IMPORTANT UPDATE- PLEASE READ
-
You did ask what we think about the changes based on what little we have seen so far. Of course, we already had light and dark modes that could be easily toggled. Evidently a lot of members never knew it, based on a post I made about it.
The personal space graphic treatment doesn't interest me. If there is an option to leave it without some sort of annoying CGI scenery, then that is what I will do. I like photos from our friends. Visits via posts to the same people. I like the members. I don't like AI stuff and computer generated imagery. I have turned off dozens of movies because they were loaded with unrealistic, overblown special effects.
I agree with friend Alan. I will wait and see what is offered and try to adapt.
Best wishes, G -
@IMR4198 said:
You did ask what we think about the changes based on what little we have seen so far. Of course, we already had light and dark modes that could be easily toggled. Evidently a lot of members never knew it, based on a post I made about it.
The personal space graphic treatment doesn't interest me. If there is an option to leave it without some sort of annoying CGI scenery, then that is what I will do. I like photos from our friends. Visits via posts to the same people. I like the members. I don't like AI stuff and computer generated imagery. I have turned off dozens of movies because they were loaded with unrealistic, overblown special effects.
I agree with friend Alan. I will wait and see what is offered and try to adapt.
Best wishes, GAbsolutely I asked. And I appreciate the feedback.
There's no AI related BS on this site. It is designed to emulate this forum as much as possible. Some buttons may be a bit different, it may look a bit different and there may be a few new features, but in the end, it's a basic forum.
It may look a little different, but it will be MTO. Some things may work slightly differently, but it will still be MTO.
This wasn't a decision we made lightly. It wasn't us being jazzed about fancy new software, at was absolutely necessary- you all noticed us offline for a day last week, right?
As for the user page, well, if you don't add an avatar, there's a default avatar, but it's ours. We could have done the same here but it's one of those things we never got finished.
If you don't upload a cover photo, it's just a blank bar- no weird AI generated crapola.
Just like this software, there's no AI stuff on the new forum. There's Private Messages, there will be merit badges (OUR merit badges), smileys (OUR smileys) and everything you are used to here. And, when we get there and anything is different or not working (there are bound to be issues, we've had 20 years to get this place working the way we like it) let me know and I'll see if I can fix it.
Changes that we will have- you can tag folks, and they will get a notification. No, not a text message or an email or anything like that, just a teeny little number appearing at the top, which will tell you things when you click on it, including private messages and tags. Not intrusive, not annoying, just there, quietly in the corner.
Also, when you reply here and someone replies before you do, currently you get a message saying that someone has. On the new software, when someone else posts, you don't have to reload the page, it just shows up. Much more convenient.
And, when you want to post a photo, you can drag and drop it in, rather than going through the uploader doodad we have now.
The changes are the kind that are going to work for members, not the ones that are going to change the experience any. I went through the big software change at Knifeforums back in the day and I spent weeks helping guys get their accounts back, get logged in and figure out the new software. I know first hand what an absolute nightmare it is, and I have done all I can to make sure that the transition is as smooth as possible.
It's also why we have been operating the same software for twenty years, and why I'd rather be running SMF for the next twenty as well.
But, everything breaks down eventually. The lifespan of most successful forums is 7 years. We have been working with SMF for three times that. It has served us well, and there's no shame in saying good bye to it.
I hope you all will all give the new software a chance, and give me a chance to fix or change whatever we don't like about it.
Def

-
The drag and drop photo set-up sounds like a big improvement. At least on the surface. Like anything else, it will be a learning experience the first time. The 'tag' feature is unfamiliar to me. Possibly it is a common feature on forums. I was pleased to see there was no mention of 'like' and 'dislike' tallies at the bottom of a post. I haven't ever been on a forum with that sort of nonsense but I always hated that sort of thing. Everyone on here is polite enough to realize that a down vote on a post will likely cause friction in the forum. I don't like everything I read here. Who does? I do have enough sense to not bellyache about it. I realize I post some strange stuff, but everyone either just lets it float on by or maybe decide not to read the drivel that I dribble. Some people might enjoy it. Who knows? I don't remember any of the stuff I posted in the past. Sometimes I go back to check a thread, and I see where I posted something. At times I can't believe I said what is written, and other times I get a giggle out of it. Either way, nobody is giving me (or anybody else) a thumbs down for it. I do appreciate good manners and try not to annoy others.
I am sure there will be some shake down and adjustments for the new format. There always is in any change. If I see something troubling, I will send a PM. If I see something I like, I will post that in open forum. Live and let live. I am willing to give the new structure a chance and see how it works.
Best wishes, G -
Every forum platform ships with the upvote/downvote/reputation system. AT least, every forum platform I have seen does.
We tried it here once. People asked for it, so we tried it and it did not go well.
It is not an experiment I am in a hurry to repeat, and I'm not going to say it was the first thing I turned off, but it was definitely early in the process.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login