Maybe in the market for a new diver…
-
@nate j said:
I think I’m converging on a Citizen Promaster diver.Looking back at my original specs vs. the models I’m considering:
-
Bracelet with extra links available - Check, and Citizen has even agreed to adjust the size for me up to what I need.
-
Solar powered - Yes, Citizen’s well-regarded Eco-Drive
-
Tool-less micro adjustment or a built-in wetsuit clasp - Yes, on the models I’m considering
-
Luminous hands and markers - check
-
All-analog display - check
-
Second hand - check
-
Day and date - Compromising here, as these have date but not day
-
Water resistance: Ideally at least 200M - Yes, Diver’s 200M
-
Size: Prefer a larger case diameter - 41mm - I’d prefer larger, but

-
Price: I was originally hoping for under $200, or even under $300 - Not quite, but I can probably get one for under $350 or so, if I can catch a 25% off sale.
-
Crystal - Strong preference for sapphire - check
Now, to pick a color, since there are 3 options:
Stainless steel, black face & bezel (BN0261-51E) - Seems like the classic, conservative choice. Similar to most of the watches I’ve owned. Offers the best contrast and readability, since the hands and markers are a pale green.
Stainless steel, blue face & bezel (BN0260-54L) - Blue seems less serious and more fun than black. But I can see myself looking at the blue and thinking, “Hmmm, kinda wish I’d gotten the black.” Harder to envision the reverse.
“Gold-tone” stainless steel, green face & bezel (BN0262-59W) - I think this looks fantastic, but have a few reservations…
“Gold-tone” stainless steel means there is a thin layer of gold or gold-colored metal on top of stainless steel. I’m fairly hard on watches, and I’m looking for something to wear daily or almost daily, hopefully for years. I would be disappointed if the “gold-tone” started to wear off/wear through after 1, or 2, or even 5+ years. I have seen watches where this has happened, and it looks like smurf IMO.
Also, I feel like it might be too flashy/gaudy/over-the-top for some occasions.
So, which color would you get, and why?

I'm a bad reference point for your color selection. I've been eyeing up the BN0264-53E. Meets your specs but not your price point, by a fair margin. Sounds like your last color choice would be my first.

I have the sibling to the NY0155-58X with fully lumed face. Mine is not and I regret not getting the NY0155-58X as mine is white faced. But both of those are automatics, not solar powered so also not meeting your criteria. The lume on my Citizen is second only to the Zelos watches I own (I don't believe they make any solar watches).
From your post black on black is the way to go. You'll second guess yourself on the other two, the gold not being you at all. Blue is interesting but probably the most common of watch face colors out there. Seems like you're looking for a true tool watch and the best readability of the bunch. I have a couple of watches I'll be parting with because as I age my eyesight ain't so great, even for an analog watch and in poor light, pfft, forget it.
Good luck, good sir.
-
-
@nate j said:
I think I’m converging on a Citizen Promaster diver.Looking back at my original specs vs. the models I’m considering:
-
Bracelet with extra links available - Check, and Citizen has even agreed to adjust the size for me up to what I need.
-
Solar powered - Yes, Citizen’s well-regarded Eco-Drive
-
Tool-less micro adjustment or a built-in wetsuit clasp - Yes, on the models I’m considering
-
Luminous hands and markers - check
-
All-analog display - check
-
Second hand - check
-
Day and date - Compromising here, as these have date but not day
-
Water resistance: Ideally at least 200M - Yes, Diver’s 200M
-
Size: Prefer a larger case diameter - 41mm - I’d prefer larger, but

-
Price: I was originally hoping for under $200, or even under $300 - Not quite, but I can probably get one for under $350 or so, if I can catch a 25% off sale.
-
Crystal - Strong preference for sapphire - check
Now, to pick a color, since there are 3 options:
Stainless steel, black face & bezel (BN0261-51E) - Seems like the classic, conservative choice. Similar to most of the watches I’ve owned. Offers the best contrast and readability, since the hands and markers are a pale green.
Stainless steel, blue face & bezel (BN0260-54L) - Blue seems less serious and more fun than black. But I can see myself looking at the blue and thinking, “Hmmm, kinda wish I’d gotten the black.” Harder to envision the reverse.
“Gold-tone” stainless steel, green face & bezel (BN0262-59W) - I think this looks fantastic, but have a few reservations…
“Gold-tone” stainless steel means there is a thin layer of gold or gold-colored metal on top of stainless steel. I’m fairly hard on watches, and I’m looking for something to wear daily or almost daily, hopefully for years. I would be disappointed if the “gold-tone” started to wear off/wear through after 1, or 2, or even 5+ years. I have seen watches where this has happened, and it looks like smurf IMO.
Also, I feel like it might be too flashy/gaudy/over-the-top for some occasions.
So, which color would you get, and why?

