Leatherman REBAR Multi-Tool
-
So there we have it. Design perfection is best described as putting together the things that are already there, just in the right combination.

-
Well in this case it's refinement, but with a brand new design, Leatherman seems to "finish" their product more than Gerber in my experience.
Gerber designs look like they just come off the drawing board where Leatherman products feels like they go back to the drawing board a few times (or a few more times) before they're released. I could be wrong, just my theory.
-
I suppose... if each company were to put in "X" amount of dollars into designing a product, company A spends a lot of time trying to design new and interesting products, that leaves company B lots of funds to throw at redoing company A's ideas.
Funny how if the positions were reversed, everyone would be smurfing on Gerber for copying Leatherman, but since it's Leatherman that is stealing ideas it's ok.
Double standard anyone?

Personally, I miss the days when Leatherman made Leatherman tools, not "upgraded Gerbers."
Def
-
Schrade Century products are OK, because they were made by the good Ol'boy Schrade, but if anybody in China dares to make a knife that looks vaguely like a US model people eat him alive in the forums.. Some companies are more equal than others (The Multitool farm)
I think one of the great things here is that because it is Canadian owned it has quite an international flavour, where all countries and products are treated equal (ish)... -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Personally, I miss the days when Leatherman made Leatherman tools, not "upgraded Gerbers."I just don't get that statement at all. Leatherman tools are hardly upgraded Gerbers. In terms of design, build quality, and virtually every other tangible measure, they are at the opposite ends of the MT spectrum. They both make MTs, and Leatherman is coming out with one tool that remotely resembles a Gerber (when viewed from a distance, through squinty eyes) but thats about where the similarity ends. And Tim Leatherman invented the MT market. If anything, Gerbers are (vastly) downgraded Leatherman tools, not the other way around.
JMO. :)
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Personally, I miss the days when Leatherman made Leatherman tools, not "upgraded Gerbers."
I just don't get that statement at all. Leatherman tools are hardly upgraded Gerbers. In terms of design, build quality, and virtually every other tangible measure, they are at the opposite ends of the MT spectrum. They both make MTs, and Leatherman is coming out with one tool that remotely resembles a Gerber (when viewed from a distance, through squinty eyes) but thats about where the similarity ends. And Tim Leatherman invented the MT market. If anything, Gerbers are (vastly) downgraded Leatherman tools, not the other way around.
JMO. :)
What I think Def's refering to are the things Gerber had first (replaceable cutters and one hand plier access) that LM has now adopted. Also I wouldn't say Gerber and LM are on totally different planes. The MP600, Octane, and Shard are all great. Really both brands are far better than the cheap no names. And worse than Vic. :D
-
All that I have to say is...stop buy Leathermans and stick with the "advanced" Gerbers. :D
-
When Leatherman starts paying the bills for this site I'll consider blowing smoke up their butts- until then this site is open for people's opinions. To me, there hasn't been a whole heck of a lot interesting coming from Leatherman lately, and to be honest, I hope they haven't gotten to the point where they figure they don't have to go to effort for people to buy their products. Sadly, with very little of interest for the last couple of years and virtually no innovations of their own, I am at the point if I'd wondering if Leatherman is losing touch with the consumer.
As for Leatherman being first, you can really only use that as an argument if you drive a Ford. I don't. I acknowledge they were first but I drive what I want to drive and what meets my needs regardless of who comes first. Same with multitools.
I'm not crapping on Leatherman, I just think we should expect more from them if they want to stay at the head of the pack. Nothing they are doing now or have done in the recent past really excites me.
At least Gerber, SOG and CRKT are experimenting with different and new design ideas.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Personally, I miss the days when Leatherman made Leatherman tools, not "upgraded Gerbers."
I just don't get that statement at all. Leatherman tools are hardly upgraded Gerbers. In terms of design, build quality, and virtually every other tangible measure, they are at the opposite ends of the MT spectrum. They both make MTs, and Leatherman is coming out with one tool that remotely resembles a Gerber (when viewed from a distance, through squinty eyes) but thats about where the similarity ends. And Tim Leatherman invented the MT market. If anything, Gerbers are (vastly) downgraded Leatherman tools, not the other way around.
JMO. :)
What I think Def's refering to are the things Gerber had first (replaceable cutters and one hand plier access) that LM has now adopted. Also I wouldn't say Gerber and LM are on totally different planes. The MP600, Octane, and Shard are all great. Really both brands are far better than the cheap no names. And worse than Vic. :D
I think both companies make great tools, but not all their products should have been released. I love Gerber's MP600 and MP400, but most of their other stuff doesn't do anything for me. As for Leatherman, I agree that Tim was the driving force behind the market and EVERY other Plier based tool is, to an extent, a copycat. That doesn't mean they aren't good tools, you couldn't say Chevy's suck because Ford came out first. I don't particularly agree with Grant's statement, using other companies designs and modifying them is what the whole market thrives on. The Rebar looks to be fantastic regardless of any influences. I wish all the companies would stop making crap on their lower priced end. The Sidekick, Wingman, Crucial, Etc, make me sick.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
At least Gerber, SOG and CRKT are experimenting with different and new design ideas.Agreed and that's what frustrates me about Gerber. I'll look at a review for a new Gerber tool and think "what a neat design". Then I buy it and think that the execution is not nearly as good as the idea.
There are exceptions. Take the Shard, which is inexpensive, interesting and useful. I have hopes for the Dime.
-
@powerring said:
Then I buy it and think that the execution is not nearly as good as the idea.This is what I mean by Leatherman seems to go back to the drawing board. When I was doing software engineering, I remember the first question my professor asked me was "Why do we program software?" the answer was "to solve a problem". I suppose the same can be applied to engineering a multi-tool.
If Leatherman doesn't hear problems about their tools, why are they going to throw money into research and development when they already have success?
I suppose if we make enough noise about how the lack of scissor on the Rebar will cause us to jump off a cliff because there's no point in life anymore, Leatherman will design a model with scissors.
-
I want to see more innovation however I think leatherman is more in touch with what I want to see than any other manufacturer. The 300 is not innovative but it is the best tool released in the last five years for any manufacturer in my opinion.
-
I'd like to see better heat treatment for less tool chipping and breakage. Its place your bets on how many broken plier heads we're going to see once the REBAR is finally released.
-
@sawman said:
I'd like to see better heat treatment for less tool chipping and breakage. Its place your bets on how many broken plier heads we're going to see once the REBAR is finally released.Unfortunately that's a real fear with Leatherman tools. I too am a bit worried about chipping with the Rebar. Luckily my EDC blast has held up very well for the last year.
-
I'd like to see better heat treatment for less tool chipping and breakage. Its place your bets on how many broken plier heads we're going to see once the REBAR is finally released.
Unfortunately that's a real fear with Leatherman tools. I too am a bit worried about chipping with the Rebar. Luckily my EDC blast has held up very well for the last year.
It's just a matter of getting a good one off the assembly line and the best way to ensure that is to start using the hell out of it right away and see how it holds up

