The SAK Whittling Club
-
Yes, the whistle works. When it dried the gap changed and I had to adjust it. I took that picture some time ago and always thought of it when I saw this thread. Since I found it, I finally added it. I still wonder if he knew of the Pioneer Settler, unfortunately retired if that has not changed.

-
@Bill.H said:
Wouldn't the Tinker be more comfortable to use for a long period? The more-rounded edges and especially the extra thickness might make a big difference.I think it would be close. The Tinker has the smoother scales, but the Pioneer Settler has the smooth back of the knife; the springs are flush with the liners, and there are no lumpy tools back there to get in the way.
So far, the Recruit is the best I've tried by a pretty big margin, as it combines the advantages of the two aforementioned knives.
-
Amici,
From my experience being in the field conducting some serious whittling, the Wenger Evo series is by far a superior fit and feel when in the hand, and resharpens quickly evan after the most heavy use.Cheers,
Serge -
I just received the harvester it feels great in the hand and also the pruning blade seems very nice I ll keep it for a while and see if i m gonna mod it to wharncliffe
-
Alright I forgot pictures of the Egg/Ball I was working on, but here is the Ball in a Cage in progress.






-
Looking good Cap'n! It reminds me that I need to get going again on my spoon.
-
Amici,
Pretty impressive, WOW!Cheers,
Serge -
I'm looking forward to some more 'in progress' shots Cap, very cool. 8)
-
Here are my projects till now the knife is not fully done since the wood is not dry enough i am waiting for it.
And my reshaped spartan blade that was done today, plus my harvester which is great for whittling even with the original pruning blade!

-
Sorry for the horrible photo its taken with my phone :(
-
Very nice work, Volbu. There's nothing wrong with the photo for illustrative purposes. I hope my spoon comes out that nicely.
-
thanks now i realize i didnt give my rooster the appropriate exposure :P :P
-
that is indeed a very good looking spoon.

-
thanks!!!
its really smooth indeed! -
Okay, here's a quick thought. I currently have a Tinker with a modified small blade for whittling, but I am wondering if this would not be a better option for EDC so I always have a whittling blade on me http://www.amazon.com/Victorinox-Swiss-Secretary-Pocket-Silver/dp/B0007QCO6U
I realize that it might not be as comfortable as the Tinker due to the thinner body, but I am looking for a minimalist knife to keep with me at all times. I'll still have the Tinker at home, and always have my LM Wave on me, so I don't need the extra tools. Come to think of it, the only thing I'd really miss would be the tweezers and toothpick (darn, I hadn't thought of that! I really like having that toothpick around!).
Any other options similar (but possibly with tootpick)?
-
@gcconspiracy said:
Okay, here's a quick thought. I currently have a Tinker with a modified small blade for whittling, but I am wondering if this would not be a better option for EDC so I always have a whittling blade on me http://www.amazon.com/Victorinox-Swiss-Secretary-Pocket-Silver/dp/B0007QCO6UI realize that it might not be as comfortable as the Tinker due to the thinner body, but I am looking for a minimalist knife to keep with me at all times. I'll still have the Tinker at home, and always have my LM Wave on me, so I don't need the extra tools. Come to think of it, the only thing I'd really miss would be the tweezers and toothpick (darn, I hadn't thought of that! I really like having that toothpick around!).
Any other options similar (but possibly with tootpick)?
Victorinox ricruit
-
The Secretary is very thin, I use mine only when I have to pretend I'm civilized. My Pocket Pal knives see much more use, simply because I think they're more comfortable in the hand. (Secretary is only 5 mm thick, vs 9 mm for the Pocket Pal.)
-
@Steinar said:
The Secretary is very thin, I use mine only when I have to pretend I'm civilized. My Pocket Pal knives see much more use, simply because I think they're more comfortable in the hand. (Secretary is only 5 mm thick, vs 9 mm for the Pocket Pal.)I had looked at the pocket pal, and it is a viable option for sure. To be completely honest, the main reason I was drawn to the secretary is that it is an alox knife and I've never had an alox SAK... Oh well, I'll have to see if I can compare the two in person. Thanks for sharing your experience, it really helps.
-
Okay, here's a quick thought. I currently have a Tinker with a modified small blade for whittling, but I am wondering if this would not be a better option for EDC so I always have a whittling blade on me http://www.amazon.com/Victorinox-Swiss-Secretary-Pocket-Silver/dp/B0007QCO6U
I realize that it might not be as comfortable as the Tinker due to the thinner body, but I am looking for a minimalist knife to keep with me at all times. I'll still have the Tinker at home, and always have my LM Wave on me, so I don't need the extra tools. Come to think of it, the only thing I'd really miss would be the tweezers and toothpick (darn, I hadn't thought of that! I really like having that toothpick around!).
Any other options similar (but possibly with tootpick)?
Victorinox ricruit
I had looked at the recruit, but am not sure if I would gain much going from a tinker to a recruit... They are both 2 layer celidors. Would going from a 91mm knife to an 84mm knife make a real noticeable difference?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login