Can Opener Comparison
-
Great write-up, RP!
Thanks! 
I've used the Vic can opener the most, so it's the one I prefer. I'm jaded by experience. As a bonus, the Vic can opener can be used as a small driver/Phillips driver or light pry tool. So....I'd give the Vic can opener an extra point for 'Versatility' and call it a draw with the Core. :D
-
Oh, and I seem to encounter a lot of cans that need can openers: beans, tomatoes, tuna, etc.....
-
Thanks guys!

I'll get more cans and test some tools and either confirm their score or change a thing or two.
Not yet tested some tools:Surge, Rebar, SuperTool 200. Locking Leatherman claws. Probably just as good as the Core.
PST, Sideclip, Wingman. Non-locking Leatherman claws. I wonder if they'll get stuck.
Safari Hunter, Bantam. Victorinox combo tools. Will they be as good as their classic quarter-circle?
Victorinox 84, 93, 111, 130mm models. Classic quarter-circle, so probably the same performance as the Deluxe Tinker.
Wenger 120mm and 130mm. Still not locking, but they might be better than their 85mm model claw.
PowerLock, probably the same as the PPP. -
@ReamerPunch said:
Thanks guys!
I'll get more cans and test some tools and either confirm their score or change a thing or two.
Not yet tested some tools:Surge, Rebar, SuperTool 200. Locking Leatherman claws. Probably just as good as the Core.
PST, Sideclip, Wingman. Non-locking Leatherman claws. I wonder if they'll get stuck.
Safari Hunter, Bantam. Victorinox combo tools. Will they be as good as their classic quarter-circle?
Victorinox 84, 93, 111, 130mm models. Classic quarter-circle, so probably the same performance as the Deluxe Tinker.
Wenger 120mm and 130mm. Still not locking, but they might be better than their 85mm model claw.
PowerLock, probably the same as the PPP.IME the Wingman one sucks, :P but could be my technique :ahhh
the Combo tool works wonders on my Wenger Entree (due to its thinness guess
) but not so good on my Vics ???
PL is the same as the PPP, ergos of the handles apart, at least in my testing.
-
Look forward to you testing more can openers RP

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Core, Buck, and Schrade. Look how far to the wrong side the Buck can opener is.

Looking at this again, I may use the BuckTool left-handed.
-

Our next contestants are all claws. Leatherman Rebar and Wingman, Victorinox Safari Hunter, Wenger 06 - Mountaineer, and last, and possibly least, the Workpro 10 in 1.


-
Leatherman Rebar
Not only a perfect 10, but even better than the Core. The Rebar, Charge, Core, and a few others have the same can opener, but the Rebar excels in ergonomics. Nothing protrudes to dig into my palm, and it is not as squared and bulky as the Core. Moving the body up and down with ease, the edge advanced beautifully through the can top. Perfection.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Leatherman Wingman
This is not identical to the locking can opener found in the Core, Charge, etc. It is a different design, though still very capable. The can opener sits a bit more to the right than on the Rebar, so to compensate, they made the implement longer, distancing the hook from the handle. Unfortunately, its edge meets the can top at a more obtuse angle, and is shorter, limiting the length of each individual cut. Good edge and properly sharpened, with a good piercing point. Not as straight forward as the Core/Rebar. I had to adjust my grip and be mindful of where the cutting edge was going. There are also some edges that could be more rounded. Still, a clean cut with no sharp edges. A great choice.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

Victorinox Safari Hunter
This looks more like a good bottle opener and less like a combination bottle and can opener. No typical can opener edge grind, no acute piercing point either. I was surprised with how easily it punched through the top, and it felt great in the hand. Being at the tip of a saw, the can opener sits the farthest away from the body than any other can opener. This may have helped leverage, and in conjunction with a good hook to help it stay on the can rim, the affair was quite comfortable. At no point did I feel like the saw edge would mess up my evening. The downside is that, since there is no edge like on other claw can openers, this is more of a bender than a cutter, and as such, it left a messy cut, with sharp points and edges.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
1 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

-
**Wenger Ranger 06 - Mountaineer **
The same can opener as on the 85mm Wenger models. A larger handle to hold on to, but with a massive blade spine digging into my fingers. This appeared to cut better than the Highlander, though it still jammed when cutting, and folded when being freed.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
0 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 7

