Livarno, Romisen, C8, Small Sun cheap HID torches
-
-
I took some torches to the beach and tested them in the water, up to a depth of 3m, whilst swimming/diving at a reasonable speed.


The two classic cheaper diving torches (4AA yellow and red) worked fine. They both produce a narrow, bright beam, useful for looking into the hiding holes of fish, or at a distance of a few metres.
The water did not manage to get in, so they worked fine. No noticeable temperature increase.
The one I was a bit worried about was the headlight, as it has 3 potential openings for water to get in.
To be on the safe side I used 3AAA alkalines in it so as as to avoid any surprises from LiIons or destroy any rechargeable batteries, if the water managed to get in.
This limited, noticeably, the brightness of the beam. It was still brighter than the other two though.It worked well and enabled me to take pictures and swim with a free hand.
The beam is nicely spread with a middle hotspot, enabling you to see in opening but also see more around you. The uniformity of the beam means that you can make a video or take pictures without having the centre part "burned" from the high hotspot.
The position, on the top of you head, means that if you use a mask with clear silicone some light will get in and may get annoying. Also it means that there is not a lot of space to secure it, above the mask, so it may come off during fast movement.
Still, if you are not using flippers, it should stay in place.
At a depth of 3m


Some general comment for anybody using their torches underwater.
Do not spend more than you are willing to lose, as there is always the chance that you will lose your light or that they will get water in them (most will sink and not float)
Tighten them to the right amount. Too little and water may get in, too much and you may damage the threads or move the rubber seals out of position, on cheaper torches.
Many will have a switch movement that appears stiff out of the water. Do not worry as in the water, because of the lubrication provided by the water, they will work much smoother/easier.
After use rinse them with clean tap water and as soon as possible immerse them in a water bath for a while so as to remove all salt water. The salt, if not removed, will form crystals which can push part of the head etc apart.
If you have used sunscreen then use soapy water too.
Let them dry well before opening them. Wash your hands before opening them.
After opening them, again give them a quick wipe inside out and let them air dry for a bit.
Lubricate the rubber seals, contacts etc when needed. If the seal dries then water will get in.
Even if salt water gets in you may be able to save your torch if you immerse it in tap water for a few minutes and then dry it quickly, with a towel and in the sun
Note that some diving torches will get very hot out of the water. If possible avoid using them for too long out of the water.
When I got out I used the SA-22 as my beach torch (which still did get hot..) -
Reporting for reading/commenting duties. >:D
Glad they worked ok and some excellent advice on salt water and flashlight maintenance.

-
I think Gareth saw this post so I do not expect any more readers. :D
-
Very cool. 8)
I actually really like the look of the BLF light, but I'm totally struggling to come up with any justification for it.

-
I actually really like the look of the BLF light, but I'm totally struggling to come up with any justification for it.

Because you work hard and YOU are worth a treat.
- The sa-22 runs on AA batteries, has very good quality, is bright with a uniform beam and is a lot cheaper than similar offerings from other makers. Looks unusual and is good in the hand with decent modes. 18650 power with AAs.
I do remember you complaining about lights using only 3 batteries... well this uses 4.
- The price seems to have gone up now, a bit, and the web site is a bit unstable lately, and there seems to be no NW ones left...
- The sa-22 runs on AA batteries, has very good quality, is bright with a uniform beam and is a lot cheaper than similar offerings from other makers. Looks unusual and is good in the hand with decent modes. 18650 power with AAs.
-
Another XML-U2 torch, $9.99.
Ultrafire F13

