The great (broken) multitool picture thread
-
Thanks for that Bob. I couldn't tell the brand because it was a small image and I don't have SwissTool experience

-
@stealth007s said:
Thanks for that Bob. I couldn't tell the brand because it was a small image and I don't have SwissTool experience
Yeah, I had to look long and hard for that photo. The SwissTools are practically bullet proof - I don't think many of them end up with broken pliers.
-
Been awhile since we've spilled any fresh blood in this thread: >:D







Again, I can't remember where all these pictures came from, so if one of these is yours, my apologies in advance.

-
I'm glad none are mine!
-
:ahhh TWO!? broken plier-parts on that Surge! :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
How can one brake both jaws? :ahhh Probably he was prying with it.
-
@Schneider said:
How can one brake both jaws? :ahhh Probably he was prying with it.You break one side by squeezing to hard and you say to yourself, "what the heck, I'll try to break the other side prying with it."
-
Wouldn't it be funny if both sides simultaneously broke when cutting wire
-
WOW! That Surge pic is sweet. I hope mine falls apart like the Blues Brothers Dodge under hard use.
-
@Bensasupertool said:
WOW! That Surge pic is sweet. I hope mine falls apart like the Blues Brothers Dodge under hard use.Man that was a great scene, in a great movie! I love how they bowed their heads to it in respect. :D
-
Looking back trough this thread there are a lot of broken Leatherman and Gerber tools, followed by SOG. Now I've seen too many Leathermans break just like Gerbers, but never a SOG (never even saw a SOG mt in person) and Swisstools.
I can' help to wonder if this is due to the popularity, people being more willing to show their tools to be broken or is there another reason? -
I've broken two Leathermans so far, a Skeletool CX and a Juice CS4 and the locking tab on my Wave broke but I didn't consider that a warranty worthy break and kept using it. I've abused my Victorinox made multitools much more than I have any Leatherman, the pliers have cut wire that I tried to cut with full sized Leatherman but felt like they could break and chose to use dedicated wire cutters instead. Never felt like that with the Swiss multitools. It's often the common sense what your tool can handle and how it feels. Mostly you can tell if something is too much of a job for a implement on a multitool. For instance the Phillips driver on the SOG. Not really a heavy duty tool, can't compare to the ones on the Spirit/Swisstool or the dedicated ones on a Leatherman. I tried to tighten a screw on my chair with it and felt it bending. I knew it would have snapped if I applied any more force to it so I stopped and used a Spirit.
-
Well that is common sense. But considering some events I've been thinking back and looked up trough this thread again and it was a bit unnerving.
Namely in my roadie days (2008 to 2012) most people had Leatherman, Gerber and el cheapo brand tools. Only 1 had a Swisstool. Gerbers broke almost as much as the cheapo tools but they didn't go as trivially, for instance where a cheap tool literally spilled it's guts (implements) out because the tightening screw just got undone.
Leatherman tools were a bit of a hard read. some broke during fairly trivial use, some went screaming and kicking trough crazy abuse (like undoing a welded bolt). The last one standing was a Charge ALX. It had dings, scratches and rust but it was the last Leatherman standing at that point.
Now when you look at this thread it just feels like all those crazy days and nights are getting a conformation -
@styx said:
Looking back trough this thread there are a lot of broken Leatherman and Gerber tools, followed by SOG. Now I've seen too many Leathermans break just like Gerbers, but never a SOG (never even saw a SOG mt in person) and Swisstools.
I can' help to wonder if this is due to the popularity, people being more willing to show their tools to be broken or is there another reason?Funny this has come up, because look at the poor sucker I stumbled on during my long bike ride on Sunday:

Remember, this Evo s18 was somebody's baby once...The scale is unattached, and coated in some kind of gross-feeling lacquer or something. The backspring for the blade layer is madly bent, so the lockblade no longer...well...does. I have no idea how anyone accomplished this, since *my *s18 has done the batoning thing to no ill effect.
Interestingly, when I look really closely, I can actually see where the Scouts Canada logo has worn off of the scales. Based on the locations of Scout stores around here, I can just about guarantee this unfortunate soul came from the exact same store as mine.
-
That really poses the question of what the hell happened
-
Someone certainly must have abused it in order for that to happen. :P
-
My guess is dinosaurs.
-
From J-sews:

That's my Surge, before it was sent in for warranty work. There was also a broken Core in that photo set. I'll find the other images to go with it...Oh yeah, car tire.
-
Ah good, I can't wait to hear the story behind that one! :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
