Bear Grylls Survival Tool Pack - In-depth Review
-
Great review Al

-
Thanks for the review. I put this thing on my Amazon wish list some time back, and have heard some good things about it. While the tool itself seems okay, I think the overall package is pretty darn good. It looks like a really nice outdoor kit.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Thanks for the review. I put this thing on my Amazon wish list some time back, and have heard some good things about it. While the tool itself seems okay, I think the overall package is pretty darn good. It looks like a really nice outdoor kit.That's pretty much hit the nail on the head Lynn. The tool is ... OK, the sheath firesteel and torch really do elevate it to very good. I still think it would have been better with a few extra tweaks though, but I can understand them not wanting to deviate from standard production tooling too much
-
I really like this one. Regardless of your feelings on the BG thing I think the grippiness and the high visibility handles make this better than the regular Strata, which I feel is one of the great unsung multitools out there.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I really like this one. Regardless of your feelings on the BG thing I think the grippiness and the high visibility handles make this better than the regular Strata, which I feel is one of the great unsung multitools out there.Def
Well, if Gerber's UK agent ever gets back to me ::) there's a chance I may be seeing a standard Strata as replacement for a MP700 which bit the dust a while back (never did get that pliers spring fixed, despite buying old beaters for parts :-[) It'll be nice to see how the two tools compare
-
@50ft-trad said:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I really like this one. Regardless of your feelings on the BG thing I think the grippiness and the high visibility handles make this better than the regular Strata, which I feel is one of the great unsung multitools out there.
Def
Well, if Gerber's UK agent ever gets back to me ::) there's a chance I may be seeing a standard Strata as replacement for a MP700 which bit the dust a while back (never did get that pliers spring fixed, despite buying old beaters for parts :-[) It'll be nice to see how the two tools compare
Be interesting too hear how Gerber UK are compared to LM uk warranty wise Al
as i do like my mp800 but ive always liked the fact that Lm's warranty service is so good and smooth 
-
I got to have a good look at this on the way down to the last meet-up and have to say I was broadly impressed.
It didn't yell "buy me, buy me" to me, but if someone was planning on getting one I wouldn't do anything to put them off either. 
-
@Gareth said:
I got to have a good look at this on the way down to the last meet-up and have to say I was broadly impressed.
It didn't yell "buy me, buy me" to me, but if someone was planning on getting one I wouldn't do anything to put them off either. 

That was the most fantastically middle of the road non-committal tool appraisal I've seen in a long time mate :D I'm impressed
:D
-
I didn't mean non-committal did I
Aw, sod it I knew what I meant :-[ :D :D -
Wishy-washy perhaps? :D
That's kinda the problem though; I liked it well enough to make me think it was a good tool for someone, but it didn't do enough for me to make me want to own one.

-
I know what you mean - like we both said (slurred
:P) that night, the tool is distinctly average, though add in the sheath light and firesteel and it becomes far more appealing ... especially for £50 ;) -
I am not really a fan of teh BG series, although teh colour scheme on soem of teh items looks kinda nice.
I bought a used Strata out of curiosity, but it is not useable as the part of the handles the plier head rests on when open are broken and so teh plier just flops around.Alas, i just wanted to add that my standard Gerber bit kit does fit the Philips nicely.
-
Just got one for Christmas. I'll give a review when I'm sober, and have a chance to play with it more. :D
-
I look forward to hearing your thoughts Lynn