I got it because of the emitter and the fact that it looks good.
Big cooling fins, which is nice.Specifications:
Emitter Type: XM-L U2
Battery Type: 26650, 18650
Battery Quantity: 1 x 18650 / 26650 Battery (not included)
Mode: 5 (High > Mid > Low > Strobe > SOS)
Mode Memory: No
This feels really good in the hand, because it is designed to take the 26650 batteries, so it has a thicker body.
The finish is good and the internal components look well made. It feels very solid, definitely a lot better made than the cheap XML lights we were getting 2 years ago.
I was surprised by the fact that this was the 1st cheap torch I got that had a plastic protective film on the lens that had to be removed. It shows that they care.
It says XML-T6 on the body, which is a bit worrying, though I think that they have used the newer U2 emitter in an older tube.
It came with three 18650 sleeves, for some weird reason. It has some glow in the dark rubber sealing rings, inside and around the lens. The modes look workable and moving through them is done by pushing gently on the robust feeling rear button.
Compared to the SA-22 it has a slightly more intense hot spot and a cooler light. Nice beam.

The Sa-22 is more than double the price, but feels nicer.A good buy. A cheap, nicely made, torch that is bright with a nice beam and sexy looks.
-
Fun, Fun, Fun.
$1.50.
Comes with 3 LR44 batteries.

Aluminium body with plastic head and tail cap.
The construction is fine but the buttons are a bit flimsy.
The LASER is bright (5mW supposedly) and can be seen on buildings a few hundred metres away. Impressive. There are some artefacts in the beam.

The LED is very bright, for its type.

The UV light is not very bright but works OK, showing the watermarks of money.

It has two buttons. One switches the LASER on, for as long as it is being pressed.
The other one controls the LED and the UV light in sequence.
Apart from the low quality switches there is nothing to complain about.
An extremely fun torch; possibly the most fun torch I have.
There are some other similar models, for more money, but I don not think the quality will be any different, unless you pay 10 or more times more. The batteries may cost more than $1.50..
Buy, buy, buy!!
-
Another Laser, green and more powerful but also bigger.
YL-Laser 303
When I bought it it claimed to be 100 to 200mW (Chinese Watts ;) ) .
I got it for about $8 from [url=http://forum.multitool.org]multitool[/url]
http://www.[url=http://forum.multitool.org]multitool[/url].com/G303-Adjustable-Focus-532nm-5mw-Green-Laser-PointerLight-Star-Cap-p-942235.html
Most lasers of this style and power are around $10.
Green is considered to be more visible than red. Runs on 18650 batteries.NOTE: As I discovered after getting frustrated for 20 minutes, the battery goes in the wrong way round. The -ve goes in the body, rather than the +ve ....
Specifications from the sellers site:
Product name: G303 532nm 5mw Green Light Laser Pointer
Body material: Aerometal
Power supply :Power supply : 1 x 18650/1 x 16340 battery(not included)
Wave length: 532nm
Laser range: 200~5000m
Working voltage: DC=3.0-3.7V
Charging time: 3~5 hours
Spot size: 6M place <φ10mm.
Power: 1-200mw
Dimensions: 126x22x22mm(without the extended tube)
/158x22x22mm(with the extended tube)sticker:

It has a key to allow its operation and switches on with a press button, only for as long as you keep it pressed.
Compared to a keychain model:



10 times heavier...
It has a zoom function, for a thicker or narrower spot.
It also comes with a diffraction attachment for pretty effects. At night you can turn the whole neighborhood into a magic place.
in pieces:


The switch was not working OK so I just soldered the whole system, so now it operates with just the push button.


Comparison beams with the keychain red laser.
Fat spot on the 303:

Small spot setting:

Difference in brightness at 30m, in DAYLIGHT.

The 303 is clearly visible in daylight on buildings a few hundred meters away, a significant increase in power compared to the red, keychain model.
At night it will put a bright spot on objects, as far away as I could see.

Definitely worth it for the fun factor, though the beam is visible by all at night so not very stealthy.
For safety I live the diffraction optics on, so that the beam is divided into many small spots, when I am not using it.
Not a toy for children :D
-
Why is it that I* really* like the fact it has keys? :D
-
I think it is a US legal requirement.
You have the keys (which are small and easy to lose) and the reverse battery insertion, so it is pretty safe. Unfortunately, by the time I realised how the battery goes in the switch (though it worked, according to my multimeter tests) was not operating the laser properly. I may have moved the connectors or maybe they were bad to begin with....

