Bit driver vs 3d phillips
-
I would also add that the flat bit extender can be a nice stand-alone tool on low-torque screws, whereas I rarely carry my 3D adapter and wouldn't find it useful for anything other than its intended use.
Additionally, I would not carry any MUT bits or adapters in my coin purse; I think they would all be too long or too thick.
-
When comparing screwdrivers, especially the very commonly used Phillips bits, I see a number of performance factors.
Size range. Phillips bits don't have to be the perfect size to fit the fastener the way Allen and Torx do, so one bit will fit a number of sizes. I've seldom had a problem with this using multitools.
Torque limits. The nature of the driver tip puts a practical limit on the torque that can be applied. True 2D drivers like that found in the Micra doesn't "index" in the screw head, so it wants to "hinge" out of the screw head. That and it will apply torque to only some of the grooves in the screw head and is more likely to strip the screw out under load. "Squished" drivers like the Wingman index and grip the head better, and can apply more torque. Full size drivers like the Juice line and the Rebar are better still.
Shank length. This gives knuckle clearance to the work surface and the ability to turn recessed screws. Of course, the usefulness of this metric is related to
Shank width. The Wingman has a nice, long Phillips driver, but the shank is so wide that it won't go into screw recesses. This is a problem with any bit set, because the bits are usually 1/4" in at least one dimension and must be set into a driver that's wider than that. However, sometimes you want a short driver to reach a screw in a crevice. A partially-opened Juice might serve in that capacity.
Variety of sizes/types. Multis with fixed drivers almost always have one Phillips driver and at least one slot driver, usually several. Tools with bit drivers are usually compatible with a wide variety of bits--Leatherman has their proprietary bits, almost every other company uses standard 1/4" bits or other standard hex sizes. They usually come with a +/- bit, others can be purchased separately.
These factors effect the ability to fit whatever fastener you must turn, the ability to reach it, and the ability to provide adequate torque without damaging the fastener or camming out.
How about this: Take the Charge AL, scrap the flat blade and tiny driver, and replace with the Phillips from the Rebar. Phillips screws are so common that a dedicated, low compromise driver is worth it, leaving the bit driver to handle all the "strange" stuff. One bit card with metric allens, torx, a couple slot drivers and that #3/#0 Phillips bit would get you through basically anything. I'd probably package it with the full bit kit anyway though.
-
Craiger, those are some cool pics!!!
live from Nate's mobile
-
I'm liking this coin purse idea more and more. Then I could actually carry all the bits. Hmmm :P
-
Problem with the coin purse is that the bits will get all jumbled up, so finding the right one will be a pain.
Anyone else want Leatherman to make a double-sided bit card?
-
@av8r1 said:
Problem with the coin purse is that the bits will get all jumbled up, so finding the right one will be a pain.Anyone else want Leatherman to make a double-sided bit card?
A 2-sided bit card is a great idea but more so they need to make their sheath hold it. I can only fit one card in my rebar sheath forcing me to choose my most likely 10 needed.
-
The new sheaths for the Surge kinda suck. The older ones had a place for the bit card and one for the saw and file. New ones don't. Just for the file and saw or the bit card.
live from Nate's mobile
-
Problem with the coin purse is that the bits will get all jumbled up, so finding the right one will be a pain.
Anyone else want Leatherman to make a double-sided bit card?
A 2-sided bit card is a great idea but more so they need to make their sheath hold it. I can only fit one card in my rebar sheath forcing me to choose my most likely 10 needed.
I used to carry both bit cards in my Skinth but anymore I only carry one, I find I never really use the posidrive or metric hex. Leatherman should give you the option though.
-
Thanks Nate!
In regards to the jumbled bits, my frequency of use is pretty low so I don't mind. I think we can all agree that a phillips driver is most popular, and for that I am always loaded and ready to go. Even though I don't use the bits all that often, I do like having them, and I especially like having them comfortably disappear into my (bag-less) EDC, which I could never seem to do when they were in those stiff bit cards.
-
In regards to the jumbled bits, my frequency of use is pretty low so I don't mind. I think we can all agree that a phillips driver is most popular, and for that I am always loaded and ready to go. Even though I don't use the bits all that often, I do like having them, and I especially like having them comfortably disappear into my (bag-less) EDC, which I could never seem to do when they were in those stiff bit cards.
I'm having trouble locating your exact change wallet. Can I ask where to buy them?
Thanks!
-
Search Ebay for "leather rose coin purse" and you should be set!

-
fact is, I don't EDC my bit kit, I only take them along if I have reason to believe I'm gonna need them. The stock +/- Skeletool bits and the long shank thin phillips/eyeglass driver of the Style series does me well.
One problem is that Allens come in metric and standard sizes, so they have to include so dang many of them in the kit. Also, I have never seen a Pozidriv screw in real life.
-
I have one of those coin purses on the way and plan to pick out the ones I may need and carry them that way. :)

-
I got a the bit adaptor in the mail today. I'm going to pair it with a rebar and the 1/4 bits I normally carry.
I'd use the leatherman bits but I use my bits in a drill and the leatherman bits can't handle the torque.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