No kidding I just had one in my hands today as I dropped off one of my Orient Perpetual Calendars for repair. He only sells Luminox and Citizen, and there was the Promaster Eco Diver.
Very light. Felt much lighter than the G-Shock GST-S110 I was wearing at the time but much more legible with the black dial and white markings and hands. Everything stood out nicely especially the seconds hand. ISO 6425.
Really nice piece for $350, and he was offering 25% off of that so I could have walked out of there with it for $263 plus tax. Certainly less than a questionable, "near mint" SKX007 plus $100 shipping from Japan off of eBay.
Unfortunately I have some serious truck engine repair with the initial tear down this week, so I have to hold off. But although I am into automatic movement, this Eco Drive felt as light as my G-Shock G100 (hard to believe THESE are up around $100 or more now) and, like it, requires nothing to just put it on and go!
I think it would be a great choice. I liked the black, but I could see going for the dark blue as well. Anything else in this particular platform would seem strange, like more of a statement than a tool like this is meant to be.
-
-
I am going to wish you the best of luck with the eco drive citizen. I have had 2 failures in the past. both being on Promaster pilot watches. Maybe they have improved it lately. Never had issues with any other solar watch brand.
-
@kirk13 said:
Nate, while they won't meet a number of your requirements , have you had a look at Steeldiver and Addiesdive on AliExpress? They get good reviews on a number of FB watch groups and the start point on the prices aren't bad.I've not got any personal experience of Addiesdive ( dive style watches not being my thing, well not yet anyway), but I did order a Steelflier Dirty Dozen homage for around the £40 mark, and its stunning
What I find very interesting is that one Chinese knockoff brand is distancing itself from another Chinese knockoff brand for stealing their designs and logos. Well, not knock-off per se, since they aren't attaching the Seiko name to their Turtles. But it is interesting. No problem undercutting Seiko but dang it, when AddiesDive undercut SteelDive, the gloves were off.
Still, I wouldn't mind trying either one especially since DKS finds them suitable to the task and undoubtedly has more real dive experience than me. I just swim at the beach and deepest I go is snorkeling
-
@Echotech said:
All three are nice looking watches, I always go the green option when there is one, but I too have my reservations about the gold taking scratches. The blue is classy and I’d probably choose that, the black a little plain but you’d never regret it, classicI think you’re probably right about never regretting the black.
Have you had any experiences with their gold coating?
@buggs said:
I'm a bad reference point for your color selection. I've been eyeing up the BN0264-53E. Meets your specs but not your price point, by a fair margin. Sounds like your last color choice would be my first.
From your post black on black is the way to go. You'll second guess yourself on the other two, the gold not being you at all. Blue is interesting but probably the most common of watch face colors out there. Seems like you're looking for a true tool watch and the best readability of the bunch.
Looks like the BN0264-53E is essentially the same watch as the others, but in a limited edition color.
@ThundahBeagle said:
No kidding I just had one in my hands today as I dropped off one of my Orient Perpetual Calendars for repair. He only sells Luminox and Citizen, and there was the Promaster Eco Diver.Very light. Felt much lighter than the G-Shock GST-S110 I was wearing at the time but much more legible with the black dial and white markings and hands. Everything stood out nicely especially the seconds hand. ISO 6425.
Really nice piece for $350, and he was offering 25% off of that so I could have walked out of there with it for $263 plus tax.
I think it would be a great choice. I liked the black, but I could see going for the dark blue as well. Anything else in this particular platform would seem strange, like more of a statement than a tool like this is meant to be.
As I was reading the reviews on the Citizen website, I ran across several that said things like “Glad they made a diver that isn’t huge” and “looks great on my 7-inch wrist”. I did want something bigger, but was prepared to accept this 41mm case diameter for a watch that hit so many of the specs I wanted. But now I’m wondering if it will look like a toy or otherwise appear silly on my 10+” wrist. Having seen one in person, what’s your take on the size?
@Chako said:
I am going to wish you the best of luck with the eco drive citizen. I have had 2 failures in the past. both being on Promaster pilot watches. Maybe they have improved it lately. Never had issues with any other solar watch brand.Wow, that’s disappointing! I can see how multiple failures would make you leery of the brand. I have an older Citizen PCAT that has been solid for years, and they seem to have a pretty good reputation overall. Hoping yours were the rare lemons that snuck past QC, and not part of a larger trend.
I might very well go with the gold & green (let’s face it, something like this is as close as I’ll likely ever come to a real gold watch), if I could get a warm and fuzzy feeling that I would never have any issues with wear through or scratch through of the coating, but I just don’t have that feeling at present. I suppose I could pull the trigger on this one, and relegate it to beater status if the coating ever showed any issues.
As several folks have pointed out, black is classic and probably the safest choice.
So maybe I can make some progress and cross off the blue?

