removing it).
Those bits are handy indeed.

It's a shame that the people who sell ratchets don't put that much thought into what would fit the best in their tools. -
Just an FYI, I'm still around, but my laptop and phone started dying at the same time. I'm looking into solutions, but may end up just getting a new one.
I hope to start making reviews again soon.
-
@m47mu74nt said:
I did pull the trigger on the DR54, and on cheapos, will seeCheapos were just some kind of stubby 1/4 hex and square drivers without anything fancy, might have a use for them I'll see.
Still waiting for the DR54 though -
@ReamerPunch said:
Just an FYI, I'm still around, but my laptop and phone started dying at the same time. I'm looking into solutions, but may end up just getting a new one.
I hope to start making reviews again soon.
Don't worry, we'll wait for you

-
Hopefully I'll soon be able to contribute with a review of the Bosh ratchet from the 2607017160 set
-
That's the one I have. Works fine!
-
Cheap from Harbor Freight at $2.99. PITTSBURGH - Ratcheting Right Angle Multi-Bit Screwdriver Set, 8 Piece. SKU #92630


I got one, works fine for my needs. Not very refined, not real heavy duty either, but gets the job done for what I need it for.
Mike
*Note: Not my pictures, linked from HF. -
-
So much news on this topic....
The tiny 711L ratchet is much cheaper now.
I got it for $29 USD, now it's $20.
Or a set with 8 bits for $24.And there is a 4mm bit micro ratchet! :ahhh
LaBear has a folding bit ratchet, with bit set.
I hated the flat LaBear ratchet but this looks quite ok.
Four colours too.



-
Prestacycle sells the T-handle Pro for $23 with the extension and 12 bits. This (plus wallet) was $40. Ratchet and extension alone were $30.
I think it's the same one, but it may be a slightly shorter version?
Still, great value.
-
I saw this ratchet thing. Pass-through design, so not everyone will like it. No bit retention from what I read. Still, inexpensive, and holds two bits, and has a glass-breaker tip. Looks funky, too.

-
Also, I saw a Milwaukee bit ratchet that looks like the Klein one, but the Milwaukee one has a carabiner in the finger loop. Not bad. Not available in Amazon. Might be a local US deal. It even comes with the same bits as the Klein, but the bit holder is set-up for edc too.

-
The Klein ratchet comes in black now.


-
And the Ares comes in black too!

Branded Sundry, from Amazon Japan, comes with sockets and the modular bit holder that the Vessel mini ratchet came with.

-
Hazet 2021SA advent Calendar ratchet set!

-

BGS 115 Special Bit Ratchet
(Can also be found branded by Astro)
Weight: 37g
Length: 99mm
Head width: 14mm
Head clearance with standard bit: 26mm (adds 1mm)
Teeth count: 16
Minimum swing arc: 22.5°
Bit retention: none
In-line driver: no
Bit material: Chromium-Vanadium steel
Handle material: Chromium-Vanadium steel
Price: $17 with 4 ultra-stubby bitsAccessories
The BGS 115 comes with four ultra-stubby bits that have ring springs on them.
The packaging includes a plastic sleeve and a holder for the ratchet and bits. This could be used as a carrying case, but it is quite large and negates the slim profile of the ratchet.
Dimensions
The BGS is the flattest ratchet yet, at only 4.5mm. Like the SK11 ratchet, the BGS has a very narrow head, at only 14mm. It is 99m long, so about average. It only weighs 37g.The bits are only 11mm long, and would have provided the lowest clearance yet, but the ratchet adds 1mm. The SK11 ultra-stubby bits are 12mm long, but the ratchet adds no length to them, so it has the same clearance as the BGS.

Bottom right: 711L, Jackly, Tone, Wera, Hazet, Wiha, Stanley, Topeak, BGS, SK11, Klein, PrestacycleTeeth count
The BGS has only 16 teeth, which is rather low. The ratchet requires some space for it to be able to swing and engage the next tooth, to be able to turn a fastener.Bit retention
The BGS ratchet has no retention. No spring, no ball bearing, no magnet, nothing. That’s why the bits themselves have ring springs.Bit compatibility
The bit compatibility is extremely high, thanks to the almost pass-through head.
It is interesting that the bits it comes with are extremely difficult to insert in the ratchet. Inserting a bit required pliers. This is a first, especially considering that these proprietary bits were made to be used with this ratchet.
Even bits with ball bearing retention cannot be used easily, because the ball bearing will not engage the ratchet head, due to the latter being extremely shallow.The bits themselves have very low compatibility with every ratchet, including the one they come with. Because of the ring spring being on the bits, they are difficult to insert in any ratchet, and they are extremely short, so in most ratchets they will just sink in and be hard to remove. And their springs will only make things harder.

