Swisstool X Vs Original Supertool
-
It's not hard to find someone to rant the glories of a Swisstool around here, so by matching them so easily you've just made me want a Supertool more! (after I get my hands on a PST II)

-
Looked good to me- there were a few points I didn't agree with, but then if I wanted to agree with everything in a forum, I wouldn't have left it open for others to join!
Good point about the shorter plier head- that's not one I normally think of, but the SwissTool's nose is indeed a little stubby. I like that because I usually find myself doing more grunt work than fine work and I always worry about pointy plier heads.
Also, I prefer combination tools- all the dedicated flatheads in the world won't help you if you need to open a can or strip wire!
Def
-
I'm glad it was ok, I'm no writer so do please ignore all the bad grammar. :)
Def, I just think that combination tools are great when you are trying to squeeze as much into the smallest size possible, but with regards to a heavy duty full sized tool I prefer dedicated drivers that will do the job better.
Nomad, I am glad you are now more keen on the Supertool. My intention here was certainly not to put people off the Supertool as I still regard it highly and will still continue to use it as well as my Swisstool.
-
I'm glad it was ok, I'm no writer so do please ignore all the bad grammar.
You guys invented the language, you should be able to use it! :P
Like I said, it's all a matter of preferences, which is why there are so many tools out there. This is not the SwissTool forum, nor is it for folks who only appreciate the SwissTool. I happen to like it (although I am also fond of both SuperTools as well) but my main interest is helping folks find the tool that is right for them.
Hell look at this review and you'll see I even tried to say nice things about them!
Def
-
Well done , thats a great review . I am a big fan of supertools and I look apon them as my 2nd choice .I dont have one at the moment but had a ST 200 in the past . Benner be carefull when cleaning the supertool . If you open all the tools fully on one handle how are you going to close them :P :D
Dunc
-
@dunc5 said:
Well done , thats a great review . I am a big fan of supertools and I look apon them as my 2nd choice .I dont have one at the moment but had a ST 200 in the past . Benner be carefull when cleaning the supertool . If you open all the tools fully on one handle how are you going to close them :P :DDunc
Cheers buddy! :)
Don't worry I've heard various stories of people making that mistake so I intend to learn from them. ;)
-
I never did that with a SuperTool, but I did do it with a Schrade Tough Tool and had to use another tool to pry open the lock. That was before I realized that in each handle, pressing down on one of the non locking tools will release the lock!
Def
-
@Defender said:
I never did that with a SuperTool, but I did do it with a Schrade Tough Tool and had to use another tool to pry open the lock. That was before I realized that in each handle, pressing down on one of the non locking tools will release the lock!Def
I think I read a post somewhere of someone else doing that on a Schrade TT and they then threw it away! :(
-
Waste of a decent tool in my mind, although I can certainly understand the frustration!
I am tempted to get one of the new ones and compare it to my old USA made TT, but the thought of Taylor Cutlery getting any of my money directly or indirectly makes me feel ill. At least the cheap tools you see in the bargain bins at Wal Mart aren't trying to pretend they are something they are not, but I won't get into that rant again! :P
Def
-
Great review there mate, you can see you put a lot of time and effort into it :)
You had me on the edge of my seat, when i thought the LM might win :D And while I don't agree with all your points I can see you've been fair :)
-
@micky d said:
Great review there mate, you can see you put a lot of time and effort into it :)You had me on the edge of my seat, when i thought the LM might win :DAnd while I don't agree with all your points I can see you've been fair :)
Good good, I did try to be as fair as possible. :)
I'm glad people don't agree with everything I have said, would make forums a little dull if everyone just agreed all the time. :)
What don't you agree with then buddy? I am happy to re-test some areas to have another look.
