Can Opener Comparison
-
Leatherman Signal
The hammer prevents the handles to close with the can opener deployed. You will have to either open one handle, or both. With both handles open it was a bit better in the hand, and given that this is the standard locking claw, found on the Core, Charge, and Rebar, it performed just as well. Easy and consistent cutting, with nothing to be concerned about.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

Wenger 06 - Mountaineer
Having identified the cause of Wenger claws getting stuck, I was able to get it to cut with no issues. Watch the edge, do not push the entire length of it past the top of the can, and all will be fine. The blade spine was still a little annoying, but at least it did not get stuck, and the cut was consistent and clean.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

-
Victorinox Fireman (liner-lock)
No surprises here. This is the identical can opener that the 91mm and 93mm models use. Very sharp, it cuts very well, and the only issue I seem to have is slipping off the rim now and then. I am definitely getting better with the quarter-circle design, and you cannot argue with how well it cuts.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
1 for not slipping.
Total: 9

Victorinox OHO Trekker (liner-lock)
The only difference between this and the Fireman is ergonomics. The blade's thumb-hole that allows for one-handed deployment creates a considerably large hump that digs into my hand. Nothing too major, but the Fireman was slightly better.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
1 for not slipping.
Total: 8

-

Next on the list, some can openers we have seen before, on bodies we have not. Victorinox RangerGrip 79 and Hercules, Leatherman Surge and Sideclip.

-
Leatherman Surge
No surprises here. The same great claw found in the Core. Locking, great angle and edge, it punched through as if the can top wasn't there. No slipping, no jamming, and great cutting, leaving no sharp points or edges. The ergonomics take a small hit for the blade spine and a few edges that could be rounder. Still, not at all worrying.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

Leatherman Sideclip
The identical can opener as in the PST, this performed just as beautifully. Excellent piercing, cutting, and ergonomics, with no jamming or slipping off the rim. Having no lock made no difference, as it has more than adequate tension to remain open. The same performance as its larger siblings, only in a smaller, lighter, and more comfortable package. Outstanding.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

-
Victorinox Hercules
111mm slidelock model. When it comes to can openers, the only difference between slide-lock and liner-lock models is that on slide-locks the can opener is more inline to the handle, whereas on the liner-lock models it is more canted forward. Thus, we have a light difference in the angle of the handle when cutting, but it is the same can opener found on both. The can opener is also identical to the one in the 91mm and 93mm range.Hercules (slide-lock) and Fireman (liner-lock)

Fireman on top.

It is interesting to note that I did not slip with this. Quite surprising, considering quarter-circles tend to slip on me. Comparing its can opener to the Cadet's, the main difference is size. Seeing how the Cadet did not slip me at all, I made smaller cuts with the Hercules can opener, and it worked. Treating it as if it were smaller, I did not slip off the can at all. It cut beautifully, and its wide frame provided a nice, comfortable grip.
I will be revisiting the quarter-circles that I slipped off the can with, to see if my technique has improved.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Victorinox RangerGrip 79
I will definitely be revisiting other quarter-circles, since I did not slip with this one either. Again, the same can opener as in 91, 93, and 111mm models. As with the Hercules one, I made smaller cuts with this than it could. It may have taken a little longer than with a Leatherman claw but I managed to stay on the rim, so it was definitely quicker than if I were slipping off of it. Great cutter, no jamming. The blade spine does protrude from the body, so not a perfect 10, but a great choice nonetheless.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

-
Very interesting!

-
is that Surge the first large LM to go under 10
-
-
-
The list so far.
Asterisks will be tested again. They lost a point to slipping, which might have to do with my technique. I managed not to slip with the Hercules and 130mm quarter-circle, which is the same in 91, 93, 111 LL models, and very similar to the Spirit and MP400, so they might not slip on me now.10 - Core
10 - Rebar
10 - PST
10 - SuperTool 200
10 - SideClip
10 - Wenger Highlander
10 - Victorinox Cadet
10 - Victorinox Hercules9* - Spirit
9* - Fireman LL
9* - SwissChamp
9* - Deluxe Tinker
9* - Farmer
9* - MP4009 - Charge
9 - Signal
9 - Surge
9 - Wingman
9 - Ganzo G302
9 - Safari Hunter
9 - Wenger Ranger 06 - Mountaineer
9 - Wenger RangerGrip 60
9 - Victorinox RangerGrip 798* - OHO Trekker
8 - Bear Jaws
8 - Mini-Tool
8 - SOG PPP
8 - Victorinox Bantam7 - Craftright
7 - Juice
7 - PowerLock6 - Roxon Storm (modded)
6 - BuckTool (left-handed)
4 - Schrade TT
4 - Coast
3 - BuckTool
3 - WorkPro scissors
0 - Roxon Storm
0 - Shefield 10 in 1 -

Today we will be going full circle, as we revisit four quarter-circles, the Victorinox SwissChamp, Deluxe Tinker, and Spirit, and the Gerber MP400.
These had all lost a point to slipping. There are many variables which can lead to slipping off the rim as you cut. Not only the tool itself with a badly formed or over-polished hook, bad placement, too blunt an edge, or terrible ergonomics messing up your grip, but also a polished or too narrow can rim, paper label getting in the way of the hook, or even user error, such as improper grip, excessive eagerness to get the can open, not concentrating properly on what they're doing.
So how did these do? Let's see.

