Woodsmans Owners Club
-
Nice one John - Love these comparison pictures - And the old, well used, and appreciated SAKs !!

Thanks for posting
And welcome to the forum - Please stick around - Sounds like you'll fit in well :DI have another couple of differences for you!!
-
One potential difference - Can't quite tell from the photee ??? - But on the older one do you have the 'fluted' corscrew? - ie with the small groove going all round the corkscrew - Quite likely with the eyeless awl!
-
This one is really subtle - The blade thinkness changed in 2005 I believe from 2.4mm to 2mm - So I think that difference will be there.
-
Also the tang stamps will be different on the main blade.
-
Oh just thought of another one - The Phillips on the new one will be shorter to accommodate the new mag glass !!
Then regarding the mag glass
- If you bought the new one in the last couple of years - Which I assume you did - Is this one from Mexico too?
It will be the V3 mag glass with a glass lens not the old plastic one piece - It's hard to tell the difference - But you could try pinching the lens hard and try and rotate it in the frame, if it moves you have the glass one !
Hope that helps - rather than coming across as anal and picky!! :o Tool varaiations is my SAK hobby!!

-
-
@Huntsman said:
Nice one John - Love these comparison pictures - And the old, well used, and appreciated SAKs !!
Thanks for posting
And welcome to the forum - Please stick around - Sounds like you'll fit in well :DI have another couple of differences for you!!
- One potential difference - Can't quite tell from the photee ??? - But on the older one do you have the 'fluted' corscrew? - ie with the small groove going all round the corkscrew - Quite likely with the eyeless awl!
- This one is really subtle - The blade thinkness changed in 2005 I believe from 2.4mm to 2mm - So I think that difference will be there.
- Also the tang stamps will be different on the main blade.
- Oh just thought of another one - The Phillips on the new one will be shorter to accommodate the new mag glass !!
Then regarding the mag glass
- If you bought the new one in the last couple of years - Which I assume you did - Is this one from Mexico too?
It will be the V3 mag glass with a glass lens not the old plastic one piece - It's hard to tell the difference - But you could try pinching the lens hard and try and rotate it in the frame, if it moves you have the glass one !
Hope that helps - rather than coming across as anal and picky!! :o Tool varaiations is my SAK hobby!!

Thanks for the warm welcome . . .
Some answers-
Yes, the new one is the 2014 Mexico 130th Anniversary although I didn't realize it at the time I fished it out of deBay.
-
The old one does, indeed have the fluted corkscrew and you can just barely make it out in the photo.
-
The Phillips in the new one is shorter, by about a quarter inch, and the magnifier on the new one is longer because the lens is bigger diameter.
-
Magnifier is, indeed, v3 two-piece as I accidentally popped the lens out cleaning it vigorously after examining it closely using a 5x loupe; fortunately it popped back in with some gentle pressure with no damage to lens or magnifier frame. (Personal note: Clean carefully in future!)
-
Main Blades: New one is thinner comparing the backs. Not only that, but the tang is the same thickness as the blade back on the new one. Old one not only has thicker blade back, its tang is even thicker yet. The markings on the tangs are different as you mentioned. Biggest difference is the old one has the "rostfrei" umbrella logo, and just says "Switzerland" while the new one doesn't have the umbrella and says "Swiss Made" - remaining markings are similar
The old Woodsman was the smallest of three "go-to" knives I carried on the battle rattle. The other two were iconic in their own rights: a Buck 110 lockback and a M7, both of which I have, and still use, albeit the M7 doesn't see as much use now as it did. As a footnote, I'm a little surprised that the Camillus MIL-K-818 is apparently so collectible. IMHO it was pretty much a throw-away and they were never "general issue" to the soldiers, who had plenty of P-38's to get the C-rats open. You could get them through the supply system with an astute company supply sergeant, and you could buy one of your own at the clothing sales store if you wanted one. I suppose they got the job done for those few that had them (and took care of them), but they were quite crude by comparison to a 1961 SAK Soldier, which had all the same blades, or the "old" 108mm slipjoint GAK from that era which was another decent knife. One of the reasons I had the Woodsman. I fixed more "stuff" in the field with the Woodsman's tools than I could ever begin to remember. I wasn't that sad to see the Camillus MIL-K-818 retired completely.
Thanks for pointing out the other details . . . which I probably would not have noticed for some time.
John
-
Homebuilt Woodsman Club :D Mine have hooks, but no fine drivers.

-
@Huntsman said:
Nice one John - Love these comparison pictures - And the old, well used, and appreciated SAKs !!
Thanks for posting
And welcome to the forum - Please stick around - Sounds like you'll fit in well :DI have another couple of differences for you!!
- One potential difference - Can't quite tell from the photee ??? - But on the older one do you have the 'fluted' corscrew? - ie with the small groove going all round the corkscrew - Quite likely with the eyeless awl!
- This one is really subtle - The blade thinkness changed in 2005 I believe from 2.4mm to 2mm - So I think that difference will be there.
- Also the tang stamps will be different on the main blade.
- Oh just thought of another one - The Phillips on the new one will be shorter to accommodate the new mag glass !!
Then regarding the mag glass
- If you bought the new one in the last couple of years - Which I assume you did - Is this one from Mexico too?
It will be the V3 mag glass with a glass lens not the old plastic one piece - It's hard to tell the difference - But you could try pinching the lens hard and try and rotate it in the frame, if it moves you have the glass one !
Hope that helps - rather than coming across as anal and picky!! :o Tool varaiations is my SAK hobby!!

