Wuben was due yesterday, OLight was due tomorrow
-
I have a Wuben E7. In green. :D
It's really nifty, small but powerful.
-
Both lights meet my stringent flashlight requirements, or are at least close enough.
The i3E EOS seems like a great little light, although I am not really a fan of the twisty head instead of a switch. I hated twisty heads on Mag Lite Minis, and I still hate them.
Well, hate is a strong word- I suppose it's better to say that on a list of preferences for flashlight activation methods, the twisty headlight thing comes in near, or at the bottom.
That being said, it appears to have a high enough brightness to size ratio and it meets my battery requirements:
Batteries must be a standard, easy to source battery size, easily obtainable from the odd Mom and Pop shop that happens to be open after a natural disaster, or be easily rechargeable, preferably by USB-C.
The AAA battery does fit that requirement, as AA, AAA, 9V and C cells tend to usually be available in many small stores, or are easily borrowed from other sources like TV remotes (not going to watch TV in a power outage anyway) or smoke detectors.
The Wuben G5 also meets that personal standard as it is easily charged by USB-C. Or at least, I assume it is. I haven't actually tried yet, but the port seems quite easy to access, with no fanciness that would obstruct even an odd shaped USB-C cable from fitting into it.
Where the Wuben G5 falls down (IMHO) so far is the interface. Yes, it's easy once you figure it out, but as it took a bit for me to figure out, I don't believe it's as intuitive as the OLight OClip Pro.
My basis for this is my 84 year old father. I sent him the OClip, having faith that right out of the box he'd have it figured out in no time, without even bothering with the instructions.
And he did, which is one of the reasons he loves it. There's no thought necessary, he just uses it and doesn't think about it.
I have no doubt that he would figure out the G5, but it wouldn't be as immediate and out of the box as the OClip. After all, I play with these things frequently and it took me a little while to figure out how everything worked. Honestly, I'm still not 100% I know it all yet, and I may even read the manual.
I'm a fifty year old man- I shouldn't have to read a manual for a flashlight. No one should.
And that's the initial drawback I see to the G5.
Once you know how it works the G5 is quite a nice little light, and it's not complicated so you can use it easily.
But just imagine in an emergency and handing it off to someone else. They are distracted and you have to explain how to use it.
Not ideal.
Def
-
After a few days of playing with the Wuben E5 I have made some observations.
The second LED has multiple light colors: To get to the secondary LED you hold the power button while the main LED is on and it will switch to the secondary LED and you can change the color of this LED by rotating the gear. This LED actually cycles through the colors of the rainbow in order. It goes Red, Orange, Yellow, Green, Blue, Indigo and Violet, or ROY G. BIV as I was taught when I was a kid. I'm not sure what use this function is, but it is kind of neat for when you want to have a blue light for some reason.
The lock switch is a bit annoying: The switch on the side has three positions, and also serves as the charging cover for the USB-C port. Position 1 is a lock, position 2 allows you to use the light and position 3 reveals the charging port. The LED only works when the switch is in Position 2, which is another thing you will have to fiddle about with in the dark.
The magnetic base is okay: Far be it for me to argue with the AI and the Reddit users who supplied the info for the AI review above, but the magnet will actually hold the light. Not as strong a hold as the OClip, so I wouldn't recommend this one as a headlight for night time pogo sticking, but it does hold itself up on stationary objects.
It's a bit awkward: While it may have this cool futuristic steampunk WALL-E type look to it, it's actually not the nicest thing to hold on to. I can imagine that if I tried to use this in the winter with gloves on, I'd probably drop it frequently. I like a flashlight with a little meat to it so I can use it in the winter or when wearing work gloves- and I always wear work gloves. I have had more than my share of incidents involving my hands that could have quickly ended my ASL singing career if I hadn't been extremely lucky or wearing gloves.....
It's complicated: Honestly, it's easy once you get used to it, but I don't want to have to think about operating a flashlight. I want to press a button and have the world be slightly less dark. I don't want to press a button and get no light and then have to fart around with the thing in the dark to try to move the switch to Position 2 only to find out that I am actually adjusting the pocket clip angle instead. And, I don't want to hand it off to someone (as I said earlier) and have them stare at me confused when things are just as dark afterwards and I then have to explain to them how to make light come out.
Overall it is a decent light and I do like the aimable head and magnetic base, and the spinny gear thing for adjusting the brightness is absolutely a good thing. There is a lot to like about this light.
I also like the color changing LED function, although to be honest I am not sure when I would use that feature or why, but it is neat because not a lot of other flashlights do that- in fact, I don't have any other light that does that, nor have I ever had another light that did that.
But I have to say that I don't think it's going to replace any of my other lights any time soon. I like it, it is a decent light, but it just misses that all purpose usability that I expect from a flashlight, a knife, a multitool etc.
Def




