Scissor test
-
I keep telling people here how great micra scissors are but they never listen...
As said, they get a bit worst with age. My usa stamped ones,older, need to be tightened.
-
@dks said:
I keep telling people here how great micra scissors are but they never listen...I've known the Micra scissors were good for quite some time, however, I carried a Crosscut for a very long time. At one point, I lost them, and the only tool available for me to replace them with was a Micra. I then carried it for a few months until I found the Crosscut again. I tested them side-by-side, and the Crosscut was decidedly better. That was 12 or so years ago.
Fast forward to yesterday, when I have the new Crosscut 2.0 and a new Micra. This time, Micra wins, pretty handily. The thing is, I've had 5 Micras in my life, and they were ALL really good. I've had 2 Crosscuts; the old, which was outstanding, and the new... which is less outstanding. It might be this specific tool, or the entire line, but every Micra I've owned has been consistent.
-
My Micra is old poor thing, perhaps it's time for me to get a shiny new one to compare! :D
I'm enjoying your reviews on the subject a lot

-
@nuphoria said:
I'm enjoying your reviews on the subject a lot
Thank you. In truth, scissors are the tool I use most on any MT. I >REALLY< care about how good my scissors are. It's a major factor in my tool selections I intend to EDC. I wish I had a more scientific way of testing, other than my 'sucked/kinda sucked/didn't suck/kicked @$$' method... which is more than a little subjective. I would also feel better (like it was more scientific, less subjective) if I had multiples of each to test, as points have been raised, most notably about Leatherman QC issues. But, I do what I can.
I hope to have a brand new Vic 91mm with scissors to test some time in the near future. That's one of the scissors I really want to get fair rankings for.
-
Oh, scissors are the top tool for me too, without a doubt.
I love the 91mm ones and use them as my first choice

-
Today, a head-to-head of two tools I've owned for a while, and never thought to test.
The Victorinox 58mm (Rambler, in like-new condition) versus the Leatherman Style PS (also in like-new condition). I'm not going to draw out any suspense. They were as close to identical as I could possibly imagine.
Failed: nothing
Barely Adequate: Heavy Plastic and Corrugated Cardboard.
Passed with Distinction: Khaki, Suede, and 550 Paracord.Final scores for both: +10
The size of both of these little fold-out scissors made cutting heavy material very painful. However, in both instances, I was really shocked how well they cut through thicker soft material, like the khaki and particularly the 550, each of which snipped through with one cut.
The quality on both tools shows clearly when compared with the same size scissors on the Sheffield 12010.
The Style PS has the same scissors as on the Squirt PS4, for the record.
So the rankings of all tested scissors to date stand as follows...
Sheffield swiss army rip-off -3
SOG Powerlock +0
Sheffield 12010 +1
Vic 58mm (Classic, used) +5
Juice S2 (used) +5
Wingman +6
Vic 91mm Scissors (used) +7
Crosscut (used) +8
Micra (used) +9
Squirt S4 +10
Vic 58mm (Rambler, new) +10
Leatherman Style PS +10
Wenger 85mm +11
Wave +12
MP400 +12
Crosscut 2.0 +12
Spirit X +12
Micra (new) +15 -
I EDC a Leatherman Style PS and I do use the scissors from time to time and they have not let me down. I originally had the Style CS but found I needed pliers more than scissors as a primary implement.
-
I got the Style PS for a trip I was taking over Christmas, where I knew the TSA would be eyeballing my MT. It went through without issue. I only needed the pliers once, and probably could have gotten by without them, but the scissors were used frequently, and I was pleasantly surprised with their cutting ability.
-
This time, I'm taking a look at a budget tool, the little MT from the Sheffield 2 Piece Mini Multi Tool Set, listed as #12707S
I'll just list it as Sheffield 12707 below in the compiled rankings.
The scissors' blade length and back spring are similar in style to the 85mm Wenger, but with a much shorter lever handle, and with some fatal flaws I'll cover below.
Out of the package, these things were pretty good cutting right-handed, and terrible left-handed.
Right handed:
Failed Nothing
Barely Adequate for Corrugated cardboard and heavy plastic.
Passed with distinction on T-Shirt
Score: +8Left Handed:
Failed PAPER!!!, T-Shirt
Barely Adequate on Corrugated Cardbaord, Khaki, Suede heavy Plastic
Passed all others.
Score: +1The bad performance left-handed is, of course, due to lose pivots. Unlike Wenger and Leatherman Juice series, which use the same style of spring bar as these, they didn't bevel the edges of the tools where the scissor handle meets the spring. That feature on the Leatherman and Wengers forces the blades together, even for a left-handed user. So, I took a metal file to the tool, and did the bevelling.
The results were that they improved slightly for left-hand use, and were now barely adequate for T-shirt and passed Suede, bumping the score from +1 up to +3
I will list the numbers as out-of-package below, however.
For a right-handed user, I would call these scissors shockingly good for the price of the tool. For me, though... :(
So the rankings of all tested scissors to date stand as follows...
Sheffield swiss army rip-off -3
SOG Powerlock +0
Sheffield 12010 +1
Sheffield 12707 (left handed) +1
Vic 58mm (Classic, used) +5
Juice S2 (used) +5
Wingman +6
Vic 91mm Scissors (used) +7
Crosscut (used) +8
Sheffield 12707 (right handed) +8
Micra (used) +9
Squirt S4 +10
Vic 58mm (Rambler, new) +10
Leatherman Style PS +10
Wenger 85mm +11
Wave +12
MP400 +12
Crosscut 2.0 +12
Spirit X +12
Micra (new) +15 -
I think the Surge would have scored mightily as well.
-
If someone cares to pony up for one, I'd LOVE to test it. :D
-
I was going to also mention that the video I linked to in the original post has a test with the Surge scissors, if oyu want some comparison with what I'm doing.
-
A quick update. I just tested my new Style CS scissors. They are identical in performance to a new Micra in cutting ability, but outshine the Micra considerably in ergonomics. So far, this makes them the best scissors in the industry.
Test results
Failed nothing.
Passed with distinction on T-Shirt, 550, Paper, PETE, Cardboard, Heavy Plastic+15
Final Scores
Old: +9
New: +15Sheffield swiss army rip-off -3
SOG Powerlock +0
Sheffield 12010 +1
Sheffield 12707 (left handed) +1
Vic 58mm (Classic, used) +5
Juice S2 (used) +5
Wingman +6
Vic 91mm Scissors (used) +7
Crosscut (used) +8
Sheffield 12707 (right handed) +8
Micra (used) +9
Squirt S4 +10
Vic 58mm (Rambler, new) +10
Leatherman Style PS +10
Wenger 85mm +11
Wave +12
MP400 +12
Crosscut 2.0 +12
Spirit X +12
Micra (new) +15
Style CS (new) +15 -
That's proper high praise!

