Some Skeletool -vs- Zilla-Tool Jr. thoughts
-
@DaveK said:
As for the screwdriver handle positions, I agree that it is a bit awkward at first, but I quickly got used to it, and even started to like it. I find that with the pliers lying on the driver handle, the ability to get your thumb behind the pivot of the other handle is very useful.
Yes, same here. In photos the Skeletool looks awkward all splayed out like this, but its really pretty good. I would hazard to say that the Skeletool makes for a more comfortable screwdriver platform than the more common multitool screwdriver arrangement, which places the driver far off-center when in use.
(In other words, I would rather drive tight screws with a Skeletool than with a Wave or a SOG or a SwissTool)
-
Agreed, and also it's a very simple adjustment from the position in your pic, to set the trailing handle at 90 degrees if you really want to apply some torque.
I still wish it had scissors though, although I wouldn't necessarily trade any of the existing tools for them, and if you add more, then I guess you may as well get a Fuse..
Great review btw Bob!
-
I recently emailed LM and asked them if they had any plans to make bit holder implements.. By this, I mean like a can opener, awl, chisels, and the like.. And they said NOPE.. Oh, and I asked them if they are going to have any new tools out... They said in February!!
-
Thanks Bob! Great review!
I wansn't interested in the Zilla, but after reading your review I think I'll have to reconsider. -
Yeah I saw a Skeletool the other day :o and really like the look of it nice review Bob
:D -
New tools in Feb? What do you think might face the chopping block?
-
On blades that have the flipper thing: I usually flick my wrist, as well as my finger. That always gets the blade out. But if I just play with it, and flip it out several times in a short time, my wrist starts to get sore. :P
-
Excellent input and pictures Bob!
-
@Viper said:
On blades that have the flipper thing: I usually flick my wrist, as well as my finger. That always gets the blade out. But if I just play with it, and flip it out several times in a short time, my wrist starts to get sore. :PA well designed flipper won't need wrist action at all, like kershaw's junkyard dog. But on my kershaw storm I can't open it without wrist flip.
-
@Leatherman123 said:
Oh, and I asked them if they are going to have any new tools out... They said in February!!Now that's something to make a person all warm and fuzzy inside :ahhh
:D -
On blades that have the flipper thing: I usually flick my wrist, as well as my finger. That always gets the blade out. But if I just play with it, and flip it out several times in a short time, my wrist starts to get sore. :P
A well designed flipper won't need wrist action at all, like kershaw's junkyard dog. But on my kershaw storm I can't open it without wrist flip.
I agree with this; the flipper is a function of the tab design, blade weight and locking system interaction. When all three interplay effectively the knife should open with no wrist flicks. I'd wager that the problem with the Zilla Jr. is due to the low blade weight, small tab, and impingement by the locking liner. Not necessarily a "problem" just inherent in this particular design. On my full-size Zilla I had @85% positive flipper deployment even after tuning, just one of these tradeoffs made to keep the tool sleek and ergonomic, never really minded.
Bob, meant to comment earlier but forgot about this. How do you find the "serrations" on the Jr.? Are they smaller scallops than the full-size? On the full-size; I never found them to cut as effectively and cleanly as a proper design like the Spyderco pattern but they did perform well on rope and fibrous material, just not much else.
-
Even with a wrist flip, I can't get the Zilla Jr blade to open completely. You guys are right, it has to do with the extremely lightweight blade. (That and the drag from the liner lock.)
Spoon, I do not care for the serrations on either Zilla. The tooth size on the Jr is scaled down somewhat from the full-sized model. The problem however is that only the "valleys" of the serrations are sharp, but not the peaks. For instance, I can rub my thumb along the peaks of the serrations with no danger of drawing blood. I suspect that is why it only performs well on the rope and fiber materials. :-\
-
i love the way that the zillas pliers are spring loaded and pop out at the flip of a switch, i expeirienced one at an rei a couple of days ago and i can't say it wsn't a little bit addictive. its also neat how you can use the hole in the pliers as a carabiner whn in the locked position. and is the knife on the skeletool relalythat much better? or is it just the comparison that makes the zilla seem so wimpy
-
@RiverRider said:
i love the way that the zillas pliers are spring loaded and pop out at the flip of a switch, i expeirienced one at an rei a couple of days ago and i can't say it wsn't a little bit addictive. its also neat how you can use the hole in the pliers as a carabiner whn in the locked position. and is the knife on the skeletool relalythat much better? or is it just the comparison that makes the zilla seem so wimpyThats a good point RR, the Zilla Jr knife blade is really about the same size as most other 4" plier multitools. It's the Skeletool blade that is slightly larger/thicker.
-
Great review! I would like to offer one more point about the Skeletool screwdriver.
This may not be it's intended purpose, but I have used the screwdriver with the handles in a 90-degree angle one to another. This gives you turning power if you are putting woodscrews into a board, which is sometimes impossible to do with the driver in the default position.
-
i love the way that the zillas pliers are spring loaded and pop out at the flip of a switch, i expeirienced one at an rei a couple of days ago and i can't say it wsn't a little bit addictive. its also neat how you can use the hole in the pliers as a carabiner whn in the locked position. and is the knife on the skeletool relalythat much better? or is it just the comparison that makes the zilla seem so wimpy
Thats a good point RR, the Zilla Jr knife blade is really about the same size as most other 4" plier multitools. It's the Skeletool blade that is slightly larger/thicker.
thanks for the help, i wouldn't think that CRKT would put a small knife on one of their products! im not sure but did someone already bring up[ that the zilla is 4.8 oz while the skeletool is 5 oz? just if someone wants to know.
-
@J-sews said:
The problem however is that only the "valleys" of the serrations are sharp, but not the peaks. For instance, I can rub my thumb along the peaks of the serrations with no danger of drawing blood. I suspect that is why it only performs well on the rope and fiber materials. :-\Reminds me of the sog seal 2000 I used to have, the serration isn't ground deep/wide enough so the tip of serrations are unsharpened and probably 1/2 mm wide, so much for a knife that's touted for use by navy seals.
-
and also, if your an eco nut and a alcoholic and a rock climbing fanatic, when you open a bottle with the bottle opening, most of the time the carabiner catches the cap in its spring too! how practical.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login