-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Both lights meet my stringent flashlight requirements, or are at least close enough.The i3E EOS seems like a great little light, although I am not really a fan of the twisty head instead of a switch. I hated twisty heads on Mag Lite Minis, and I still hate them.
Well, hate is a strong word- I suppose it's better to say that on a list of preferences for flashlight activation methods, the twisty headlight thing comes in near, or at the bottom.
That being said, it appears to have a high enough brightness to size ratio and it meets my battery requirements:
Batteries must be a standard, easy to source battery size, easily obtainable from the odd Mom and Pop shop that happens to be open after a natural disaster, or be easily rechargeable, preferably by USB-C.
The AAA battery does fit that requirement, as AA, AAA, 9V and C cells tend to usually be available in many small stores, or are easily borrowed from other sources like TV remotes (not going to watch TV in a power outage anyway) or smoke detectors.
The Wuben G5 also meets that personal standard as it is easily charged by USB-C. Or at least, I assume it is. I haven't actually tried yet, but the port seems quite easy to access, with no fanciness that would obstruct even an odd shaped USB-C cable from fitting into it.
Where the Wuben G5 falls down (IMHO) so far is the interface. Yes, it's easy once you figure it out, but as it took a bit for me to figure out, I don't believe it's as intuitive as the OLight OClip Pro.
My basis for this is my 84 year old father. I sent him the OClip, having faith that right out of the box he'd have it figured out in no time, without even bothering with the instructions.
And he did, which is one of the reasons he loves it. There's no thought necessary, he just uses it and doesn't think about it.
I have no doubt that he would figure out the G5, but it wouldn't be as immediate and out of the box as the OClip. After all, I play with these things frequently and it took me a little while to figure out how everything worked. Honestly, I'm still not 100% I know it all yet, and I may even read the manual.
I'm a fifty year old man- I shouldn't have to read a manual for a flashlight. No one should.
And that's the initial drawback I see to the G5.
Once you know how it works the G5 is quite a nice little light, and it's not complicated so you can use it easily.
But just imagine in an emergency and handing it off to someone else. They are distracted and you have to explain how to use it.
Not ideal.
Def
Don't have any love for the i3E EOS. My wife and daughter were both recipients of them from me as Olight gave them away like candy from a white van. Ahem. The lights themselves were fine, but the head would twist off all on its own inside a purse. I replaced both with i1R's and they are doing just fine. No self decapitation issues at all.
Much, MUCH prefer the i1R EOS. It doesn't have that annoying habit of losing its head and they hold a charge forever. I actually replaced my i1R with a Fenix E02R on my keychain due to "opinion" on here. Make no mistake, the little Fenix is great but that's two, maybe three years ago I did that and my little i1R's sit patiently waiting, holding their charge for years in backup. I know it's blasphemous to a degree, but the i1R = E02R in pretty much every way from my experience. i3E not so much.
-
That's one of the reasons I really don't like twisty head lights as well.
Def
-
@buggs said:
Don't have any love for the i3E EOS. My wife and daughter were both recipients of them from me as Olight gave them away like candy from a white van. Ahem. The lights themselves were fine, but the head would twist off all on its own inside a purse. I replaced both with i1R's and they are doing just fine. No self decapitation issues at all.Much, MUCH prefer the i1R EOS. It doesn't have that annoying habit of losing its head and they hold a charge forever. I actually replaced my i1R with a Fenix E02R on my keychain due to "opinion" on here. Make no mistake, the little Fenix is great but that's two, maybe three years ago I did that and my little i1R's sit patiently waiting, holding their charge for years in backup. I know it's blasphemous to a degree, but the i1R = E02R in pretty much every way from my experience. i3E not so much.
For what its worth, it seems olight have updated the i3E at some point so it now has 2 o-rings on the head and seems less likely to unscrew in a pocket. the last couple of "free" ones I've gotten are like that.
-
@gustophersmob said:
For what its worth, it seems olight have updated the i3E at some point so it now has 2 o-rings on the head and seems less likely to unscrew in a pocket. the last couple of "free" ones I've gotten are like that.Here’s a pic showing what I mean.
Both styles take right at 3 full turns from completely tight to make the head come off but with the old style, the head clears the o-ring after one turn at which point it can come loose very easily.
With the new style, the second o-ring is still providing friction all the way up till almost the last bit of the third turn. It’s a much better design.

-
Just an amusing follow up to this.
I had told my buddy Abe about how I felt that the Wuben G5 was overly complicated and therefore next to useless IMHO, and he decided I was being too critical and a bit of a crybaby.
So he bought one to show me what an idiot I am being about it.
And then he called me to find out how to use the damned thing because he couldn't figure out how to get anything more than a green light out of it.

He now agrees with me about it, even though he now also is enlightened (pun intended) and knows the Way of the Wuben.
Amusingly, today is another friend's birthday and I bought him an OLight OClip OPro (NOT the UV one, he watches too much NCIS to be allowed to have a UV light!).
He knows Abe and so I had told him the story of Abe Vs Wuben and he thought the OClip was the problem light and wanted to tease Abe that he figured it out immediately.
I felt bad bursting his bubble, but I also did not want to have to teach this guy how to use a Wuben too!
Def
-
I just got my Wuben G5 and I do like it, lotta features that are complicated? too much thinking/remembering? ehh most smart lights are that and are way more expensive. My Olight Oclip is a beast and very well made and more expensive even on sale. For budget and lots of features I appreciate the Wuben. I kinda think it is made more for clip-on use then hand held, something I like a lot, headlamp/pocket-lamp/sleeve-lamp. I do wish the magnet were stronger though.

-
Yeah I agree. The magnet is a bit too pathetic, particularly if you have the wrist strap on it, which I do.
But yes, it is absolutely too complicated.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login