-
SMUFIN SMURF!!!
This WAS the review on the Gerber Mini Suspension S, but I somehow got stupid and modified it to the Vic 91mm review, instead of copying it and modifing like I intended to. So... anyway... I'll repost the review of the Mini Suspension S later.
And here it is, the one I've been waiting a long time to test... the scissors on the 91mm line, represented here by a brand new Climber (Thanks Felinevet!). These will be listed as 'Victoinox 91mm (new)' on the list below.
Test results
Failed Nothing
Pass with Distinction with Paper, T-Shirt, Suede, PETE, Cardboard
Passed everything elseScore +14
The blades have no slop, no play, and cut very well, and cut equally well left or right handed. Only marks against them is the fairly narrow handle makes cutting heavy material like Corrugated Cardboard and heavy Plastic a bit painful, it failed to get a clean single-stroke snip on 550 paracord, requiring a second half-snip, and there was also multiple snips required to pass through the khaki seam. Excellent scissors for being of the fold-out variety.
(Quick review of the Gerber Mini Suspension S: Passed EVERYTHING but Corrugated Cardboard wit hdistinction, and passed Currugated Cardboard right handed, somewhat less effective left-handed)
Sheffield swiss army rip-off -3
SOG Powerlock +0
Sheffield 12010 +1
Sheffield 12707 (left handed) +1
Vic 58mm (Classic, used) +5
Juice S2 (used) +5
Wingman +6
Vic 91mm Scissors (used) +7
Crosscut (used) +8
Sheffield 12707 (right handed) +8
Micra (used) +9
Squirt S4 +10
Vic 58mm (Rambler, new) +10
Leatherman Style PS +10
Wenger 85mm +11
Wave +12
MP400 +12
Crosscut 2.0 +12
Spirit X +12
Gerber Mini Suspension S (lefthanded) +13
Victorinox 91mm (new) +14
Micra (new) +15
Style CS (new) +15
Gerber Mini Suspension S (righthanded) +17 -
That IS a little surprising. :o Keep up the good work Lynn.

-
The scores for the Gerber Mini Suspension S are posted above. I messed up and overwrote my review.
So... here are my thoughts again.
Test Results (Right Handed)
Passed EVERYTHING but Corrugated Cardboard with distinction
Passed Corrugated Cardboard.Test Results (Left handed)
Barely Adequate for Khaki
Passed 550 and Corrugated Cardboard
Passed everything else with distinction (Paper, T-Shirt, Suede, PETE, Cardboard, Heavy Plastic)These scissors are the best I've tested so far for right handed users. While there are ergonomic issues with the mini suspensions, use of the scissors isn't really where that issue comes into play. The deployed tool has large handles with big flat areas for a very comfortable gripping surface.
They showed a little preference to right over left handed use, but not a huge difference I've seen in many other scissors.
I have to say I was really shocked at how well they performed.
-
Gerber Dime Scissor test
Results
Barely adequate for Corrugated Cardboard and Heavy Plastic
Passed everything elseScore +7
Tested side-by-side with the Vic Rambler, these are not quite as smooth or as clean in cutting on all materials tested, so their score is just a bit lower. However, the wider purchase for the thumb makes cutting heavier material more comfortable. These are a very competent little pair of fold-out scissors, and likely quite up to regular day to day use. They showed no difference in performance used right or left handed.
Sheffield swiss army rip-off -3
SOG Powerlock +0
Sheffield 12010 +1
Sheffield 12707 (left handed) +1
Vic 58mm (Classic, used) +5
Juice S2 (used) +5
Wingman +6
Vic 91mm Scissors (used) +7
Gerber Dime +7
Crosscut (used) +8
Sheffield 12707 (right handed) +8
Micra (used) +9
Squirt S4 +10
Vic 58mm (Rambler, new) +10
Leatherman Style PS +10
Wenger 85mm +11
Wave +12
MP400 +12
Crosscut 2.0 +12
Spirit X +12
Gerber Mini Suspension S (lefthanded) +13
Victorinox 91mm (new) +14
Micra (new) +15
Style CS (new) +15
Gerber Mini Suspension S (righthanded) +17 -
Lynn, you really need to get hold of a Paul Chen Multitasker ;)
This thread just wouldn't be complete without it
>:D :D :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login