SAK for whittling
-
Personally I made one specifically for wood butchering:


However, if I were buying one I'd go for a slippie pattern designed for whittling - something along these lines with the smaller blades for precision work:

You'll find very cheap ones and extremely fancy ones with a bigger ticket on them, so your budget will easily be catered for :)
-
I'd say you definitely want a small blade for detail work as well as a larger one of the rougher shaping. A Tinker has been the recommendation of Chris Lubkemann for a good few years and I can't see any reason to disagree. :) BTW I've only done some very basic whittling myself so don't feel you need to take my word as gospel.
Like Nuph I did my own Woodcrafter mod, but really a Tinker or Tinker Small would do just as well.

-
I've been thinking about putting together a whittler too, but I need a way to get a crook knife on there.

I need something like that if Im carving a bowl or spoon. I think that, a saw and a knife would do it.
-
I thought about case, et al classic knives, but I'm a vic snob, modding would be good, but would end up costing more, i would have to pay someone to do it...do you see a saw as being necessary? Should I just stick to multiple blades?
Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk
-
Na, the saw's not really necessary IMO, just a handy extra for gathering material. :) If you did want to get a saw for him though the Hiker would still be a good option without getting too fat for prolonged use.
-
I did the mod on a hiker as Chris did in the book,it actually is a great knife for whittling!I use it more than my other 3 bladed whittlers. Having the saw is a +. I think the hiker is the perfect whittler IMO.

-
Hiker could work if I could get more grippy scales...I know rotokid sells g10 blanks, but does anyone know where I could get already finished g10 scales?
Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk
-
Personally I've never had any issue with the 'grippiness' of cellidor, but I know others don't like it. Rather than looking for custom G10, have you thought about the stock Nylon scales?
-
Nylon scales on my fireman, like them, Hiker available with nylon or only aftermarket?
Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk
-
That's a good question. The 91mm Nylon scaled SAK are called the EcoLine range and a bit of searching didn't turn up an EcoLine Hiker. :-\ The other Nylon ones you might want to think about are the Stayglow's.
PM Rotokid and see if he's got either of kicking around. :)
-
@k12cop said:
Hiker could work if I could get more grippy scales...I know rotokid sells g10 blanks, but does anyone know where I could get already finished g10 scales?Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk
Since it is a working knife try using some skate board grip tape or some safety grip tape on the scales. You do not need much, only a couple small pieces on each side should do the trick.

Sent from outer space via my Star Trek communicator. :P
-
What about getting him a real woodcarving set? I love SAKs but for serious detailed carving I would get something like this;

-
I really like the Recruit (or sometimes called the Driver, I think) for whittling.
I prefer the way the 84mm frame fits my hand and the lack of backspring tools makes it much more comfortable to hold (plus the springs are flush with the liners).
Also, the keyring nub is an aluminum spacer, not on the spring like the 91mm, so it is easy to file off.
-
The Little Book of Whittling by Chris Lubkemann is a great book for beginners. He uses a Vic Tinker and includes descriptions for reshaping the blades for whittling.

-
On SOSAK in the past there have been quite a bit about SAKs for whittling. The Recruit was very often a favorite due to the smooth back. There was also a popular mod that modified the can-opener on it to be a very useful tool for carving. This was easier on the Recruit due to the way the knife is assembled using only 2 rivets rather than 3.
I think the mod is discussed a few other places online and maybe in a book somewhere. You might want to use google to get some additional information.
-
Amici,
Personally I;m a Wenger guy, so depending on his age and maturity level, I would get him a Wenger of one of the EVOWOOD variety.Cheers,
Serge -
Thanx for replies...may go with mod, large blade, saw, would you recomend small blade or pruning blade?
-
Definitely the small blade, IMO. That is the blade I use 99% of the time when whittling.
-
As gusto said the small blade is used most often. You may want to change the profile of the blade so that it is more pointed, or put a small wharncliffe blade on the SAK.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login