Gerber Flik vs. Leatherman OHT
-
More pics and thoughts....
This one is deceiving due to the Flik being on top. It's not longer than the OHT, as you can see above.

This is a tough one for me. The Flik has a cool aesthetic to it that I really like, and it's lighter (8.6oz vs the OHT's 9.7oz), which is more noticeable after handling the OHT. The OHT looks more like a tool, and it's bulkier, which is a factor for me since I don't sheath carry. It does fit fine so far in my rear pocket next to my wallet, but only in my work pants. It will not fit in my jeans back pocket. It will fit in the 5th pocket, but that's not where I prefer my MT to be carried, and it's where my Rogueneer normally would ride. This also applies to the Flik, as it won't fit in my jeans back pocket either. However, I don't wear jeans often in comparison to my work pants, so it's not a huge issue.
Both could be seen as overkill in an office setting, but the Flik doesn't look as tool like, even with the pliers deployed as they are shorter and not so large. The OHT especially looks like overkill with it's bulk, but its tools are all short and small, so that helps, even if it does look a little strange.
There are two primary areas where the OHT really wins me over:
(1) - the all OHO tools. Even the tools that are not accessible by my thumb (back side) can be deployed with my index or middle finger no problem (or left thumb if I wanted). I can't close those one handed though, but that's not a big deal.
(2) - the durability/quality. I can't deny that it has an overall more solid, better quality feel to it than the Flik. The smoother deploying, more solidly locking pliers are great. They are spring loaded too, which is cool.One of the primary reasons I carry a multitool at this point is for pliers as my Rogueneer has most of what I typically actually may need in a day. This is also a factor where the OHT loses in a sense, but only due to its size/weight. It's more of a fun fiddle factor MT for me than a practical carry, even though the weight isn't as much of an issue as I thought it would be. The OHO feature of all the tools is convenient, but not a necessity for me. Still, it's pretty cool to be able to deploy whatever tool I may need with one hand.
So if I've made any sense in all this rambling, there's probably not a clear winner for me. The Flik is probably more my style with my limited use, but for a more serious or heavy user, I will have to give the edge to the LM OHT. As it stands now, they are both really fun for me to play around with, and that's a big part of what matters to me, along with being able to actually use them if needed ;)
Oh, and thanks to the generous enabler that lent me the OHT, I now want one (I think the silver one). Even if I eventually stopped carrying it due to the size, it would be an excellent MT to keep in our vehicle.
Thanks for reading, and your patience if you made it through it all ;)

-
Great write up and pics. I enjoyed it and give you top marks for your effort. Many thanks mate.

-
Thanks Zoidberg
I'm glad you enjoyed it :D -
cool 
-
I don't carry my OHT because it's bulk and size and have short tools, I have small hands as well, I do feel the tool is a bit big to handle, but in pilers mode is no problem.
I do believe LM did a good design on fast pilers. As a tool designed for tactical personal / emerancy responders, I think one hand open (with gloves) is an important feature, LM knocked that out of the park.
I don't have much experience with Gerbers, and unsure of who are the intended users of their tools, so I can't say much, just hope those people don't wear gloves when they use the tools.
-
Thanks for the effort spent on this, it may not look like it to others but reviews take quite a lot of time to complete.

I know this from doing many of them over at WUS G-Shock forum in the past.Thoroughly enjoyed reading this, especially since I am an OHT owner and have been eyeing the Flik for some time now. (Freehand is out of the picture for me due to its diminutive secondary tools inherited from a smaller Flik model).
What was your resoning re S/S vs BO Flik? I heard the BO on Flik is particularly bad and peels off from handles even after light-to-medium use?
Cheers!
-
Good write up.

-
Good one Kyle!
Nate
-
Thanks for your work.

In general your result is what i expected to read, my tendency is just more straight to the OHT, due to my way of use.
After the MP 600 experience I thought about to try it again, next time with a Flik (i like it´s look) - but after reading this review i assume i can skip that.
-
BTW, just found this...</topic/4910 :(
Hope it's an isolated incident and not matter of course.
-
Nice one Kyle! Good read, and good pics.

