'Les Stroud' Engage Multitool TEST TO DESTRUCTION!
-
@ColoSwiss said:
We were talking about using a SAK for a target over on the Break Room. How about blasting this for a finale?If I can find a place that I can do it, sure. Most indoor ranges won't allow this sort of thing, due to fear of ricochet.
Also. FIRESTEEL test, struck against the file.
Into Jute birdnest. Fail, but that was expected. In dryer lint, SUCCESS, after 3 strikes. -
Those... SMURFING... scissors.
Not intending to test them, but I tried to cut a thin bit of plastic with the scissors and struggled. Tried to cut the jute for the birdnest in the firestriker test, and had to spend fifteen seconds or so chewing through thin jute cord with those utterly fecal-failure scissors.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
We were talking about using a SAK for a target over on the Break Room. How about blasting this for a finale?
If I can find a place that I can do it, sure. Most indoor ranges won't allow this sort of thing, due to fear of ricochet.
Also. FIRESTEEL test, struck against the file.
Into Jute birdnest. Fail, but that was expected. In dryer lint, SUCCESS, after 3 strikes.That would make a brilliant finale if it's possible.
I would also like to know how fireproof it is. ;) -
Oh the horror!!! :D

-
The absolutely suck-tacular philips drive vs. a wood screw. This is NOT what I'd consider a torture test. The Tinker did it. The frickin' MICRA did it. To make this tool rotate that screw two full rotations tore a LOT of metal off this driver, jumped out about eight times, regardless of a lot of pressure on the tool, and despite BOTH the pressure AND the stupid bent design, the smurfing thing collapsed on me three times. WORST FAILURE POS EVER!!!


-
I think the only way to test it is to go out in the desert/bush/mountains etc. and survive for a few days using just that tool; do a Les. You will ofcourse need to video yourself for proof.
Build shelter, capture animals, fix equipment etc. :D -
Give a tribesman who's been using only the most basic Stone Age technology and he will keep it as a 'last resort' tool

-
The only word that comes to mind is...... pathetic.
-
Maybe it could be forge welded into a usefull knife. Na I like the idea of shooting it better. Who knows if the welds will even take its not like its high quality steel like you find digging at the scrapyard or lying on the side of the road.
-
I would like to see the "Tim Leatherman Nail Cutting Test". Is that possible?
-
Saw of some nice big branches and then baton them with the blade.
-
Some actual scissor testing.
Just to recap, in my initial review, I called these the worst scissors I'd ever tested left-handed.
</topic/51479
So, here they are, after cutting various paper materials.
Versus Paper: Right handed, pass. Left handed, FAIL. YOU FAILED PAPER!!!
Versus light cardboard (the yellow stuff): Right Handed, barely adequate. Left Handed... FAIL.
Versus Corrugated Cardbaord: Right Handed, barely adequate. Left Handed... you guessed it. FAIL.And the whole time, the spring kept popped out from behind the handle, ala what's seen in the pic.
I don't think I'm going to bother with more difficult materials, and skip right to test-to-destruction with these things.
So, how about the tool's scissors versus the tool's sheath? Okay, I tested it, and a number of other MTs, versus this tool's sheath. The Engage, Vic 91mm, Leatherman Wave, and the Mountain MT from Northern Freight (a $7 MT), in that order.

Huh... strange. I bet you can only see 3 cuts, can't you? That's because after 17 strokes of the scissors from the Engage, (maybe visible above the first real cut), the Engage managed what I'd describe as an abrasion. Then the SAK's cut, then the Wave, then the Mountain, which, to be fair took about four strokes to make its cut. And the SAK was one I got off of ebay for $6!

I hate these scissors so much on the Engage, I can't even put it into words. So... let's see what I can find to test them to destruction.
-
The requested Leatherman Nail Cut Test will interrupt the scissor testing for the moment.
Here's the Engage versus the Sidekick. I'm going to be honest. The Engage's cutters did the task, and took noticably less effort that the notoriously not-great anvil cutters of the Sidekick.

That's the GOOD news for the Engage. The bad?

Sorry for the blurry. See the 'shiny spot' at the base of the wire cutters? Yeah, there was some damage. None to the Sidekick
These were also pretty small nails. I'll get a larger on from the garage for further testing.
-
So... I went out into the garage, to get MORE nails.

Both the Engage and Sidekick cut through the trim nail.
Then I got to that roofing nail.
I had to press the Engage against the floor of the garage to generate enough force to cut the roofing nail, bit it DID IT... kind of.
The result is that now, when the handles are fully pressed together, the plier head doesn't close. FAIL!

And just so you all know, I ALSO cut the roofing nail with the Sidekick. The anvil cutters of the Sidekick required even more force than the Engage's. I was LITERALLY standing on the handle of the plier to push it closed. I was applying probably 150 lbs of force when the Sidekick cut the nail, and something more like 100 or less when the Engage cut through.There is absolutely ZERO damage to the Sidekick. While I would consider this test abusive, it also makes me REALLY appreciate how well the Sidekick is made. Not so much with the Engage.
I didn't bother trying the largest nail, since the Engage is pretty well done with any nail cutting, or fine plier work, from now on.
-
Question: Can you 'baton' a #2 pencil by sticking it into the scissors, and hitting the upper scissor blade with a hammer?
Answer: Yes.
These things are always good to know.

-
:D
The scissors seem slightly "out of shape"
-
This thread is great! Keep it up!
Also it's nice to hear the sidekick can take some abuse.

-
This is good. Need to find my snacks...
How about running it over with vehicle? >:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login