So I just overrode the switch..
Now, where is the other reader of this thread? :D
-
-
I was worried....
OK, see you two next time

-
-
just more cheap rubbish :D
-
-
This will be a bit different as it will be a review(ish)/comparison between two torches.
I got this Cofly KX-D010 from [url=http://forum.multitool.org]multitool[/url] http://www.[url=http://forum.multitool.org]multitool[/url].com/led-flashlights/pp_20495.html

There is also the KX-D011 http://www.[url=http://forum.multitool.org]multitool[/url].com/led-flashlights/pp_6188.html which seems identical, apart from the D010 having a green rubber ring between the lens and the head.

I got it for less than $5, when it was on offer.
The reason was that I have the Jetbeam BA20 and like the general look of it.
The Cofly clearly imitates the Jetbeam (and its sister products, e.g. Klarus).The BA20 now costs around $30 but I have seen it cheaper. The Cofly costs around $8 to $10, so it is about 3 to 4 times cheaper,
Here is a shot with both torches.

Lets have a look at the Cofly
The bad...
It arrived with the rubber ring ring on the cap squeezed out.
This was because the ring is too big for the groove diameter... I just use it without it now.


The overall quality is OK, especially for a $5 torch. The anodising is similar to what we used to get from cheap Chinese torches 3 years (think 501B) ago and not up to the current standards of the cheap Chinese no brand torches.
It feels like a thin layer of paint. There was a small piece of the anodising missing (less than 1/2 a mm squared), which can be seen in some pictures.The Jetbeam is much older, not used a lot, but its anodising is as new and feels like a good quality finish.
The threads are not as smooth as the Jetbeam
The clip seems solid and can be rotated around or removed.
It has 3 modes - High, Low and Disco, selected by the rear push button.
The low has good PWM and is usable.By comparison the BA20 has two modes, selected by rotating the head, and instantaneous on, using the rear push button. It has current regulation for low. The low is very good for looking in cupboards or walking around the house in the dark, discreetly.
The Cofly uses an XP-E and the BA20 an XP-G (larger die, less throw)
The Cofly claims 220Lm and the BA20 270. They both seem to have similar brightness in the day, but the BA20 is noticeably brighter at night, so the Cofly does produce around 220Lm.
They both use 2AA batteries and can not be used with two LiIons, which is a shame
The Cofly weighs 61.7g and the BA20 76.5, without batteries. This is noticeable.
The BA20 feels heftier, and has a larger body.
The Cofly seems a bit too short for the 2AA batteries and you feel like you are damaging them when you close the cap, as you have to screw in with some force. The metal conduct on the cap will probably need to be shortened (filed down) by 1mm.
Cofly in pieces.

The reflector is a very mild OP. The BA20 has a standard OP reflecto and has a nice floody beam (also due to the larger die)

Some comparison shots:
Cofly on the right

High beam, Cofly beam on the right

Low




Overall, for the price, I am still not convinced.
For $5 or for even $10 it is not a bad light, though the rubber band shows little QC. However the BA20, especially if found around $25 (e.g. with coupons), is/feels like a much better torch. And, the Jetbeam has been around for some years now and has a solid reputation.If you want to buy a few, then go with the Cofly. If you will only buy one, to actually use regularly then it may be worth saving for the Jetbeam (which is really not that expensive). I use the BA20 as my bedside-intruder alert- check things at night- first option torch.
Now lets wait for the two readers's comments..
-
First reader, checking in. ;) Good review mate. I think I'll save my pennies for something else.
-
Thank you Gareth. It is not a bad light, but the BA20 is not that much either.
Enki?
-
Yes, I'm here. ;)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



