Can Opener Comparison
-
this is really extensive. thanks for the comparison. personally I feel more intuitive with SAK style can openers than with LM/Wenger style, but they all work. I wonder how you'd rank the openers on Bantam or Hunter
-
Victorinox Bantam
A familiar issue with this kind of design, this is not a true claw, lacking the piercing point that goes through the can top like nothing. Also, the edge is half the length of other claws, limiting each cut. Still, a better cutter than other non-claw combo tools, due to it being thinner. Great in the hand, and it did not slip. It did get stuck a couple of times, but it is thin enough to be retrieved with little effort.1 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
1 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 8

SOG PowerLock
Similar to the PPP. Good enough cutter, although rougher than other quarter-circles. This is a lot bulkier and its gears are larger, causing more discomfort.2 points for punching through.
0 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
1 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 7

Sheffield 10 in 1
Unable to hook on the can. When trying with the left hand, it just slips off the rim, without leaving the slightest dent into the can top.0 points.

-
@styx said:
this is really extensive. thanks for the comparison. personally I feel more intuitive with SAK style can openers than with LM/Wenger style, but they all work. I wonder how you'd rank the openers on Bantam or Hunter
I prefer Leatherman ones, but to each his own. But most of them are good enough.
I tried the Bantam, it's pretty good. I do not have a Hunter. Hopefully that will change someday. -
Hunter and Bantam have the same can opener. Leverage might be a factor though
-
-
Pending:
Surge, Signal, Sideclip. They share a can opener with others. Probably same results.
Victorinox 84, 93, 111, 130mm models. Maybe one won't slip.
Wenger 85mm and 120mm. These will be tested again, due to recent findings.
BuckTool. I will try and use this with my left hand, and see if it is any better. -
Excellent testing RM

-
Hunter and Bantam have the same can opener. Leverage might be a factor though
It's the same one? I thought the Hunter had a larger one.

You could be right. I'll take side by side pics when I get home
-
Excellent write up and investigation

You have to wonder at some of the cheaper companies including a tool that can't even be used!

-
Awesome comparisons RP...

Forgot if I tried to use the LM/Wenger can opener design, they cut in clockwise/backwards motion right? As opposed to the forward motion of Vic’s?
-
Great review, pics and work on this RP
Stuff like this gets overlooked sometimes and I miss threads like this completly
Glad I found this gem though

-
Thanks guys!

It's been a lot of fun. :D -
@magentus said:
Excellent write up and investigation
You have to wonder at some of the cheaper companies including a tool that can't even be used!

I guess they do not expect their tools to be used by those who buy them.

Not that you can call those cheapos collection pieces. Well, some people do, but still.Even good brands occasionally mess the can opener up. Look at the BuckTool.
-
@jaya_man said:
Awesome comparisons RP...
Forgot if I tried to use the LM/Wenger can opener design, they cut in clockwise/backwards motion right? As opposed to the forward motion of Vic’s?
Yes, Leatherman and Wenger claws are designed to go backwards, aka with the can staying still, you go clockwise as you cut. Or, you spin the can counter-clockwise as you cut.
With Victorinox and other quarter-circles, you go forward, so with the can staying still, you go counter-clockwise. Or, you spin the can clockwise as you cut.You can of course go in the opposite direction to the supposed right way for each design. Not as quick though.
-
-

A few familiar faces. Revisiting the Wenger Highlander and Buck BuckTool, and trying out two more quarter-circles from Victorinox, the Cadet and Farmer.

Note the excellent placement of the can opener on the Swiss Army Knives. And then there's the Buck.

-
**BuckTool **(left-handed)
Seeing how badly they placed the can opener on this, it almost looks like a left-handed can opener. Having used it right-handed, with terrible results, I thought I'd try left-handed.
A bit awkward to use the non-dominant hand, but it worked. Despite the awkwardness, slipping, jamming, and ghost cuts, it eventually worked, and much better than with my right hand.2 points for punching through. It hooks better onto the rim, since it is more to the right of the handle than to the left.
1 for comfort. The handles are nicely rounded, but then again, so is a pencil. It does not mean I can write with my left hand.
1 for not jamming. The nail-nick kept getting caught on the remnants of the edge on the wall of the can.
1 for cutting. Not every push yielded a cut. It kept slipping and jamming, delaying an already frustrating process.
1 for not slipping.
Total: 6

The can opener is commonly placed on the left-most side of the handle, allowing it to hook onto the rim, without having the left corner of the handle getting in the way. Ideally, the only thing touching the can will be the hook, under the rim, and the piercing point on the top of the can, right next to the rim. If a can opener is placed too far to the right of the handle, then the handle will get in the way of the hook, forcing the piercing point away from the rim.
Top: Leatherman Core & Wenger Highlander. Correct placement; the handle does not get in the way.
Bottom: BuckTool with right hand (barely hooking onto the rim) & BuckTool with left hand (not as bad, but I am not left-handed).

Wenger Highlander
Another surprising revisit, the Highlander claimed its place in the 'perfect 10' club. Rather than sinking the entire claw in the can, I was watching the harpoon barb closely, so it would not go past the top and get stuck. It worked wonders. I did not get stuck at all, while cutting consistently and cleanly. Perhaps slightly slower than I would have with a Leatherman claw, but still quick and easy enough not to remove any points. All it takes is to simply not jab the entire claw in the can.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

-
Victorinox Farmer
Identical can opener to the one on 91mm models. And identical performance. Nice, thin and properly sharpened edge, great ergonomics. No jamming, and a beautiful cut, with a little bit of slipping. Could it be the polished finish? Is the hook too rounded?
2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
1 for not slipping.
Total: 9

Victorinox Cadet
The identical design, just shrunk down a little. Surprisingly, this small difference in size worked in its favor, allowing for a consistent, clean cut, with no slipping whatsoever. I managed to stay on the rim of the can for the entirety of the cut. Excellent.2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.
Total: 10

-
could the slipping issue be due to hand size?
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login