-
Silly things really like your saw test (not a big deal I know) the Vic saw is a lot more effective because it cuts both ways, and due to the design of the teeth, there more of less self cleaning :)
And the lack of butterfly action on the swisstool, well because I've used mine for a good long while it's not a problem, I just hook one of the handles over my belt and rotate, not as quick I'll grant you, but it's one of those adaptations you make when you've had a tool for a while :)
As I say I'm not desputing your findings at all, it's just not neccassarily how I'd see it, but then like you say it would be a dull ole world if we all agreed :)
-
@micky d said:
Silly things really like your saw test (not a big deal I know) the Vic saw is a lot more effective because it cuts both ways, and due to the design of the teeth, there more of less self cleaning :)And the lack of butterfly action on the swisstool, well because I've used mine for a good long while it's not a problem, I just hook one of the handles over my belt and rotate, not as quick I'll grant you, but it's one of those adaptations you make when you've had a tool for a while :)
As I say I'm not desputing your findings at all, it's just not neccassarily how I'd see it, but then like you say it would be a dull ole world if we all agreed :)
I was going to ask you about the saws actually, as I know you are a saw user and as I said I don't think I had ever used one on a multitool before. :D
I do still prefer the butterfly opening of the Supertool, but this is offset by the Swisstools outside opening tools that make tool selection just that bit faster.
-
I think the supertool is the best the past had to offer, but it was just to damn fiddley for me ::)
-
Very thorough, thoughtful review, Benner. Bravo!
I own both tools, too, though I retired the Leatherman Supertool in favor of the SwissTool X and Spirit which are easier to use.
Another point in favor of the Supertool is its lanyard hole placement at the end of the handle rather than the SwissTool's more difficult to use lanyard hole at 1.3 inches from the end.
The Supertool's pointier pliers are better suited for electronics and jewelry work. The SwissTool's blunter pliers are stronger at the tip, making them better for mechanic type work.
-
Exellent review! You really did a great job on this review! The comparisons were very fair as well. There is one thing I think you should have included- the wire strippers. But the SwissTool would be an obvious winner because of the great strippers found on it plus it has a scraper too. BTW, what is the purpose of the wirebender? Obviously to bend wire but what is the need for that? Great job!
-
To fix bent wire that slipped through quality control?
It's like a pipe bender, only on a smaller scale. You can really bend the heck out of a coat hanger with it, and with greater precision than you can do with the pliers.
Def
-
Oh, I see. To tell you the truth I have owned SAK's for years and never really noticed that feature up until I looked at the SwissTool manual and it says wire bender! Thanks
-
Thanks for the great review and an enjoyable read.
I don't really understand your lock mechanism comparison though. I've used lots of MT and the Supertool is by far the safest and it's why I still carry it. Is it less convenient? Oh my yes, but much safer. There is no release mechanism to push on by accident. If for some reason a lock would fail on a Super Tool the edge of the blades point toward the middle of the handle, causing the blade edge to contact the other handle instead of your fingers.
I think it is far less dangerous to tap a knuckle against a blade while pulling out another tool to disengage the lock, than it would be to hit a release lever while white knuckle cutting and have the blade fold on your fingers.
Just my thoughts,
Greg. -
@GMArthur said:
Thanks for the great review and an enjoyable read.I don't really understand your lock mechanism comparison though. I've used lots of MT and the Supertool is by far the safest and it's why I still carry it. Is it less convenient? Oh my yes, but much safer. There is no release mechanism to push on by accident. If for some reason a lock would fail on a Super Tool the edge of the blades point toward the middle of the handle, causing the blade edge to contact the other handle instead of your fingers.
I think it is far less dangerous to tap a knuckle against a blade while pulling out another tool to disengage the lock, than it would be to hit a release lever while white knuckle cutting and have the blade fold on your fingers.
Just my thoughts,
Greg.A very good point. The Supertools simplicity is a large part of it's toughness and the reason why I like it.
While I agree with what you said, because of the way the Swisstools mechanism is designed I would say it would be very difficult to release it by mistake. Also, it is far easier and safer to release than the Supertools one. I always find that when unlocking the Supertool, the tool that has been selected to aid the unlocking pings back quickly and this has caught my hands a couple of times.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login