Sent from my Nokia Lumia 1020 using Tapatalk -
@Kampfer said:
I don't carry my OHT because it's bulk and size and have short tools, I have small hands as well, I do feel the tool is a bit big to handle, but in pilers mode is no problem.I do believe LM did a good design on fast pilers. As a tool designed for tactical personal / emerancy responders, I think one hand open (with gloves) is an important feature, LM knocked that out of the park.
I don't have much experience with Gerbers, and unsure of who are the intended users of their tools, so I can't say much, just hope those people don't wear gloves when they use the tools.
I would agree with what you've said here Kampfer
The OHT would be a great tool for those functions, and would work fine while wearing gloves, which is something the Flik would struggle with. I think the only tools that could be deployed on that while wearing gloves would be the pliers (obviously) and possibly the scissors due to the tab that would allow easier access. -
Good job man, GREAT now I want a OHT . Smurfing enablers :)
Sak's rule !
-
You need a Flik too.
Nate
-
@babola said:
Thanks for the effort spent on this, it may not look like it to others but reviews take quite a lot of time to complete.
I know this from doing many of them over at WUS G-Shock forum in the past.Thoroughly enjoyed reading this, especially since I am an OHT owner and have been eyeing the Flik for some time now. (Freehand is out of the picture for me due to its diminutive secondary tools inherited from a smaller Flik model).
What was your resoning re S/S vs BO Flik? I heard the BO on Flik is particularly bad and peels off from handles even after light-to-medium use?
Cheers!
Thanks for the kind words babola
Yes, it actually took me about an hour and a half I think, although part of that was due to me having to completely rewrite the second post after almost finishing it >:( My wife's tablet isn't the easiest to use while sitting it on my lap while I'm sitting on the edge of a bed (currently living in a little bedroom at her grandparents' house while waiting for our house to be finished). I unintentionally brushed the mousepad I think to remove the cursor from the text box right before hitting backspace a few times to fix a typo. Well, that resulted in the browser going back a few times to the menu of the forum, which meant I lost all that I had put in that second post. So I had to redo the whole thing, which wasted a bunch of time at that point. I really miss having a computer to do this stuff on...Anyway, to answer your question: I think that I prefer the SS look on most tools overall. The BO on something like the Flik or other OHO bladed tools may make it appear more tactical than I would like for my office setting. I have a BO Rebar, and that's fine for the more tool oriented appearance of something like a Rebar. I haven't heard anything in regards to the quality of the Flik's BO coating though. Oh, and the Freehand looks HUGE, which would definitely not work for me.
-
Good comparison Kyle

If I had to choose between the two it would definitely be the OHT.
-
@Lichtbote said:
Thanks for your work.
In general your result is what i expected to read, my tendency is just more straight to the OHT, due to my way of use.
After the MP 600 experience I thought about to try it again, next time with a Flik (i like it´s look) - but after reading this review i assume i can skip that.
Yeah, if you're more of a heavy duty user, the OHT is probably the way to go. I can only base this on the feel of the tools though, and not actual heavy use, so I don't want people to take that as a knock on the Flik's capability. For all I know, it is plenty capable of some heavy duty use, but the OHT seems more made for it, at least with the pliers.
-
@babola said:
BTW, just found this...</topic/4910 :(Hope it's an isolated incident and not matter of course.
I just read through a bunch of this. I had a similar concern when I was first fiddling around with the Flik as it seemed like it would be easy to just squeeze and crush the mechanisms, or at least based upon what I could see once the handles deploy that pawls. I've squeezed mine pretty hard and felt nothing that made me worry I was about to break it. I think it may have been the newness of the model at that point. I think this happens with other manufacturers as well at times. The Flik has since been out for a few years now, so I figure at this point, all bugs have been discovered and rectified. Thanks for that link though, as it was an interesting read

-
Nice job mate

It kind of made me want to try the Flik again ... right up until the point where you said the pawls don't always lock out, which was the main deal breaker for me last time :-\ If they made the pawl out of one piece rather than two pieces stacked together (which then flare out), it would be a much more reliable design. If they then scrificed a teeny bit of plier size so they could increas the small tools a little, it would be even better still.
I've handled the OHT, and can see why some folks might like it, but to me it's just way too big for what it offers. I'd say it's better made than the Flik, but I can't say I feel either of them are well designed. A little extra thought on both tools would have made a lot of difference for the common user .... but then again, the OHT isn't really marketted/intended for the common user. If the Flik was tweaked as above, I'd try it again, wheras the OHT steers too far away from what I want in a tool
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


;)