-
@nate j said:
Have you had any experiences with their gold coating?I haven’t nate but did a quick search on fleabay for second hand gold Citizen divers and found a few, they all looked fine
No idea how old this one is but the only issue I can see is on the clasp of the strap
This one has some marks/wear on the gold on the back, but overall also good
I always like green, so the gold and green looks great to me, think we can discard blue from your comment above, so it’s between the green/gold and black/silver, statement piece or classic
Can’t go wrong with either I suspect, always fun making these choices

-
@nate j said:
I think you’re probably right about never regretting the black...As I was reading the reviews on the Citizen website, I ran across several that said things like “Glad they made a diver that isn’t huge” and “looks great on my 7-inch wrist”. I did want something bigger, but was prepared to accept this 41mm case diameter for a watch that hit so many of the specs I wanted. But now I’m wondering if it will look like a toy or otherwise appear silly on my 10+” wrist. Having seen one in person, what’s your take on the size?
Wow, that’s disappointing! I can see how multiple failures would make you leery of the brand. I have an older Citizen PCAT that has been solid for years, and they seem to have a pretty good reputation overall. Hoping yours were the rare lemons that snuck past QC, and not part of a larger trend.
Color: the blue is nice and adds some pizazz, for sure. And with a bracelet, it is suit and tie ready. The black is classic, simple, to the point.
Size: Well, I'm on the leaner side of almost 6 feet, and have, I think, a 7+ inch wrist. Wearing my GST-S110 and then switching back to my G100 or an Orient Perpetual Calendar, they seem small at first, but they are not, the GST is rather on the large side.
I'm betting that this Eco Drive Promaster will look great on a larger wrist, no problem at all.
EcoDrive Failures: What I am reading is that these Citizen EcoDrives have routinely lasted 20 years, very often 30 and even 40. My GSTS110 is also "Tough Solar.". It looked like it lost power after I left it sit a long time. I wish I had realized I did not need to change out the batter and all I had to do was let it sit in the sun for a day.
I'm partial to automatic movement, I just love the fact that the more active you are , the less you worry about winding your watch or changing a battery. My G100 lasts for something like 7 years.
But in this case, at this price, why not try the Promaster Eco? I was impressed. If it holds up, I'm sure you will be too
-
Well, I ordered the black.
I loved the look of the gold & green, but just couldn’t shake the feeling that the gold coating would get worn through or scratched off and look like smurf long before there were any other issues with the watch.
I ordered direct through Citizen. I probably could have gotten it a bit cheaper elsewhere, but they agreed to size the bracelet up to 10 3/4” for me at no extra charge prior to shipping, so that is worth something.
Hoping it will be a faithful companion for years (if not decades) to come.
Thanks again to awl for the input and suggestions!
-
Congratulations nate

I’d have gone for the black too but only after a few days of thinking about it ….when you first posted, I’d have been super tempted by the gold/green but I think divers look best in silver, so probably would’ve chosen the silver/blue. But yesterday after looking at the pics again, the black would be the one

-
I think that was a very wise decision. I would be leery of gold plated finishes myself. Now all that remains are plenty of photos of the newest addition once it gets in your possession.

-
@Echotech said:
Congratulations nate
I’d have gone for the black too but only after a few days of thinking about it ….when you first posted, I’d have been super tempted by the gold/green but I think divers look best in silver, so probably would’ve chosen the silver/blue. But yesterday after looking at the pics again, the black would be the one

@Chako said:
I think that was a very wise decision. I would be leery of gold plated finishes myself. Now all that remains are plenty of photos of the newest addition once it gets in your possession.
gents!There will definitely be pics…
-
Well, smurf. After placing the order 5 days ago, and jumping through the hoops to make sure they were going to size the bracelet correctly, I received an email today which read, in part:
“After reviewing your order, we discovered an inventory discrepancy. We made every effort to locate and obtain the item to fulfill your order; however, despite our attempts, we were unable to secure additional inventory. As a result, the item is unfortunately no longer available. We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience. At this time, we do not have an estimated restocking date.
Because we are unable to fulfill your order, it will be canceled.“
I verified that the black does now show out of stock on the website. Blue and green/gold both appear to still be in stock.
It might be a sign, but a sign of what? That I should order the blue? That i should order the green/gold? That I shouldn’t order a new watch right now? (I do feel like the need is less urgent now that I have my Citizen PCAT back on a bracelet.)
-
Get to looking at local watch and jewelry shops, especially if you find one that sells Citizen. Like I said, my guy nearby has one at a 25% discount. This is making me think I should grab it
-
Amazon. 47% off citizen pro Master
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Amazon. 47% off citizen pro MasterI appreciate the heads up, TB. But I searched for the three model numbers I was considering, and didn’t find any of them.
One of the things I noticed about the promaster line is that it’s very diverse: some solar, some automatic, some straps, some bracelets, some sapphire, some mineral crystal. One really has to read the fine print haha.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login