-
Yup- start abusing it right away! After all you only have 25 years to find a fault with it! :D
Def
-
I'd like to see better heat treatment for less tool chipping and breakage. Its place your bets on how many broken plier heads we're going to see once the REBAR is finally released.
Unfortunately that's a real fear with Leatherman tools. I too am a bit worried about chipping with the Rebar. Luckily my EDC blast has held up very well for the last year.
It's just a matter of getting a good one off the assembly line and the best way to ensure that is to start using the hell out of it right away and see how it holds up

That's what I do. I push my blast hard all the time, and it holds up great. I've only had one fail, and it was a screwdiver tip that cracked under very little pressure.
-
Leatherman has done some innovation over the last few years. My edc is a Skeletool and I have a MUT in my shooting bag. But there is a point that both CRKT and Gerber are producing many more designs.
Having said that, I've worked with development of weapon systems for over twenty years and I suggest that Leatherman may be caught in the old dilemma. Developing a new product with new tooling, processes and materials is expensive and time consuming. It takes a while to get back the R&D costs, not to mention marketing and delivery. I'll also mention Victorinox here. When you have a worldwide market with many guidelines and extended lines of supply innovation happens but many other factors influence the decision about whether to bring something to market. I do think both Victorinox and Leatherman could be a little more innovative but I haven't seen their books. These decisions are based on long term goals and finances. I'd love to see new tools every few months but the reality is that it isn't profitable in most cases unless you use make small batches and use commercial off the shelf parts. I'd love to have Leatherman and Victorinox reply to these comments but I know that won't happen.
-
Just for the record, the guy who designed the Skeletool for Leatherman is now with CRKT.
Just saying...
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

