The SAK Whittling Club
-
@volbu said:
I am currenty whittling with the small blade (unmodified) on the Spartan and i want to have a woodsaw and get rid of the corkscrew bugging :PYou could add the eyeglass screwdriver to the corkscrew, and that would probably alleviate the comfort issues with the corkscrew to some extent.
So I am between a hiker and a harvester (have a soft spot for the alox SAKs) do you think that I will be able to get the pruning blade modded as easily as the small blade?
Yes.
Which of the 2 do you think is the best choice?
(edited) That's a tough call. The Harvester has the smooth backsprings, which is a real plus, and the inline awl, which is better. But I feel like the more textured scales may rub your hand raw during the stock removal periods of whittling.
Get the Harvester, and wear gloves when you're doing the stock removal. ;)
Or get a Recruit, and forget the awl. Or grind one of the openers into an inline awl. :)
-
@JDO330 said:
I reckon something like pine is pretty good as its nice and soft.One has to watch out for sap/pitch with pine, also knots.
I know from woodworking, the problem with pine is that I can select a piece that looks clear, and only after cutting into it do I find out there's a pocket of sap. It's bad enough to find that after table-sawing it, and having to clean it off each of the teeth after it burns on. But to spend hours whittling, then finding a hole in the middle of the workpiece that makes completion impossible....

-
@Spork, Lord of Lime Jello! said:
Personally, I don't consider the electrician blade a good option for carving...although it could be used. I has the single-sided grind like a gardener...unlike the pruning blade which has a thinner symmetrical grind like a pen blade.You won't be able to "wharnecliffe" the pruning blade because the nail nick is too close to the end. There's not enough room to taper the spine down into a point. The best you'd be able to do is straighten the edge into a psuedo sheepsfoot.
The checkering on alox scales is not very aggressive. I don't experience problems with extended handling.
Ahh, I'd forgotten that the electrician's blade had a chisel grind.
-
Almost done with the spreader.
Here's where I whittled yesterday during lunch at work:

I got the Recruit in the mail today. It is indeed more comfortable than the Hiker or Tinker, on account of the smooth back and scales.
I dremeled the small blade into a Wharnecliffe shape, and spent probably 2 hours sharpening it again. First, I used one of those carbide "V" sharpeners to remove some metal fast and get it resembling an edge again. Then, I used the coarse diamond stones on my Sharpmaker and ground it at 30 degrees. It's not that durable, I could see where the edge was bent over just from whittling on Whew, that was a lot of work.
I decided to get a little tricky with the can opener. I ground off the screwdriver tip, then ground the 1/4 circle nice and sharp. Then, I figured: "I will cut off the can opener hook and grind the bottom sharp too, to use as a draw knife, like the orange peeler on the MiniChamp."
Little did I know that the blade stops closing by indexing on that can opener hook. So when I closed the newly-modded can opener, it went clear into the knife handle and tools would need to be used to get it out now. Not only that, but the bottle opener goes too far in now too. So don't do that, if you decide to get tricky and re-purpose the can-opener.
*Looks good so far, right?

Wrong. :( *

So this knife is pretty much ruined for anything but whittling now. I'm glad they're only twenty bones.
The spreader's done now, except for the final sanding. Nevertheless, I had to give it a "field test" to spread mayo and mustard on some open face crisp bread sandwiches:


Just got another Tinker and a Sportsman in the mail. The Tinker replaces the one I did some "amateur welding" on the blade years ago.
The Sportsman, I'll talk about in the "What's your latest SAK" thread.
-
Neat spreader!
-
Ooops... a thread on here or on SOSAK mentions that issue of the opener dropping into to the scale like that. If I remember correctly there is a way to avoid it on the Recruit or one of the knives, but not on the majority of models.
-
Hey Smaug do you have a pic of how your smelly blade came out?
-
Here are some pix of the completed "Kukri Spreader."




-
Here's the progress so far on the poker. (drink stirrer)
I screwed up the rooster head on one end. So I started again on the other end. I figure the bad rooster will be whittled off anyway ;)

-
A little larger and you can call it a Spurtle :D
-
I finished up the stirrer just now. It started out as a poker from the book, but then I realized I have no need for a poker. So I changed it into a stirrer for the rum 'n cokes that Kate and I like to drink to unwind at the end of the day.
I started this one with the Hiker. Finished it just now with the Recruit.
The Recruit is certainly more comfortable, but the Hiker, with it's saw, is more versatile. The awl isn't of much use so far. The one time I tried to use it to drill out a stump of a branch, it split the branch.



-
Cool a rooster.
-
Awesome thread! I have been whittling with a modified Tinker for the past few months, and have had a blast! Here's a picture of a couple projects done 100% with the Tinker (the owl was done this afternoon after seeing the pattern on this thread!), along with a picture of the modified small blade on my tinker.


-
I've worked at Scout Camps for 9 summers in total, and at camp I would always be whittling something. Always with a SAK.
I've done balls and chains, balls in cages, lots of spoons, forks, sporks and foons, I did a different decorative walking stick/staff every year, one with a ball in a cage on top of the staff.
Good times, sadly I never do any whittling here in the real world.
-
@Sags said:
I've worked at Scout Camps for 9 summers in total, and at camp I would always be whittling something. Always with a SAK.I've done balls and chains, balls in cages, lots of spoons, forks, sporks and foons, I did a different decorative walking stick/staff every year, one with a ball in a cage on top of the staff.
Good times, sadly I never do any whittling here in the real world.
It sounds like you've done enough at scout camps to make up for it. Chains and balls in cages seem like a ton of work.
Maybe I can talk you into easing back into it here with a simple project. Just start something. :)
-
@gcconspiracy said:
Awesome thread! I have been whittling with a modified Tinker for the past few months, and have had a blast! Here's a picture of a couple projects done 100% with the Tinker (the owl was done this afternoon after seeing the pattern on this thread!), along with a picture of the modified small blade on my tinker.Lookin' good, gcconspiracy! What's the wood? It looks like Douglas Fir to me. A good choice. Straighter and less knotty and sappy than pine, but still soft enough to not be frustrating.
-
@Smaug said:
Lookin' good, gcconspiracy! What's the wood? It looks like Douglas Fir to me. A good choice. Straighter and less knotty and sappy than pine, but still soft enough to not be frustrating.Not sure what the wood is... I just pick up scraps from the "free" pile at the local lumber yard! These two pieces came from an old 2x2. For all I know it could be Doug fir!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login