The SAK Whittling Club
-
@Syph007 said:
I need the hook shaped blade to do bowls/spoons unless there is another technique for that?No, you don't need a hook or gouge. There's a technique to it. You kind of start in with diagonal cuts. I think the author recommends roughing it out, then putting some sandpaper on the end of another stick to smooth it out.
Take a look at Amazon's free reading sample of the first book I linked; it is in there. (or at least my sample's was. I don't know if they show everyone the same sample pages)
This is the difference between whittling and carving: With whittling, one only uses a regular knife. They usually seem to have short, straight edges coming to a point. Usually Wharnecliffe shape. We therefore have to work a little harder to accomplish the same thing a carver could accomplish with his specialized tools.
Maybe this will turn out to be a "gateway" drug for some of us?
On one hand, whittling gives some pride that we can accomplish something with such a humble tool. On the other hand, it is also a handicap, as digging material out is a lot slower this way.
Even so, some whittlers start by cutting a blank with a bandsaw, to save a lot of that roughing work. I've watched a few whittling videos on YouTube now, and with a sharp knife and the right kind of wood. (softish, with tight grain, e.g. Basswood) it goes AMAZINGLY quickly.
-
@LooseNut said:
Gareth, sound for that.
By the way is that a Hiker in the pic with the blade layer and keyring removed?I'm not Gareth, but you're right. Gareth gave the details in one of the previous whittling threads I linked on Pg. 1.
I went for a walk in the woods today, looking for stock with my (new) Soldier on my hip. I found and harvested some specimens. (all deadfall and small trees the park district had cut down to keep the wood chip trail clear)
With any luck, I'll get started tomorrow on a 3-minute owl or 5-minute wizard. I'm sure either of them will take me a heck of a lot longer than that, though. I'm no Michaelangelo...
-
Not to get off topic and back on SAKs again, but mightn't this little guy turn out to be a real over-achiever here, despite the small grip size?
Minichamp II, image courtesy of SAKWiki
Now here, we've already got the right size blade(s), and one of them is a Wharnecliffe.
We've got the "orange peeler" which would also have it's uses in whittling.
The "cuticle pusher" already has a bit of a dished shape to it, to follow the curves of a fingernail. I figure that guy could be sharpened up and made into a gouge.
The pen could be used to draw the patterns on the workpiece.
Not sure about the rest of it. But I think there's potential there.
-
I've used a modified MFV blade to carve spoon bowls...sharpened further up around the tip to the centerline.


-
@Spork, Lord of Lime Jello! said:
I've used a modified MFV blade to carve spoon bowls...sharpened further up around the tip to the centerline.What's MFV?
Good tip. I bet lots of us have SAKs (that we inherited of course) with broken-off tips that would be perfect for this.
That's a nice-looking spoon. I hope my first one turns out that well...
-
I a very interested in starting to whittle. Can anyone describe or share a link of how to mod the small blade into a Wharnecliffe. Will I be shortening it for the new shape? What is the advantage of the Wharnecliffe over the sheeps foot blade found on my electrician?
-
@Thisjk38 said:
I a very interested in starting to whittle. Can anyone describe or share a link of how to mod the small blade into a Wharnecliffe. Will I be shortening it for the new shape?If you go to the link to the book in my first post, then click "Look Inside" you can read the pages in the book where he says how and why to change that blade into a Wharnecliffe shape.
What is the advantage of the Wharnecliffe over the sheeps foot blade found on my electrician?
The Wharnecliffe's sharper point will probably make it easier to cut around corners and in tight spots. The sheepsfoot might do OK though. I'd certainly try that out before grinding it down, as a Wharnecliffe blade is not as tough. If you're going to file or grind a blade down, I wouldn't do the Electrician's.
Basically, all you're going to do is to file it mostly flat on the cutting edge; remove the belly. Then, touch up the spine of the blade a bit until it comes to a sharp tip.
-
Project #1:
I'm going to do the spreader, which Gareth has shown us his fine example of on Reply #10 on Pg. 1. That seems like a good staring point, because it is most similar to the sticks I whittled as a kid. With that one, we could probably even do it without the book.
Project #2:
Next, I'm going to try Will's 3 minute owl:
http://whittlingwithwill.blogspot.com/2011/05/three-minute-owl.htmlHow about you all? Are you going to join me or do you have something else in mind?
-
I do it a bit , usually use my Handyman . Results aren't all that great , but sometimes quite functional .
Chris
-
Count me in. I typically use a hiker or tinker for whittling or woodcarving if I just pick something up randomly or want to carry something in my pocket.
I do have another homemade detail blade and some scandis that I use for roughing just because of hand comfort.
-
I a very interested in starting to whittle. Can anyone describe or share a link of how to mod the small blade into a Wharnecliffe. Will I be shortening it for the new shape?
If you go to the link to the book in my first post, then click "Look Inside" you can read the pages in the book where he says how and why to change that blade into a Wharnecliffe shape.
What is the advantage of the Wharnecliffe over the sheeps foot blade found on my electrician?
The Wharnecliffe's sharper point will probably make it easier to cut around corners and in tight spots. The sheepsfoot might do OK though. I'd certainly try that out before grinding it down, as a Wharnecliffe blade is not as tough. If you're going to file or grind a blade down, I wouldn't do the Electrician's.
Basically, all you're going to do is to file it mostly flat on the cutting edge; remove the belly. Then, touch up the spine of the blade a bit until it comes to a sharp tip.
I looked through the book but couldn't find anything. Is there a page number?
-
@Thisjk38 said:
I looked through the book but couldn't find anything. Is there a page number?It wasn't the book I thought. It is on Pg. 2 of Whittling Twigs and Branches, which is available in the free sample.
Sorry for the bad reference.
-
Well, I saw this last night and thought I would start a spoon when I finished work tonight.
Got in, cooked the kids their tea, gave my super tinker a couple of swipes on the sharpmaker and then popped outside to commence work. All going well, then.......my super tinker bit me......and I'm still bleeding now