One more difference:
The scissors were held together with a screw on the older SAK, a rivet on the newer one.
-
Great posts John
The Woodsman continues to be a popular model so I'm wondering why it's been discontinued. I haven't been openly EDC'ing mine since xmas as my wife and daughter bought me a Huntsman. I really miss the mag glass and philips so I've secretly been pocket carrying the Greenwood so I don't appear ungrateful. It's still my favourite SAK 

-
I'm lucky enough to have 3 , and still always looking for more, if I could only have 1 SAK hands down this would be it. It's the perfect combination to me and wish it would be in production again. Once I awhile you find them on Ebay.
-
I'll post pics after work :D
-
-
Oooops, here's a club I missed. :-[ Long time fan and owner though.

Like Mags I had to make my own but it's well worth it.
-
@Gareth said:
Oooops, here's a club I missed. :-[ Long time fan and owner though.
Like Mags I had to make my own but it's well worth it.
Great scales too Gareth!
I'm going to mod mine to swap the small blade with an inline awl supplied by Hiraethus. Once my wife is back on her feet and I have some time again.
-
@kmanct3 said:
I'm lucky enough to have 3 , and still always looking for more,*** if I could only have 1 SAK hands down this would be it***. It's the perfect combination to me and wish it would be in production again. Once I awhile you find them on Ebay.I feel the same way. Has the perfect set of tools I use most. Closest I've seen currently being made is the Evolution 23, and wish they had an S23 variant with a locking blade. I like the idea of a metal frame on the magnifier. However, its length consumes the entire layer. Move its small driver tip to the fingernail file, shorten the magnifier and make its lens bigger, and put a Phillips in opposite it. Then it would be just about perfect . . . an Evo version of the older Woodsman that didn't have the hook, straight pin or small driver on the bottom.

John
-
The Marly Outdoorsman is the same knife with the addition of the multipurpose fishscaler. :D

-
@ebarberena said:
The only thing that denotes this a a spacial run is the model number in the cardboard box: 1.6713P15.This SAK was made to celebrate Father's Day in Mexico. They did a special BO main blade Hunstsman last year. I don't know if they did something special before that. I'll find out.
Thanks for this info!!!! I just received one in the mail and was asking about it over in the "latest SAK thread"
/post/1228862
-
@magentus said:
Great posts John
The Woodsman continues to be a popular model so I'm wondering why it's been discontinued. I haven't been openly EDC'ing mine since xmas as my wife and daughter bought me a Huntsman. I really miss the mag glass and philips so I've secretly been pocket carrying the Greenwood so I don't appear ungrateful. It's still my favourite SAK 

Don't forget that the Huntsman Lite is still around and has a nigh identical tool selection. I'd guess that the feel these two SAKs are too similar to have them both out at the same time.

-
Don't forget the Mountaineer Lite for the file fans. :D

-
I put together three more. I put new Plus scales on one because I wanted to use an old pen as a needle case. The pen no longer wrote so I thought it was empty...turns out there was still enough ink inside to make a big mess when I cut the nib off ::)

-
@Spork, Lord of Lime Jello! said:
I put together three more. I put new Plus scales on one because I wanted to use an old pen as a needle case. The pen no longer wrote so I thought it was empty...turns out there was still enough ink inside to make a big mess when I cut the nib off ::)That looks awesome. And it has my favorite scale color, Ruby [emoji1303]
Sent from my electronic multi-tool.
-
An old topic - but this BNIB Woodsman just arrived with beautiful ruby scales (photo also shows BNIB Explorer Plus that just arrived). Has 3rd version of magnifier with full tool set on the back layer.

A traditional red Woodsman I acquired earlier this year. It's a very functional journeyman color compared to the ruby. Other than scales color, it's identical in tools and proof marks.

My oldest Woodsman that I bought new in Germany circa 1978-1980. Been very difficult to date from available tool data. It has the gray first version magnifier with long Phillips opposite, fluted corkscrew, scissors screw and no groove for scissors spring, "V" on the blade tang same size as the rest of "Victorinox" and back of blade is thicker, key ring in the spacer for small pen blade (versus part of the opener spring), corkscrew and awl without sewing eye on back layer, but no hook or fine screwdriver. Scales are original and do not have the straight pin hole. Getting a micro-driver to fit into the fluted corkscrew was not easy (that tool didn't exist when I bought it). Obviously was not made for one. Pulling the differences between this old one and the ones above from memory. There may be more. I've replaced the scissors spring several times over the first decade or so of ownership, but not that I recall for at least the last two decades. They used to break at the hole where they were press fitted into the scissors handle. Not just this Woodsman but on several 58mm Classic as well. Always used the same method to drift the tiny part of the old spring out and press fit the new one in. I'm concluding Victorinox improved the spring metallurgy to make it more durable, perhaps the shape slightly as well (always had the "folded" U-shape springs). I still keep a few large and small springs.

John
-
Aaahhh, the mighty Woodsman. Indeed a very useful model, old or new, and I too don't understand why it is not made anymore. Of course the modern Huntsman is a old Woodsman with a new name and the old Huntsman is no more. But the modern Woodsman with the mag and IP is nice.
My collection today:
- Top left-my newest....84mm from the later 40's I believe. Not a drawer queen, this one has been used for right around 70 years and is still going. No T&T or bail.
- Top right-91mm version from the late 40's....again, a user for ~ 70 years but going strong....this one does have a bail and T&T.....tweezers have a nickle-silver head. Liners on both of the 40's models seem to be nickle-silver also and they are heavy for their size.
- Bottom left-84mm from the 60's, very austere, no bail, no T&T, just function.
- Bottom right-84mm from the 60's, this one has a bail, but no T&T.
- Bottom middle-modern 91mm with magnifier. Has the sewing eye, but no hook or fine screwdriver. Does have the rivet in the scissors. A very handy SAK.
Hopefully they will make these again......

max

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login