Gerber Balance
-
Its a shame the pliers are so thin. They look almost LM squirt like in terms of their narrowness and profile.
I can see the reason, its to fit the knife and scissors in the outside opening configuration.
But that isn't a necessity, the Vic Spirit handles this perfectly to give one example, the long deep tools like its file, knife, saw, and scissors are all at the edge of the handles, and reside under the curved lip, so they don't take up any extra space, and the pliers are nice and fat.
Now I don't know if that is possible with the sliding plier head gerbers, but I always find it a shame when you have a tool like this and the pliers seem too small for the tool, like a 'shrunken head' almost.
-
Ok, If we are comparing the pliers to a SQUIRT then a few size comparison pictures are in order because that's not a fair comparison. My bad for not doing a size reference shot until now :) This is the Balance next to my old JUICE C2. I don't have a Squirt. The Plier head to it's handle ratio is another issue, but the pliers are very usable. Also keep in mind that the pivot is hidden under the handle (unlike the juice) so you have to add that to the actual size of the Balance pliers vs. Juice. Cheers!



-
another for handle thickness/ length

-
Nice comparison pics ;)
Just to clarify my original post, its not so much the size that I was comparing to a squirt, but the 'design' in terms of the thickness of the pliers. And yes, whereas the tool is larger than a juice, its plier heads are about the same size, which is exactly what I was saying, its disproportionate which for some reason bugs me, but I can begin to see its a necessity with the way the tool is designed.
You do make a good point that because the pivot is hidden in the handle, that makes the pliers look smaller. I wonder how that affects how much force you can get out of them?
Would you be able to compare its size to Vic spirit, or LM charge?
-
Btw, the pliers feel very strong and sure. Good grip too. I don't, however, have any plans to put it to the test since it's a prototype.
A long time ago in my knife collecting days I found a one of a kind Benchmade with a damascus blade and no cutting edge applied to it. ( not dull, no edge bevel at all). It was interesting but at the time i thought a knife w/o an edge was like a bull without balls. So i had Shane Sibert apply a custom edge to it. At any rate, i never heard the end of it on the BM forum. I ruined an extreme rarity, yada yada. Live and learn :)
On charge/spirit request..i don't have either of those models at the moment. You could send them to me though ;)
-
No, it's a fair sized tool. Not sure of weight. Aluminum scales help, I'm sure, but still on the hefty side... Just checked advertised specs: 3.8" length fully closed. And weight 7oz. Alternately the fully loaded juice xe6 is a half inch shorter but nearly the same weight at 6.7oz. Thickness on the balance is just over 5/8" or exactly 11/16".
-
hmm 3.8 inch length is very close to the 4 inch length of charge/spirit tools.
That is a real shame, this tool has the bare minimum on it, the most useful tools, in a nice package. But if it is going to be the same size as a LM charge or Vic Spirit, or even close, then it cannot compete, they pack pretty much everything under the sun.
This would have had to be LM juice width and length for it to really stand out.
-
@Raukodur said:
hmm 3.8 inch length is very close to the 4 inch length of charge/spirit tools.That is a real shame, this tool has the bare minimum on it, the most useful tools, in a nice package. But if it is going to be the same size as a LM charge or Vic Spirit, or even close, then it cannot compete, they pack pretty much everything under the sun.
This would have had to be LM juice width and length for it to really stand out.
I'm sorry to say I agree with this, and this tool has just lost a fair chunk of appeal for me. Up to the size on an XE6 I could have lived with. Beyond that, there's several other tools I'd rather have in my pocket. That's a real shame actually as I was looking forward to this new "small" tool :-\
-
Well that's what these forums are for... To be informed. All above points taken (and valid), it's still a very cool design and very pocket friendly for it's size. To appreciate it, you have to place more value on the one hand opening pliers, larger blade and bit drivers etc.
-
one handed opening pliers doesnt make much sense if the rest of the tools arent OHO, real shame they didn't make that a feature of the knife ???
Who knows, maybe they will make some changes before release, that is if they still plan to release it.
-
@Raukodur said:
one handed opening pliers doesnt make much sense if the rest of the tools arent OHO, real shame they didn't make that a feature of the knife ???Who knows, maybe they will make some changes before release, that is if they still plan to release it.
I'm not sure I agree with that. Yes, it might be nice if some if the other tools were also OHO, but the fact they aren't doesn't make the fact the pliers are less useful IMO. That's certainly true of my MP400 and 600 anyway. :)
I'm also sure we'll see a new version at SHOT, lets just hope it makes it onto the shop shelves this time. :D
-
Doesnt make the pliers less useful, no, but surely anyone in their right mind at Gerber would realise that if they are going to use that as an advertising point for the tool (which they may not), it would be strengthened considerably by being able to say the other 'essential' tools are also OHO, especially the knife.
-
Well if you want easy and quick OHO pliers and a OHO blade then you're going to have to look at other Gerber options I think, the Flik springs to mind. Lets be fair there's almost no MT's that are all OHO, the Buck X-Tract being one of the very few exceptions I can think of. Owing that almost no other MT manages it I'm not sure that it's fair to single out this tool for criticism. :)
-
Gareth I think you misunderstand, probably because I am not expressing myself clearly :)
I am not criticizing the Balance because of this, I am saying they missed a trick in that it would be a very strong selling point if they could advertise it as being compact, carrying the essential tools we use very often, AND being one handed opening, including the pliers, with the sliding design being unique to Gerber.
As it is, I am not so much bothered about this, but disappointed with the size of this tool, it seems too big to justify having only 4 tool along with the pliers.
-
@Accujohn said:
Well that's what these forums are for... To be informed. All above points taken (and valid), it's still a very cool design and very pocket friendly for it's size. To appreciate it, you have to place more value on the one hand opening pliers, larger blade and bit drivers etc.Fair point! The knife for me is always an achilles heel on tools - I tend not to use them (well, most of them anyway). OHO pliers can be nice at times and the drivers do look very nice. I still wish Gerber would put it on a boil wash to try and shrink it a bit ;)
@Gareth said:
I'm also sure we'll see a new version at SHOT, lets just hope it makes it onto the shop shelves this time. :DI'm looking forward to see what changes have been made :)
-
@Raukodur said:
Gareth I think you misunderstand, probably because I am not expressing myself clearly :)I am not criticizing the Balance because of this, I am saying they missed a trick in that it would be a very strong selling point if they could advertise it as being compact, carrying the essential tools we use very often, AND being one handed opening, including the pliers, with the sliding design being unique to Gerber.
As it is, I am not so much bothered about this, but disappointed with the size of this tool, it seems too big to justify having only 4 tool along with the pliers.
Ah, OK. I was indeed missing your point then I think, but that's just as likely to be my fault as yours.

-
I think there is always something that bothers someone about any tool. Not any all OHO multis out there that i know off. I think the biggest selling point here is the OHO pliers combined with other outside opening tools.. No inside opening tools .That's a handy package and not many can say that
-
Just took a second to check out the Gerber site to see if anything new is posted on this tool. It is no longer shown on the site except for the pdf of the 2011 catalog where it is permanent. Wonder if this is a good sign or bad. They may be preparing for it's new january release?
-
@Accujohn said:
Just took a second to check out the Gerber site to see if anything new is posted on this tool. It is no longer shown on the site except for the pdf of the 2011 catalog where it is permanent. Wonder if this is a good sign or bad. They may be preparing for it's new january release?that would be my guess. I can see Gerber wanting to forget the stalled 2011 release and just focusing on the 2012 one. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