I'm not giving up though so count me in!
ATB, Jon.
-
Yesterday, I started off by going branch hunting.
I don't have my Hiker yet, so I brought my Soldier with me. Before breaking out the saw, I check the fallen limbs to make sure they're not too rotten.
*This one turned out to be not good:

This one passed the test, so out came the saw:

Today, I started in earnest. I beveled the wrong end of this. I need to keep the straight-ish part for the blade of the spreader. So I consider this a clean slate, as that will all be whittled away anyhow. :)

With lots of rough-cutting, the large blade on my Tinker came in handy. Too bad I did some "amateur welding" on it when I cut into a live cable, or this would have been easier:

After working for at least a solid hour, I started to get two blisters: one at the top of my palm by the pinky, and another one just above the first knuckle of the index finger. A Recruit will almost certainly be the better whittling knife than the Tinker, due to the back springs being flush with the liners on that one. Anyway, this will have to do for today:*

I was home with the kid today. Tomorrow, I'm going to pack this in my bag and take it to work. If it isn't terrible outside, I'll whittle during lunch. Maybe I'll get the blade done?
The Hiker and book are due to arrive tonight. I love Amazon Prime and their included 2-day shipping!
I also ordered a Recruit and the twigs and branches whittling book today.
-
@JDO330 said:
...All going well, then.......my super tinker bit me......and I'm still bleeding now
I'm not giving up though so count me in!
Yikes, sorry to hear that, Jon.
A tip in one of the books is to wear a glove in the hand that holds the workpiece, and at least wrap the thumb of the carving hand in some duct tape. First layer goes inside out, so you don't end up with the tape glue on your thumb. Next layer goes sticky side down.
Well better luck tomorrow.
-
I've been reading this thread, which I really shouldn't have. All of you are evil
! :D I just ordered the book from Amazon, and the local Target has Recruits in stock. Another excuse for a new SAK...... -
@jerseydevil said:
I've been reading this thread, which I really shouldn't have. All of you are evil
! :D I just ordered the book from Amazon, and the local Target has Recruits in stock. Another excuse for a new SAK......Well, I for one think it is a good excuse. Finally, we are doing something that will yield more than another SAK for the collection, right?
I just got the book, the Hiker, and a +B Yeoman moments ago. Gee, it is going to be hard to cut into this Hiker. It has that new SAK feel. No scratches, no friction, just mint and shiny...
I may wait until I receive the Recruit before I start re-purposing the Hiker.
-
I don't have any pics of any of my balsa whittling done with my recruit, but I have a few of my first whittling foray.
I call it the pseudo-spoon, which was made entirely with the BHK patch-knife shown.
After that I switched to using the SAK and mainly made (poorly ::)) little animals out of balsa.



-
@gustophersmob said:
I call it the pseudo-spoon, which was made entirely with the BHK patch-knife shown.Very cool. What is BHK, and why is it called a 'patch-knife?'
After that I switched to using the SAK and mainly made (poorly ::)) little animals out of balsa.
Well, show them! I don't know about anyone else, but I need to see someone else's poorly made stuff, or I'm going to think I'm the only one who makes things poorly.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login