Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
Day 27
Trying to show why I don't love the Case Barlow. It's just so flat. Most of my others have some rounding on the bolster, a flare towards the back, etc. I don't know if its specific to these scales, or the pattern in general. It's surprising how much of a difference it makes in hand feel.
[attach id=0 msg=2589247]
Day 28
Queen single on the Queen felt.
[attach id=1 msg=2589247]


-
Day 28

Rough Rider again today. Helped with a very exciting mail call of various SAKs, including two Wengers (Wengerinoxes?) from the 60s or so.
-
I bet you have enough different length SAKs to get one of the nice collector badges. Best wishes. G
[attach id=0 msg=2589252]
-
Day 28
Used the Colonial Barlow Electrician to open a package today. My birthday present to myself arrived. I bought the Lionsteel Workhorse Barlow with olivewood scales. I justified the expense because I liked the looks of it, but my initial thought is it is disappointing because it is uncomfortable in the hand. The back of the blades stick out of the handle a bit proud, and bite into your hand no matter which blade you open. I hope I can overcome this, because it was kind of expensive.


-
@Alan K. said:
David, should you be going back to work so soon?Doc didn't say I need to take any time off. Feel good today. Chest a little sore and I'm tired but ok. If I didn't have things to do today I would have taken this as my day off instead of later on the week. The pill in the pocket medicine I was on which I used maybe 3 times in 10 years is now my twice a day pill. But on the bright side my heart has beat smoother today than it has in a long time. I'm looking at a future ablation but for now we go with this.
-
@Alan K. said:
My birthday present to myself arrived. I bought the Lionsteel Workhorse Barlow with olivewood scales. I justified the expense because I liked the looks of it, but my initial thought is it is disappointing because it is uncomfortable in the hand. The back of the blades stick out of the handle a bit proud, and bite into your hand no matter which blade you open. I hope I can overcome this, because it was kind of expensive.Hmmm…
I can’t recall finding mine uncomfortable to hold. I may have bring it back out for the last day or two of the challenge to see if I can replicate the problem.
-
30 Day Barlow Knife Challenge
Day 21 of 30
CamcoIt was a busy weekend, but I did find time to smoke a couple of turkey breasts and bake some banana bread.

-
@PitCarver said:
Breezy time, around here, usually march through the first of May, might have told some folks to go fly a kits, some times.

@Sos24 said:
Day 27
After this challenge with the pictures and conversations on Rough Riders, I decided I would give one a chance. But I ended up with two because I couldn’t choose.Will have to wait until tomorrow for the second.
Very nice selection!
@IMR4198 said:
An old timer told me that when you got old everything started to slow down and then just finally stopped. He ran a little country store. I don't know if he sold Barlow knives on a cardboard display by the cash register, or not. Probably did.
Best wishes, G
:DI miss seeing those types of old country stores.
@mathmitch7 said:
This is an absolutely gorgeous knife!!Thanks Mitch!

@David Bowen said:
Doc didn't say I need to take any time off. Feel good today. Chest a little sore and I'm tired but ok. If I didn't have things to do today I would have taken this as my day off instead of later on the week. The pill in the pocket medicine I was on which I used maybe 3 times in 10 years is now my twice a day pill. But on the bright side my heart has beat smoother today than it has in a long time. I'm looking at a future ablation but for now we go with this.Glad to hear you're up and about and doing better.
@GA1dad said:
30 Day Barlow Knife Challenge
Day 21 of 30
CamcoIt was a busy weekend, but I did find time to smoke a couple of turkey breasts and bake some banana bread.
We ate dinner not too long ago but man oh man does that look good!
-
<u>Day 28</u>
After a bit of a rough day at work, there was a nice surprise waiting for me in the mail.

-
Day 29
Colonial Barlow opened some packages. Yeah, it's kinda' dull, especially on the bubble wrap. I haven't given it a good sharpening yet.


-
Day 26
Remington-marked Granddaddy helped open a fresh bundle…

-
Day 27
Chowed down on some Indian food while the RRR Granddaddy looked on.
The dish is this restaurant’s take on paneer 65.