-
Victorinox Deluxe Tinker
Being a Victorinox, the Deluxe Tinker helps eliminate a few of the possible causes for slipping off the rim. Taking into account the Cadet's excellent performance, I started with long cuts, and indeed slipped. Then I advanced with shorter cuts, and the slipping went away. It seems that, at least some slips were caused by the flathead contacting the can lid, and it being blunt, prying the edge out out of the can when I did not expect it to. Making shorter cuts helped keep the flathead out of the way and make the process consistent, with no slipping.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Victorinox SwissChamp
Identical can opener to the D. Tinker's. Having used the Tinker before it, I knew what had to be done, and went straight with shorter cuts than I would have. No slipping occurred, just a nice, consistent cut.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

-
Victorinox Spirit
Essentially the same can opener yet again, this was easy enough to deal with. My technique is far from perfect or fast, but I managed to stay on the can. It helps that this is sharp, and extremely ergonomic. Despite its width compared to the D. Tinker, this is just as nice in the hand. And now that it does not slip on me anymore, I like it even more. I still need to be a bit mindful to keep on the cut, and probably could have afforded slightly longer cuts, judging by the mostly bending I did at the end.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Gerber MP400
The same basic design, but not as sharp. More of a bender than a cutter, especially compared to the sharper Victorinox quarter-circle. Nothing wrong with it, though. It still punches easily through the lid, and despite the pliers tips sticking out of one end, and the buttons from the sides, this is very nice in the hand. My thumb was on the locking tab, nice and wide surface, and nothing dug into my hand or fingers. You would not think it would be this comfortable, but it is, at least in my hand. I would have preferred a sharper edge on this, but it is still excellent, and the edges it leaves behind are not jagged or pointy. And if I go slow, I do not slip off the rim.No flathead on this, so maybe the reason for slipping with the Victorinox can openers was not the flathead after all. It might have contributed a little, but I think I can blame my technique. How close I cut to the rim, how deep I push the edge, how much of the edge I retract, how I advance the edge and hook to perform the next cut. Nevertheless, the result remains. These punch through easily, are great in the hand, do not jam into the lid at all, and do consistent, smooth cuts, and you can manage not to slip. Even if you do, you'll still open the can with no issues. I might slip every now and then, but I see no reason to deduct a point for what seems like an error solely on my side, rather than the tools being used, which are, after all, proven to be very effective and dependable.
2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

-

Retesting some quarter-circles, the Victorinox OHO Trekker (liner-lock), Fireman (liner-lock), and Farmer, and also using the Sportsman, to compare to the Cadet.

-
Victorinox Fireman (liner-lock)
Like others before it, this lost a point to slipping. Also, I discovered that the cans I used had a feature which interfered with my quarter-circle technique that I had not fully anticipated. The cans have a paper label, that may get in the way of the hook. Not a whole lot, but enough to allow the hook to slip off. This was not an issue with claws, which you have to pull backwards on the rim. With the quarter-circles being pushed forward, and watching closely, some interesting events took place. Sometimes the hook pushed against the paper label, fold the label, creating a tiny ramp that facilitated the slippage. In other cases the hook ripped the label if the label extended over the rim, giving in to the force and slipping off. A few times the hook was simply unable to fold/tear the label enough to move forward, so I had to unhook the whole thing and re-adjust it to move forward.
When the label was not such a drama queen I managed to cut through the lid with ease, without slipping off or anything.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Victorinox OHO Trekker (liner-lock)
As above, minus a point for the blade spine protruding from the frame.2 points for punching through.
1 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 9

-
Victorinox Farmer
The same yet again. I can cut consistently, and having the label get in the way should not be considered enough to warrant deducting a point. Also this is great in the hand.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

Victorinox Sportsman
Having tested the Cadet, and witnessing one of the best can openers so far, I was curious whether a cellidor 84mm model could perform equally. It did. This is the same design of can opener as the larger models, but slightly smaller. The Cadet is thinner than this, but I found that the blade dug into my palm more with the Sportsman. Your experiences may vary with these small knives, but their can openers are superb. I will give the Sportsman the full 2 points for comfort. While its blade does protrude, it is also small and not that uncomfortable.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

-
Wow! Comprehensive.

I always use a Vic SAK can opener wherever I need a can opened. Once the technique is mastered (doesn't take long) you can do a quick clean job and will trust no others. 8)
-
Amazing write-up! Thank you for taking the time to organize, plan, and test all of these!
Do any of you have a general preference for the blade facing inward or outward of the hook?
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Wow! Comprehensive.
I always use a Vic SAK can opener wherever I need a can opened. Once the technique is mastered (doesn't take long) you can do a quick clean job and will trust no others. 8)
Thanks!

Yes, Victorinox makes some mean openers. Which is why so many companies have adopted the quarter-circle. But the Vics are the sharpest around.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