-
I had considered writing my own full review, but found that your original post said about 99% of what I'd say. So let me just put in some additional thoughts.
The Flashlight might be the perfect light level for a mix of close up task work and close range camp work. I had no problem navigating a familiar trail at night with it. and its fairly wide spread lit an area pretty well to about 5 yards/meters. The rubber grip and knurling on the light make it feel very sure in hand.
The ferro rod throws GREAT sparks. Retention in the sheath is excellent out of package, but I fear with use, wearing down the rod, it would loosen. The grip on this tool, as with the light, is excellent.
The MT itself.. Uggg. I want to give it a fair shake but it pissed me off right out of the gate. The locks on the tools are so stiff, it was nearly impossible to unlock any of the tools on either side of the MT. Painfully difficult. Literally. And unfolding every tool felt like it was grinding through sand in the joints. Getting past that, the blade comes wicked sharp, the philips driver has great purchase and worked fine to turn a stubburn woodscrew. I posted my results of testing the scissors in the scissors thread in the general forum, but to sum up, they are great on light material, bad on heavy material due to the little thumbstud used to press them down being too small, so heavy cutting is painful. The can opener had zero rim jumps while opening two cans of food and did its job better than average in my opinion. Grip on the tool is darn good with plier assembly closed. It is fantastic with pliers open. Wire cutters cut a wire coat hanger with a one hand grip. Spring force to open the plier head is very modest and non-obtrusive.
Leftiness.. The tool has only a few less-than-friendly to left handed user features. The thumbstud to open the blade is placed for a right handed user. The notch in the file for striking the ferro rod is hard to use left handed as the body of the tool is in the way, and the tab for opening the sheath is easier to use righthanded than lefthanded. Nothing deal breaking.
I am seriously concerned with the frame construction of the tool and serious flex under high grip force with the pliers. There seems to be loadbearing portions of the frame that are plastic, which I fear would break under force that a reasonably strong man could generate, or most anyone with a two hand grip.
Weight and dimensions in hand made me really think of the Wave, although my scale says this tool is a bit lighter... more like a Vic Spirit.
As for the file... we shall not discuss the file. :)
In full disclosure, I haven't tested the saw yet.
This tool set has a lot of plastic and rubber. My experience with rubber bits on tools is that it eventually either gets gummy or hardens. I suspect the handle inserts, and flashlight wrap are of the gummy variety. I think the rubber of the sheath flap is of the harden variety. In any case I suspect that it means the toolkit has a very finite lifespan. Time will tell.
So... worth the money? Hey, I go it free for Christmas, so smurf yeah! I'd say if you could pick it up for 40 - 50 bucks, you won't feel cheat. What's that translate to in MT Euro cost... like 800e ? :)
-
Thanks for your thoughts Lynn.
I agree the locks are fussy, fussier than they need to be. Personally I find sticking my thumbnail in behind the slide to give extra purchase helps over just squeezing and dragging. I must be honest, leftiness didn't enter my radar as I'm not defective that way :P :D :D
Good point on the ferro rod wearing - that eluded me completely. It's great retention, but relies on friction on the ferro rod at the (as new) diameter :-\ However, this is sold more as a survival (back up tool) than a bushcrafting frequent use item, so although it's a bit poo after many uses, at least it doesn't fail to do what it is meant to.
Longevity of the polymer surfaces
well, time will tell on those. I don't know enough to know how what the materials are and how prone to degradation they are. All in all, I think the tool is a fair effort and I've had far more frustration and disappointment with tools from their neighbour in PortlandUK prices? Well they retail here around £100 (GBP), though they can be had for less with a little shopping around. That translates to about $150-160 US. At that price it's not worth it, but I picked mine up for around £50 ($75-80). Bear in mind a LM Juice over here will cost between £60 & £100 dependent on the model, and I ended up with a better tool, a torch, a firesteel and a really cool pouch for less money than a Juice. From that perspective I am very happy with it
-
Defective? DEFECTIVE??!?!?!!???!!!
I'll have you know that being left handed is the LEAST of my many defects!Emmm... I Mean...:D
I think every tool has a price point that makes it worth it, and agree that even at equal cost, this pack is likely more useful than a LM Juice. At lower cost, yep, I think it would be worth it.
-
Al well knows my total apathy towards the BG tool. ;) It's a nice enough tool and if someone gave me one for Christmas I'd be very happy, but I'm not likely to spend my hard earned cash on one any time soon either.

-
@Gareth said:
Al well knows my total apathy towards the BG tool. ;) It's a nice enough tool and if someone gave me one for Christmas I'd be very happy, but I'm not likely to spend my hard earned cash on one any time soon either.
:D Despite your apathy, if it was side by side with a Juice XE6 on a shelf in a store and the BG pack was lets say two thirds the price, which would you buy? Genuine question :)
You know that I'm only a hair's breadth away from liking the Juice which is why I hate it so much :P :D but in hindsight (UK carry complications aside) I'd still grab the BG ensemble again :-\
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