-
Day 29
Next to last day. I think I have gained a better outlook on the old Colonial Barlows. My autocorrupt on MTO always puts red squiggles under Barlows. It wants Barlow's, Barlow, or Barrows. Does anyone else get ads on their browser page that has the singular of knife as knive? The plural gets displayed as kniveses.
Years ago if you pulled out a knife while talking with some others. Cleaning finger nails or opening something. Maybe on the street corner. Some friends. Some not. You could hear the question from some wag. "Is that a good knife, or just a Barlow?" Meant as a minor put-down. Not enough to start a fight over. There was a variant of that quip. "Is that a good knife, or just a KaBar?"
That kind of smirky comment might just be something local in nature. I would be interested if some other old timer in the south, like maybe our friend PitCarver ever heard it. The comment has died out now since there are no cardboard displays of dollar Barlow kniveses in dime store windows or gas stations. Actually, the old dime stores are gone as well. There was a firearm equivalent to the Barlow slur. "Is that a good gun, or just a Marlin?"
Today's answer to a smarmy comment would be a central digit display or a vocalized equivalent. That would have started a fight in the old days. I never heard anybody use either when I was a pup around grown-ups. I think the KaBar comment wasn't really deserved. Even at the time. Who has a right to be snooty about someone else's personal bric-a-brac? Not a word would be uttered about a battered old hat or pants dirty enough to stand up by themselves. And possibly walk by themselves. But pull out a knive to cut a chew from a twist of tobacco and here comes the "Is that a good knife or just a _____?"
One more photo. It is just an Imperial.
Best wishes, G
:P
[attach id=0 msg=2589290]
-
Day 29
This challenge may end tomorrow but it's given me an appreciation for the humble Balow.

-
Day 29
GEC 86 AAPK SFO

-
Day 29
Second day with the Lionsteel Workhorse Barlow. I've used the clip point blade to cut back some pineapple leaves that were encroaching on a walkway (no camera handy) and used the Wharncliffe blade to eat a pear. Both blades are nice and sharp. While I do feel the shoulder of the blades against my index finger it's not enough of a deal breaker to not carry and enjoy this knife. The Wharncliffe blade is awesome, and that is, after all, why I bought this knife.


-
Day 29
Clean, clear lines laid out today on this clear morning.
A simple LM and White boned Barlow
[attach id=0 msg=2589342]
The BARLOW pattern is a touch small for my hands, I prefer a single blade model over the models that include a pen blade. Just for ease of blade extraction!
The advantage of the BARLOW is how easy it carries in the pocket. And the stout CLIP POINT Blade most of mine have. It is a natural slicer and poky pointed sticker when needed.

-
Next to last day. I think I have gained a better outlook on the old Colonial Barlows. ~~~
As read your perspective, I really think it is a regional thing…
I remember my first BARLOW, a gift from daughter Christmas 2020, a CASE Holiday edition. Isolated Christmas celebration, and last one spent with my wife.
[attach id=0 msg=2589348]
And, this month was thinking why, I had ignored this pattern.
I think it was a regional thing, influenced by those I grew up around.
First, my grandmother bought flour in 10# or 20# bags (cloth). And helping her transfer the flour from the bag to a metal can, there frequently was a package in the bag wrapped in wax paper. A knife, a barlow, if my memory is correct. She would unwrap the item, smooth out the wax paper, fold neatly and slide in between pages of a worn Cook book. Then toss the knife in her junk drawer along another 10 or more like shaped knives.
She did not offer to me, she knew I had a knife in my pocket, and a fixed blade dangling from my belt when I cut sweet corn or trimmed celery.
Second, was my grandfather’s subtle comments. He operated a veggie road side stand to move his veggies, mostly sweet corn and tomatoes. His 2nd income, as working nights at the paper mill was prime income until he retired.
He smoked his cigars, and carried an equal ended knife for trimming the stogies as needed.
But, he was well rooted in the area, neighborhood for north side of town. Visitors came by frequently to say hi, chit chat, actually interrupting us from our work.
I recall most of these fellas would be chewing tobacco and used a barlow like blade to cut their chew.
Eventually they always asked, “do you have any seconds, I could get cheaper for the MRS, to fix up.” Meaning free stuff! Gramps always said the same thing, “I don’t grow no second rate veggies!” If varmints get in them, I cut the bad away and I feed my family with that!”
Then they would pick a sack of corn and tomatoes, pay and drive away.
Grandpa was disgusted, “dam moochers!” “Use cheap knives and want something for nothing. “
So, I think watching those interactions shaped my brain somewhat.
How a man walked, how he talked, tools he used, where he spat his chew, and how he treated others says a lot.
Funny thing is, my Grandpa’s cousins were CIGAR Makers, often at the end of the day, we would ride downtown and visited them, gramps would ask after a brief visit if they had any irregulars he could buy? Sometimes yes. Most times NO! But I was always offered to help sweep up, and I walked away with a dime, sometimes a quarter, and on good days a half dollar. Real rare SILVER DOLLAR! After Sixty plus years, those are still in my dresser drawer. Never spent them.
Good Memories.
PS: I named my first born, after my Grandpa, a great man that I grew up with. And each of my kids knew as their great grand father.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