Workpro 10 in 1
The tiniest can opener so far. Non-locking, one third the edge of other claws, and rather blunt. Piercing was not easy, nor was anything else. This is the smallest multi-tool to hold while opening a can. Being blunt, it did not punch through easily. In order to get it to cut and to get a better grip, I had to support the can opener with my thumb. It does not cut well, constantly slipping off the rim, and having a very short and blunt cutting edge. Moving at a snail's pace, my thumb got numb for little reward. If you are unfortunate enough to have this to open a can, be patient and hope that, by the time you're done, your food is still within expiration date.1 points for punching through.
0 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
0 for cutting.
0 for not slipping.
Total: 3

This is the same size as the Mini-Tool, but their can openers are not. I also supported the Mini-Tool's can opener with my thumb, but it is a wide handle, and thus very comfortable, while also providing a good grip and leverage.


-

Today's contestants are quite a diverse lot.
Leatherman SuperTool 200 and PST, Victorinox Bantam, SOG PowerLock, Wenger RangerGrip 60, and Sheffield 10 in 1.


-
Leatherman SuperTool 200
Not exactly the same design with the Core, but functionally identical. Nicely rounded handles with nothing to dig into my hand. It did not jam, it did not slip. Clean, easy cut with nothing to worry about.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Leatherman PST
Nice compact tool to hold on to, with a great claw to cut into the can, this is just as good as its locking brethren. Very comfortable in the hand, consistent cut with no sharp edges left behind, no slipping off the can, no jamming.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Wenger RangerGrip 60
I expected no difference between this and the other Wenger can openers, and yet, here we are. Great cut, clean and easy, with no sharp edges left behind. Curiously, it did not get stuck while cutting, because I was mindful of how deep I pushed the claw in the can. Taking a closer look, you will notice that this is differently designed than a typical Leatherman claw.
On the Leatherman claw, the edge is in a continuous line with the 'mouth', for lack of a better term. From the tip of the claw, to the tip of the hook, it is one curvy line.
On the Wenger, there is a harpoon element to it, as the edge sits below the 'mouth'. As the edge ends, there is almost a barb, acting similarly to a fish hook barb. If you push the claw too deep into the can, the barb passes the top of the can and interferes with retracting the claw. I hope this makes sense.

Being careful not to let the barb sink in the top of the can, I was able to cut consistently, without getting stuck, not even once. Eliminating the tendancy to jam into the can top, the only issue was the blade spine digging into my hand.
This effectively means that I have to test the 85mm and 120mm models again, and see how well they can do.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

-
this is really extensive. thanks for the comparison. personally I feel more intuitive with SAK style can openers than with LM/Wenger style, but they all work. I wonder how you'd rank the openers on Bantam or Hunter
-
Victorinox Bantam
A familiar issue with this kind of design, this is not a true claw, lacking the piercing point that goes through the can top like nothing. Also, the edge is half the length of other claws, limiting each cut. Still, a better cutter than other non-claw combo tools, due to it being thinner. Great in the hand, and it did not slip. It did get stuck a couple of times, but it is thin enough to be retrieved with little effort.1 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
1 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 8

SOG PowerLock
Similar to the PPP. Good enough cutter, although rougher than other quarter-circles. This is a lot bulkier and its gears are larger, causing more discomfort.2 points for punching through.
0 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
1 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 7

Sheffield 10 in 1
Unable to hook on the can. When trying with the left hand, it just slips off the rim, without leaving the slightest dent into the can top.0 points.

-
@styx said:
this is really extensive. thanks for the comparison. personally I feel more intuitive with SAK style can openers than with LM/Wenger style, but they all work. I wonder how you'd rank the openers on Bantam or Hunter
I prefer Leatherman ones, but to each his own. But most of them are good enough.
I tried the Bantam, it's pretty good. I do not have a Hunter. Hopefully that will change someday. -
Hunter and Bantam have the same can opener. Leverage might be a factor though
-
-
Pending:
Surge, Signal, Sideclip. They share a can opener with others. Probably same results.
Victorinox 84, 93, 111, 130mm models. Maybe one won't slip.
Wenger 85mm and 120mm. These will be tested again, due to recent findings.
BuckTool. I will try and use this with my left hand, and see if it is any better. -
Excellent testing RM

-
Hunter and Bantam have the same can opener. Leverage might be a factor though
It's the same one? I thought the Hunter had a larger one.

You could be right. I'll take side by side pics when I get home
-
Excellent write up and investigation

You have to wonder at some of the cheaper companies including a tool that can't even be used!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login