Mammoth Tusk Vic Executive Owners Club!
-
I honestly paid no attention until my wife pointed it out. Of course she paid for the knife and started pointing out it's flaws.
I've mentioned it to another proud swiss knife maker and he told me the scales are not swiss cut/finished. Curious who glues them on. A tiny bit of glue goes a long way.
Lastly, I have seen other mammoth scaled SAKS and really wish Victorinox would have put just a tiny bit more effort into it before release. I think I saw a 91 or 84 somewhere out there and the guy did an incredible job. I'll see if I can locate it.
-
@rickinFL said:
I honestly paid no attention until my wife pointed it out. Of course she paid for the knife and started pointing out it's flaws.I've mentioned it to another proud swiss knife maker and he told me the scales are not swiss cut/finished. Curious who glues them on. A tiny bit of glue goes a long way.
Lastly, I have seen other mammoth scaled SAKS and really wish Victorinox would have put just a tiny bit more effort into it before release. I think I saw a 91 or 84 somewhere out there and the guy did an incredible job. I'll see if I can locate it.
Ong did one.
-
That is what I am talking about!!
INCREDIBLE WORK!!!
To me, that is what VIC quality should be for what they are asking.
Thanks for finding the thread.
Disclaimer- Sorry to those that have this knife and like it. Enjoy it. My posts are only my opinion and personal views after receiving 2 different mammoth knives. Both had the same issues as mentioned in my previous posts.
-
No glue work issues on mine, but there is an ugly crack in one of the scales. I know mammoth tusk ivory can have cracks but this just looks like a production issue


What do you guys think?
-
I don't know how Mammoth tusk is to work, so I can't say. I have one that I EDC with a little glue running, but it doesn't bother me. The other two at my house have no glue issues.
I figured splits and cracks were par for the course, but when I look at ong's work, I don't know...

-
For $165.00, I could not live with running glue.
I wish I had not seen ONG's work. Maybe I would have been happy with the Vic version.
It's a personal thing. If you are happy, Enjoy.
-
Ya I think if you are picky and want it as close to perfection as possible, it's the kind of thing you have to do yourself, or have a pro do it. The bark is not a homogenous material like other scale materials, and its going to crack etc.
-
Agreed. I did'nt think it got any more professional than straight from Victorinox. Then again, they are trying to mass produce a product. I am just grateful I no longer have a horse in this race. Love the concept, dislike the product.
Enjoy your knives.
-
@rickinFL said:
Agreed. I did'nt think it got any more professional than straight from Victorinox. Then again, they are trying to mass produce a product. I am just grateful I no longer have a horse in this race. Love the concept, dislike the product.Enjoy your knives.
I hear you. $165 is a lot to pay for a knife. I can see how the glue thing would tick people off. The cracks, etc, I sort of think that's to be expected for an organic, non produced scale material. Yes, someone who's talented with handling materials may be able to take scale material like this and produce a flaw free scale, but that's a far cry from scaling up to the level that Victorinox has to, to make a viable commercial product.
Again, I completely understand where you're coming from, but I have to say, even my glue marred Mammoth tusked Executive brings a huge smile to my face whenever I pull it out of my pocket. :tool:
-
I would have a problem buying any hand finished knife for that money unseen, though I would not have had, until now, such a problem with SAKs.
However, sometimes you can not go to a shop.
What I tend to do, eg with my better slipjoints, is ask for a few good pictures of a few knives of the same model and then choose the best speciment. -
I will not mention the vendor but they were not willing to do that. The two knives I received were worlds apart. I will not by another specialty knife like this online or allow my wife to be so kind as to buy it for me online.
Case closed and sorry to Highjack a collectors thread. Just my two cents.
Take care.
-
@rickinFL said:
I will not mention the vendor but they were not willing to do that. The two knives I received were worlds apart. I will not by another specialty knife like this online or allow my wife to be so kind as to buy it for me online.Case closed and sorry to Highjack a collectors thread. Just my two cents.
Take care.
I'm pretty sure I know the dealer you contacted (based on the price). I will say, I contacted a different dealer and was sent a series of pictures of the the knives they had. I was able to pick the exact one I wanted.
I completely understand your disappointment. If all of my Mammoth tusk vics had glue runs, I'd be disappointed too.

That said, my mammoth tusked vic feels great in hand and the blade is larger than a classic and is therefore MUCH more functional. The 74mm sized Vics are really a much more useful size (compared to the 58mm Vics)
-
May have to get one of these now. I wonder how many they made?

-
Mine also had a poor gluing job and scales that were not flat on the back to fit flush on the liners. The dealer ("one of us" I believe) exchanged it for a very nice one.
-
The price of these seems to have gone down.
-
-
Wow I didn't know that. I can't find anything wrong with the one you sold me.
-
I like the new price... maybe I need one more.
I've been meaning to update the Wiki, but I've heard that there have been quite a few production issues with these. Some are kind of natural to my mind but some interpret the same thing such un uneven thickness as an undesirable cosmetic issue. The glue and the structural cracks I take more seriously. Apparantly this is something that Victorinox USA dreamed up (nice dream), but they had a third-party put them together, and they were not approved by Victorinox Switzerland. Can anyone confirm any of this information?
I REALLY like these, it's a shame that they were not up to the regular Vic standards in terms of the scales since they were a very premium price.
-
I just ordered #8 today. I'll be joining you all officially with pix next week.
-
@GigaHz said:
Wow I didn't know that. I can't find anything wrong with the one you sold me.I have sold 16 with no complaints or returns but there has been a buzz about others purchased elsewhere so I had to drop my price in order to sell. I stand behind anything I sell 100% so anyone not happy just let me know, no problem.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login