The SAK Whittling Club
-
Finished the fork the other day. Looks tiny, but works well. I think I'll do a spoon next.

-
I have been really wanting to try my hand at whittling, but have been busy lately and it just slipped my mind. I think I might make a wood run tomorrow.
-
I made a wood run yesterday, during a walk through the forest preserve with my mom and baby. They have cleared the saplings at the edge of the trail, so there's some nice, relatively green wood just ripe for the taking. (green wood whittles better. Dried sugar maple or birch, for instance, are murder to whittle. But green is actually really nice!)
I've got a wide enough piece to make the spoon now.
-
My problem is I am not very experienced when it comes to identifying trees which would be good wood for whittling.

-
@captain spaulding said:
My problem is I am not very experienced when it comes to identifying trees which would be good wood for whittling.
You just need the right tutorial:
Monty Python The Larch sketch:D
-
Now i'm ready. lol
-
@captain spaulding said:
My problem is I am not very experienced when it comes to identifying trees which would be good wood for whittling.Avoid pine and oak. Just about anything else is good. Green is easier. If there aren't recently-cut branches on the ground for you to just pick up somewhere, trim one off that is in the way anyhow and use that. (like reaching toward your house, or overhanging a sidewalk too low, etc.)
I got my latest batch of branches in the forest preserve yesterday; they had cut all the saplings back from the pea gravel trail, and just threw them into the woods. So off I went with my Hiker, saw deployed and ready for action.
Consider buying the book I recommended on Page 1: "The Little Book of Whittling." It is well worth the $10, and the author dedicates a few pages to species and where to find the wood. He also gives step-by-step instructions on how to whittle each of the projects I've done so far. (spreader, fork, poker) Check out the free preview on Amazon, and you'll get a good taste of it.
-
Thank you for the great info Smaug. I definitely need to get my head in some books and do some studying. I actually wen't to a craft store today and picked up some wood specifically for whittling. I am in the process of my first real whittling project and am loving it so far. I am using a VIC Spartan for the first go as it had a large blade and small blade which turns out is working well. I will keep everyone updated.

-
@captain spaulding said:
My problem is I am not very experienced when it comes to identifying trees which would be good wood for whittling.
(http://forestry.about.com/od/treeidentification/tp/tree_key_id_start.htm) I like maple, green is soft and it gets very hard and strong as it dries.
It's a shame you guys don't live close, I am constantly burning maple saplings and small branches just to get rid of them. They grow like weeds here. Then again, if you lived near me (Maine) you wouldn't need mine :-\
For those who don't have a ready supply of local wood: if you search Amazon for basswood, there's a lot of selections.
-
Ok, Im off work sick today, so maybe I can give whittling a shot. I found a chunk of basswood I had saved. Im going to try doing that chain one, not practical for anything, but it looks neat to say you make a chain from a single piece of wood I think.
-
I whittled this eagle's head last night with my Tinker. It is out of some sort of bark I found on the beach, and I really did very little to it, mostly just worked with the natural shape of the piece.

-
Very nice work, gcconspiracy. That makes me think of what Michaelangelo said about seeing shapes in the marble, just wanting to be released.
-
Well I have been doing a bit of whittling over the last few days. I was going to do the egg shape to hone my whittling skills, but half way through I decided (more or less) that a wooden ball would work out as well. I am just about done, it just needs some fine tuning and its done. I have pictures of the progress and will post it here when I finish it.

-
@gcconspiracy said:
I whittled this eagle's head last night with my Tinker. It is out of some sort of bark I found on the beach, and I really did very little to it, mostly just worked with the natural shape of the piece.Nice work!!
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-


I modified a Tinker as suggested and used it to carve a whistle. I still wonder if I should have just stuck with a Pioneer Settler. ;)

-
Nice work Donald! Does the whistle work?
I don't know about you, but I think that first book of his SUCKS! Nothing but goddamn branch chickens.
I'm so glad he wrote the second one.
-
Yes, the whistle works. When it dried the gap changed and I had to adjust it. I took that picture some time ago and always thought of it when I saw this thread. Since I found it, I finally added it. I still wonder if he knew of the Pioneer Settler, unfortunately retired if that has not changed.

-
@Bill.H said:
Wouldn't the Tinker be more comfortable to use for a long period? The more-rounded edges and especially the extra thickness might make a big difference.I think it would be close. The Tinker has the smoother scales, but the Pioneer Settler has the smooth back of the knife; the springs are flush with the liners, and there are no lumpy tools back there to get in the way.
So far, the Recruit is the best I've tried by a pretty big margin, as it combines the advantages of the two aforementioned knives.
-
Amici,
From my experience being in the field conducting some serious whittling, the Wenger Evo series is by far a superior fit and feel when in the hand, and resharpens quickly evan after the most heavy use.Cheers,
Serge
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login