Switch action
The BGS has an oversized and exposed pawl, which acts as its own switch. It has excellent detent, and does not change direction when accidentally bumped into something.Ease of use
The BGS is an ultra-low-profile ratchet, and has the flattest and narrowest head so far. It also adds 1mm to the inserted bit's clearance. It only has 16 teeth, so this still needs some room to move around.
The ratchet is long enough for a four-finger grip. Its ratcheting gear has exposed teeth, so it can be used as a knurled finger wheel, for loose fasteners.
The ratchet has a lanyard hole, so if needed, it can be tethered and prevent misplacement or being dropped.
It is not easy to use the bits that came with it. They are very reluctant to be inserted in the ratchet due to the ring springs, and they are tiny, so not easy to manipulate.
Using standard bits, or pretty much any bits other than the four it comes with is not easy. The ratchet has no retention, so bits will just fall out.Top left: LaBear, Vessel, Anex, Mulwark, SK11, BGS

Construction Quality
The BGS is a sandwich ratchet, with two metal plates holding the internals in place.
The ratcheting gear has no wobble in the frame. The teeth are perfectly machined and the pawl has excellent fitting with the gear. The pawl has great detent. The lanyard hole edges are rounded off and will not damage cords.
The corners are chamfered and the ratchet has no hotspots. There are no gaps between the plates and hard plastic insert.Portability
The BGS 115 is extremely thin and flat and will sit unnoticed in a pocket. No need for multi-tool pouch side-sleeves, edc pouches, and pen sleeves. This can tuck into any thin, flat pocket, along with other gear, and take extremely little space. This of course means that it may just slide out of elastic loops where other ratchets would stay in place.
Thanks to the generous lanyard hole, it can also be clipped to a bag or pack with a quick-release clip or carabiner, or even tethered with a cord to keep it from dropping.
Value
At $17 with only 4 hard-to-use bits and no nice way to carry them, this feels like a mixed bag. The ratchet itself has some nice features, but offers no retention. It will definitely disappear in a pocket or wallet, and it can be used with standard bits, but honestly, the SK11 offers the same bit clearance and has none of the BGS downsides.Conclusion
The BGS 115 is certainly interesting, especially compared to the SK11. They both have a lanyard hole, a knurled finger wheel, are well-made, thin and flat. The BGS is even thinner, so it will occupy even less space.
The big difference is that the SK11 ratchet is easy to use. It has a retention spring for the bits, so it can be used with pretty much any ¼” bit. And it can be found with an ultra-stubby bit kit with 10 bits in a bit holder with a carrying loop. In contrast, the BGS has no retention. Using standard bits will require a modification to keep them in place. The BGS bits do have built-in retention, but they are impossible to insert into the BGS ratchet with just fingers. Even if they were easy to use, the ratchet only comes with four. There is an additional bit kit with 12 more bits, but this will cost an additional $20 USD, and the bits come loose in a box.The benefit of proprietary bits, if any, is that they will work well with the tool they come with. Well, not in this case. It took an extremely long time to insert a bit into the ratchet, with pliers, after getting my fingertips numb with no progress. Being the thinnest ratchet so far puts the BGS on top of at least one list already, but quite poorly so. If you are indeed looking for a thin ratchet and stubby bits, the SK11 with its bit kit is a much, much better option.
Pros
-Extremely thin frame.
-Knurled finger wheel.
-Extremely high bit compatibility.Cons
-The ratchet itself has no retention.
-The included bits are extremely hard to insert into the ratchet.
-Comes with proprietary bits and only four at that.
-The proprietary bit kit contains only 12 additional bits and costs $20.
-No bit holder.
-Only 16 teeth.If you liked this ratchet, help is on the way. Also check out:
-
I'm back! :D
I've written a few more reviews. I'll take pictures and post them soon.
Pending reviews: 711L mini, Tone mini ratchet, Hazet 2021 advent calendar exclusive, Stanley Fatmax mini ratchet

711L, Jackly, Tone, Wera, Hazet, Wiha, Stanley, Topeak, BGS, SK11, Klein, Prestacycle
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
















































