Bit driver vs 3d phillips
-
I think both have there place. Sometimes I prefer the 3d sometimes I prefer the bit holder.
it depends on what I am up to.
I haven't tried the bit adaptor yet. I need to get one.
-
The main problem I encounter when using a bit driver is recessed screws, especially those holding electronics together. My Style CS file/driver works great on those. I like being able to customize my loadout for a particular activity or carry the whole bit kit for total versatility. Problem is, I pocket carry the Skeletool and thus the bit kit doesn't really fit into my system very well. I usually get along without it.
If I were to break it down, probably 50% of the fasteners I turn on an incidental basis are Phillips, 15% slot, 15% hex headed screws, 10% Allen, 10% torx.
If I had a tool that could reliably replace a wrench or socket set in my EDC loadout, I wouldn't see my toolbox much anymore.
-
I only carry one bit card, leaving the second with the hex and torx at home. The LM sheath simply isn't designed to accommodate both, I wish it were.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I only carry one bit card, leaving the second with the hex and torx at home. The LM sheath simply isn't designed to accommodate both, I wish it were.
I bet there's a Skinth that could handle it. :D

I like the LM sheath for the Rebar even though it only holds the 1 card, but I could use a Skinth for my MP600 to carry both cards and adapter along with it. Maybe even toss in a small torch.
-
I just looked at the Skinths and it seems they do not accommodate the MP600 needlenose tool :(
-
I also prefer the 3-D philips head over the flat bit driver so I switched it out on my wave with one from a rebar. I did it because I liked having the use of all the flat bits of the bit kit but used the bits with either my topeak or victorinox ratchet.
I also got the leather charge sheath witch is just deep enough that when used with the thinner wave instead of the charge gives you just enough room to fit the second bit card in the sheath and you get the second elastic loop to store a small AAA light on the other side from the loop I store the wrench and bit extender.
-
Dnyc, i like the sound of your wave mod!
Does the lock still work with the rebar phillips? Do you think the rebar awl could also replace the small bit driver?
I see a set of security torx bits as my next purchase.
-
3D will always win. The main thing about the bit adapter is to have 20 torx and allen and other bits in your pocket. So ideally a 3D phillips for all the phillips screws and a bit adapter for a ocasional "weird" screw.
-
I think the bits are more in the spirit of MT's, though, capable of a lot of stuff, but not mastering one... I prefer the versatility of the bit set personally, and I think for not-full 3d drivers, they actually are really quite good :)
-
I haven't tried the bit adaptor yet. I need to get one.
It would be a nice addition to Little Boy and the Fat man thread. :)
You know what ITGeek
I think you may be right.
But
I don't think I have any room left in my skinith for it.
then again
it might be just the thing for the little boy kit in trying to make up for this summer.I got to do some thinking.
-
I haven't tried the bit adaptor yet. I need to get one.
It would be a nice addition to Little Boy and the Fat man thread. :)
You know what ITGeek
I think you may be right.
But
I don't think I have any room left in my skinith for it.
then again
it might be just the thing for the little boy kit in trying to make up for this summer.I got to do some thinking.
What can you do without from the Skinth to make room for the bit adapter and bit card? It may be worth it to drop a dedicated folder for it and use the MT's blade instead... Hmm.
-
I haven't tried the bit adaptor yet. I need to get one.
It would be a nice addition to Little Boy and the Fat man thread. :)
You know what ITGeek
I think you may be right.
But
I don't think I have any room left in my skinith for it.
then again
it might be just the thing for the little boy kit in trying to make up for this summer.I got to do some thinking.
What can you do without from the Skinth to make room for the bit adapter and bit card? It may be worth it to drop a dedicated folder for it and use the MT's blade instead... Hmm.
I'm pretty happy with my fat man skinith setup the way it is.
I do think it would work awesome with my rebar kit.
I should be able to slid it in the sheath that came with it.
I just posted a topic for one in the tools wanted thread.
I need to get the rebar kit ready. Summer is coming fast.
-
@ITGeek said:
Dnyc, i like the sound of your wave mod!Does the lock still work with the rebar phillips? Do you think the rebar awl could also replace the small bit driver?
I see a set of security torx bits as my next purchase.
ITGeek -- yes, the Rebar tools fit nicely in the Wave/Charge, and the locks work as intended. :)
however, there will be some grinding/minor modifications required to allow the Wave/Charge to close fully. here's a pic of a Wave with Rebar drivers in the handles... notice the gap between the handles.

and here's a shot that shows a stock Rebar awl on top, and a Rebar awl that I put in a Wave and ground down to allow the Wave to close properly:

hope this helps!
-
Breezy, would the choice of rebar or wave plier head affect the ability to close fully?
Looks like it's time for me to start hanging out in the mods forum.
-
@ITGeek said:
Breezy, would the choice of rebar or wave plier head affect the ability to close fully?Looks like it's time for me to start hanging out in the mods forum.
maybe... but I'm pretty sure you'd have to do some grinding either way. the Wave in the first pic I posted has the Wave plier head in it; the awl in the second pic was ground down to fit in a Wave with the Rebar plier head.
I'm not sure if anyone has been able to get a Rebar Phillips driver into a Wave as just a straight drop-in without any modification (with either plier head).
-
I wouldn't really say that I prefer one over the other, but both definitely have their places. I carried a Surge for several years, and found myself needing a 3D Phillips for recessed screws. That's why I recently got a ST300 to pair with it. Now I use the Phillips on the ST300 for recessed screws or screws that really need torquing down, and the Surge for stuff that requires more specialized bits.
-
I have both, across several LM tools. Versatility is the name of the game for me, so the flat bits can't be beat. Although I find I don't use it often, I EDC a coin purse with the full suite of flat bits. It rides light, flat and comfy, in a pocket that I normally never use anyway.
I rarely have to deal with recessed screws, but it seems like when I do, it isn't the same size as the ST300/Crunch phillips anyway so I still have to get a dedicated tool. The bit kit extender can also improve depth access in some situations. And for true diehards, the MUT bits will get you down deep.
Of course, a blend of your own past experiences and tool expectations will dictate what is right for you.
-
I like the flat bit. And if I need a long driver, I use the Mutt bits.
live from Nate's mobile
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login